Why Are People Blaming Jadeja Instead of Dhoni

[davidcooper]

If you're so sensitive that you need some individual to blame for this loss then maybe cricket isn't the sport for you. I recommend going to the ballet instead.

please type in english

[yoda]

I thought people were blaming Tendulkar. :giggle:

[jusarrived]

am surprised you are not blaming Kohli instead

[Chandan]

Because people say he is God and God can do anything

So you believe that he is not human but he is God? Had it been so, would India have lost a single match? Be a bit sane. He is a big genius and we should appreciate that. He has hit 3 centuries in last 10 innings that he has batted in. Which other Indian batsman has done that? No one. A single man can't do each and every job. That he did 9 out of 10 is our good luck and that man's genius.

[CSK Fan]

It was pressure if pressure can make SRT think out of the blue Jadeja is less than half of SRT. .

How exactly did pressure make Sachin think out of the blue? He was playing similar shots all across his innings. He hit a similar shot for 4 runs just 5 overs ago. I didnt see him changing his approach at all Dont you think its easier for a batsman who comes down at 4-5 to finsih things off than to one who has played 47 overs, scored 175 and is very tired and has done his job Pray tell me what this has to do with pressure Also, this has been one of Sachin's rare failures. Should I list Dhoni's many in similar situation? Care to tell me exactly how dhoni is better in 'such' situtation?

[Aaku]

Cause he is super stupid and immature. Nobody knew what he was trying to do ? Running around after every ball? :S And no blaming shlaming, it all just built up, cause he's consistently managed to perform GHETIYA. GETTT TYAAAGGGIIIII !

[Aaku]

am surprised you are not blaming Kohli instead

No, lets blame Kambli :nervous:

[The Outsider]

If u r playing for 47 overs' date=' u need to finish the game. You cannot leave it to tailenders. If we had batsman to come i don't blame him at all, but when he knew there is no specialist batsman after him then he needed to be there.[/quote'] Can you name one opener in ODI history who has finished the game chasing 275+? I'll help you, it was Bill Athey and he did it in a 55 over match. No one has done it in a 50 over game, ever.

[Little_Master]

no i don't blame Jadeja' date=' it was great sachin tendulkar. we needed 18 of 19 and he played a horrible shot, jadeja is a newcomer u cant blame. he wanted to take the strike but didnt judge the run and got runout. I blame Raina too, when he got out india needed 52 of 48 with powerplay remaining[/quote'] absolutely agree....the more i think abt it...the more i get pisssed off that sachin and raina committed such blunders:dash1::dash1:

[vvvslaxman]

absolutely agree....the more i think abt it...the more i get pisssed off that sachin and raina committed such blunders:dash1::dash1:

52 required in 48 balls.. Imagine Dhoni and Yuvi in that place? :winky: I bloody will bet a billion dollar India will win the match.

[Texy]

Jadeja is making mockery of selection....

[rkt.india]

Can you name one opener in ODI history who has finished the game chasing 275+? I'll help you' date=' it was Bill Athey and he did it in a 55 over match. No one has done it in a 50 over game, [b']ever.

I don't worry about what u say, but some guys here agree with me. I am not talking or taking anything from SRT away of his great innings but my only argument is if he had played 47 overs without any problem he should have stayed there till the end and only 18 balls were left with a few tailenders and records are there to made and he is the best person to make that record.

[rkt.india]

How exactly did pressure make Sachin think out of the blue? He was playing similar shots all across his innings. He hit a similar shot for 4 runs just 5 overs ago. I didnt see him changing his approach at all Dont you think its easier for a batsman who comes down at 4-5 to finsih things off than to one who has played 47 overs, scored 175 and is very tired and has done his job Pray tell me what this has to do with pressure Also, this has been one of Sachin's rare failures. Should I list Dhoni's many in similar situation? Care to tell me exactly how dhoni is better in 'such' situtation?

He did no play that kind of a shot against a forntline bowler, played mostly against spinner or Michael Hussey and he was playing Mackay carefully before that because he was bowling well. I was shocked when i saw him playing that shot. I was a suicidal shot when the match was in India's pocket, he just threw it away, it happens in pressure situation. I started all this here because its unfair to blame Jadeja for this loss when greater experienced batsman did not quite went through that pressure Jadeja is no where near a complete batsman. He was playing well and hit 3 4s and took the pressure off Sachin in the 46 over. In a loss whole team is to be blamed.

[rkt.india]

So you believe that he is not human but he is God? Had it been so, would India have lost a single match? Be a bit sane. He is a big genius and we should appreciate that. He has hit 3 centuries in last 10 innings that he has batted in. Which other Indian batsman has done that? No one. A single man can't do each and every job. That he did 9 out of 10 is our good luck and that man's genius.

I don't make any human being to be God, but people here in ICF says it. Please don't make human beings God in any field, treat human as a human.

[The Outsider]

I don't worry about what u say' date=' but some guys here agree with me. I am not talking or taking anything from SRT away of his great innings but my only argument is if he had played 47 overs without any problem he should have stayed there till the end and only 18 balls were left with a few tailenders and records are there to made and he is the best person to make that record.[/quote'] So, according to you no amount of physical and mental fatigue sets in during scoring 175 runs in a 350 chase that you are trivializing it to 19 off 18 deliveries? If that were the case would we not have seen at least one instance of a batsman carrying his bat through in a 275 run chase, forget about 350? The Modus Operandi of people like you is to have superhuman expectations from him and then blame others for being worshipers when he does not fulfill your wet dreams.

[rkt.india]

So, according to you no amount of physical and mental fatigue sets in during scoring 175 runs in a 350 chase that you are trivializing it to 19 off 18 deliveries? If that were the case would we not have seen at least one instance of a batsman carrying his bat through in a 275 run chase, forget about 350? The Modus Operandi of people like you is to have superhuman expectations from him and then blame others for being worshipers when he does not fulfill your wet dreams.

You are wrong I do not make him God or believe anything superhuman from him. I was just making my point. I was trying to say that he is not a superhuman, don't make him God as many posters here calls him God. You talk about fatigue. He was not looking fatigued at all. It wasn't a very hot day at all. It was just concentration problem at that time. He played a great innings without blemish, just played 1 unnecessary shot in motion and then disappointed himself more than others.

[The Outsider]

You are wrong I do not make him God or believe anything superhuman from him. I was just making my point. I was trying to say that he is not a superhuman' date=' don't make him God as many posters here calls him God. You talk about fatigue. He was not looking fatigued at all. It wasn't a very hot day at all. It was just concentration problem at that time. He played a great innings without blemish, just played 1 unnecessary shot in motion and then disappointed himself more than others.[/quote'] Yeah, he was probably taking his gloves off and shaking his hands to jerk off?

[Dravid]

as useless as they come... even more useless then bb.. goli maardeni chahiye saale ko...

[rkt.india]

as useless as they come... even more useless then bb.. goli maardeni chahiye saale ko...

Its not very easy to accept the truth mate. I am not blaming him for the loss completely, but i think it should be balanced. He won't become a lesser player for anyone's saying. He does not need to prove anything to anyone, but i talked about this specific occasion. If any other player was there then i would have blamed that player. I am not saying anything specifically against SRT and his honor. I just want to see India win matches, don't lose games from the pocket. Sorry guys, if i said anything wrong in the honor of SRT and for me every player is as valuable as anyone whether it is Jadeja, SRT, or MSD. I don't think any player is bigger or special than the team and do not see them with different perceptions.