rkt.india Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 In a tournament like this i would rather have RP or Ishant. Who can move the ball unlike Dinda. But Dinda can be used as a good death bowler. He is much beter death bowler than many of our best. Still he shouldnt have been picked. I wud have Mishra in place of Aswin, Pandey in place of Tiwary. IPL sux now. every player need to be given a role in the thts why i thik tiwary is chosen as a lower order hitter rather up the order batsman here...unlike pandey who is a not a hitter as we dont have any big hitter lower down the order in this squad as Yuraj is out and Dhoni is becming dravid now a days we have kohli and rohit who takes time to settle before hitting
Lord Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 I Have already we i wud prefer genuine bowler or a batsman. We don need bits andd pieces player. We need a genuine bowler. Which is not Irfan. n who is that genuine bowler.is there anyone who u can trust to take wickets
Andy Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 every player need to be given a role in the thts why i thik tiwary is chosen as a lower order hitter rather up the order batsman here...unlike pandey who is a not a hitter as we dont have any big hitter lower down the order in this squad as Yuraj is out and Dhoni is becming dravid now a days we have kohli and rohit who takes time to settle before hitting I dont have any problem with tiwary. But it seems all players have been chosen on IPL performance, which is a wrong scale, given our prior results.
Andy Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 n who is that genuine bowler.is there anyone who u can trust to take wickets No not really, some rookie could have got a chance, remember how Ishant, RP, Zak, Pathan did when they were new?
Gunner_Mania Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Even BD will fancy to beat us in every match now... :hatsoff:
Lord Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 No not really' date=' some rookie could have got a chance, remember how Ishant, RP, Zak, Pathan did when they were new?[/quote'] Dinda got his chance in Zim.he did okay. wat i want is balance in the side.in a nutshell i dont want Jadeja batting at no.7 for us
Andy Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Dinda got his chance in Zim.he did okay. wat i want is balance in the side.in a nutshell i dont want Jadeja batting at no.7 for us Irfan beter than Jadeja, anyday.
King Tendulkar Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 see i want to play 2 attacking offies in Ojha n Ashwin/Bhajji.that means we need a pacer who can bat at 7.Irfan fits the bill perfectly.its not like other bowlers r taking wickets by heaps.they r crap as well atleast Irfan lends balance.wat we r playing now is 2 darters n 3 crap pacers,now doubt teams regularly score 300 against us I understand the desire for balance. But crapthans bowling is poor and frankly so is his batting. His batting is so over hyped, he is worse as a batsman then Jadeja and Y Pathan. We should dispense with this idea of an all rounder until we find one that is actually good. Jadeja seems the best of the bunch in all rounder category
King Tendulkar Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Dinda got his chance in Zim.he did okay. wat i want is balance in the side.in a nutshell i dont want Jadeja batting at no.7 for us What and you want crapthan batting at 7?? Pathans batting is vastly over rated, in the crappy batsman all rounder role , Jadeja is better
asterix Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 I'm asking for Irfans inclusion because he can bat decently down the order and can do no worse than Dinda etc. in bowling. I can't see the utility of Dinda. He is a mediocre bowler and will always remain mediocre.. I would advice Irfan to switch to spin bowling. With his current pace, it will not be too difficult. Then he can even replace that Bhikhari malnutritious Jadeja. Jadeja has the potential to ruin important matches (he has done it regularly and actually has made a career of it). lol at the suggestion that Jadeja is better bat than Irfan.. Irfan has even opend the innings. Jadeja will crap from his malnutritious **** if asked to open the innings..
Lord Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 I understand the desire for balance. But crapthans bowling is poor and frankly so is his batting. His batting is so over hyped' date= he is worse as a batsman then Jadeja and Y Pathan. We should dispense with this idea of an all rounder until we find one that is actually good. Jadeja seems the best of the bunch in all rounder category thats BS.Irfan has done very well as a lower order bat.has a test ton too. i dont think we can dispense with looking for an allrounder.it is a must in an ODI team.we cant play with only 4 bowlers n part timers
rkt.india Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 I dont have any problem with tiwary. But it seems all players have been chosen on IPL performance' date=' which is a wrong scale, given our prior results.[/quote'] Tiwary had a first class average of 98 in last year ranji season....he is one of the youngest captain in domestic circle....
Andy Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Tiwary had a first class average of 98 in last year ranji season....he is one of the youngest captain in domestic circle.... But technically he looks so poor. Anyways didnt know that he has good domestic performance.
Gunner_Mania Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Sehwag, Gambir,Dhoni, Raina, Rohit,Kohli, Harbhajan,Zaheer,Nehra,Praveen. That leaves one slot open. Why would we need another batsman there? Ashwin/Ojha Doesn't that look like a balanced side?
King Tendulkar Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 thats BS.Irfan has done very well as a lower order bat.has a test ton too. i dont think we can dispense with looking for an allrounder.it is a must in an ODI team.we cant play with only 4 bowlers n part timers Let Bhaji play as all rounder. Or even Yuvi!! Yuvis bowling is probably better thgen Crapthans, and I know who the better bat is! How people can call pathan an all rounder when his bowling is dreadful is beyond me. At least malnourished Jadeja can at times keep it tight
King Tendulkar Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Tiwary had a first class average of 98 in last year ranji season....he is one of the youngest captain in domestic circle.... Those were in the plate though. I must say terchnically he looks very average. But does have stats to back him
asterix Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Sehwag' date=' Gambir,Dhoni, Raina, Rohit,Kohli, Harbhajan,Zaheer,Nehra,Praveen. That leaves one slot open. Why would we need another batsman there? Ashwin/Ojha Doesn't that look like a balanced side?[/quote'] Because India' strength is batting and need a good hitter down the order. India cannot win matches depending upon bored bowlers like Zaheer, Bhajji and angry bowlers like PK & Nehra..These bowlers have so much of attitude filled in them that they can't be relied upon. Hence we need a team which has a useful batting line up.
rkt.india Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 But technically he looks so poor. Anyways didnt know that he has good domestic performance. technique is not the only guarantee to the success...otherwise Akash Chopra would have been One of India's greatest batsman...its how u score runs...like Sehwag
Lord Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Let Bhaji play as all rounder. Or even Yuvi!! Yuvis bowling is probably better thgen Crapthans, and I know who the better bat is! How people can call pathan an all rounder when his bowling is dreadful is beyond me. At least malnourished Jadeja can at times keep it tight Jadeja is one dimensional.he cant slog in end overs unles he has 20 overs to get set.n is a darter while bowling. Irfan last played for Ind in T20WC 2009.so i dont know what makes u think Jadeja is better bowler than him.we havent seen Irfan at all
rkt.india Posted June 7, 2010 Posted June 7, 2010 Those were in the plate though. I must say technically he looks very average. But does have stats to back him technique does not always matter..its temperament where he looks good
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now