Dhoni was sacked and Kohli Was made Captain:Mohinder Amarnath

[Pagalpanti]

Being a Dhoni fan' date=' why dont you replace the first letter of your handle with a 'D'? But you wont because you are NUMB[/quote'] Get a sarcasm detector.

[hhunaeh]

It is like a coup is being attempted sensing the weakness of the current elite with no concern for the next test's result.

[CG]

If it was an unanimous decision which was over-ridden by Srini, why wasn't nothing said earlier? Does Srini have the right to over-ride decisions made my the selectors, the people who've been hired to pick the side? If he does have that power, then either get the 'rules' changed or carry on doing what your job is. If he doesn't have the power, then they should've challenged Srini.

Yes Bcci constitution gives power to chairman to override and when selectors made the move they were shown the constitution.But when they were appointed there was clarification about the matter.

[hhunaeh]

setting one player against another in public before an important test . It looks like he wants us loose.

[Lord]

setting one player against another in public before an important test . It looks like he wants us loose.

yep hes on ECB's payroll:cantstop:

[CG]

:hatsoff::hatsoff: Jimmy .Bcci may even now cancel His 1 time benefit of 1 crore rs.Kudos to him for having the courage to speak up

[Raghav_12]

Get a sarcasm detector.

He proved himself to be DUMB while talking to NUMB :hysterical:

[Sachinism]

Yes Bcci constitution gives power to chairman to override and when selectors made the move they were shown the constitution.But when they were appointed there was clarification about the matter.

Well it is something that should have been made clear. Anyways if its in the constitution, then you can't disagree with Srini over-riding anything. I'm not saying its right, far from it actually and ideally that needs to be changed A.S.A.P. but for the moment, it is there.

yep hes on ECB's payroll:cantstop:

The way he has brought this to the fore, shows he's not that concerned about Indian cricket. He couldn't have waited a week? Him bringing this out, can't have a positive effect on the side.

[Lord]

The way he has brought this to the fore, shows he's not that concerned about Indian cricket. He couldn't have waited a week? Him bringing this out, can't have a positive effect on the side.

what would a week's wait would hv done,another Test loss?

[Sachinism]

what would a week's wait would hv done' date='another Test loss?[/quote'] Please explain what positive effect this will have. You think him ranting is going to win us the test match? There are already so many issues the team is dealing with. Him ranting is not going to change any of those, nor will Dhoni be replaced as captain for the 4th test. So what does he achieve by bringing this out 2 days before a must-win test match?

[Lord]

Please explain what positive effect this will have. You think him ranting is going to win us the test match?

no,it'll cause BCCI to act n make changes they wouldnt have.nothing wrong with timing imo except naming Kohli

[diga]

He prove himself to be DUMB while talking to NUMB :hysterical:

my bad ...:facepalm:

[diga]

Please explain what positive effect this will have. You think him ranting is going to win us the test match?

better now than never ???

[King Khan]

This news must be very upsetting for Dhoni, for being zero confidence-captain from selectors all these time after 8-0. More importantly its must be dissapointing for Kohli (the future captain) for being sided by hypocryte heads of team & board, by now India could 've face England with more moral & mental strength after at least beating NZ. Who knows maybe under Kohli's captaincy Indian could have aquire the Asia cup as well.

[Sachinism]

no' date='it'll cause BCCI to act n make changes they wouldnt have.nothing wrong with timing imo except naming Kohli[/quote'] So he had to come out with this right now? If he brought this up next week everyone wouldn't have took notice? After the 8-0 hammering, if he brought this up then, people wouldn't have listened? Its inconvenient.

[CG]

So he had to come out with this right now? If he brought this up next week everyone wouldn't have took notice? After the 8-0 hammering, if he brought this up then, people wouldn't have listened? Its inconvenient.

He was asked in the ceat show i think .Even after 2 whitewashes bcci and dhoni and team came up with Dekh lenge India mein tumko and media also did not go after dhoni and atmosphere was still to persist with dhoni whihc was shocking in away.But now as england ne india ke pungi bajaa de hai captaincy debate is on.

[Lord]

So he had to come out with this right now? If he brought this up next week everyone wouldn't have took notice? After the 8-0 hammering, if he brought this up then, people wouldn't have listened? Its inconvenient.

whats wrong with bringing it out now?its not inconvenient at all he was still selector during 8-0 obviously couldnt speak then

[hhunaeh]

Ayaz menon on twitter. The moderator of Bat & Chat discussion organised by Ceat.

Amarnath erupted in a Bat & Chat discussion organised by Ceat in Pune which I moderated. Surprised everyone. V'sarkar was other participant Jimmy Amarnath may have very good reason to be miffed: but is his ire directed at Dhoni or the BCCI I wonder

[hhunaeh]

Even the host ayaz menon doubts jimmy's intentions

[Sachinism]

whats wrong with bringing it out now?its not inconvenient at all he was still selector during 8-0 obviously couldnt speak then

Its the middle of a test series. With 1 test to go, a must-win test, we already have enough problems to deal with. There is no way he's going to be dropped as captain before this test match and as a selector he should understand that. So I wonder what his reasons are.... He couldn't speak up when he was a selector?! :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical: So what the heck was he being paid to do? Pretty convenient he collects his cheque and then speaks about matters which he was hired to deal with.