Jump to content

Do we really need a dinesh karthik ?


Rob9

Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't care about stats. Ashwin is pretty mediocre. What are his numbers against sides apart from the lankans? His fielding is mediocre and his batting as well. case dismissed

Posted
I don't care about stats. Ashwin is pretty mediocre. What are his numbers against sides apart from the lankans? His fielding is mediocre and his batting as well. case dismissed
:confused:
Posted
:hysterical:
what's so funny dude? gambhir is a great ODI batsmen and has lot more years of cricket left in him. He's far better than karthik or other batsmen one could consider to walk in
Posted
yes we should persist with gambhir and UV over the other better options just because they have already played ? if this thread is to defend gambhir and UV then this thread is as useless as DK
They have not only played but are match winners and great players. It's not like we are talking about an aged bunch of experienced lot. Yuvi and gauti are still young. I agree that they were dropped on basis of poor form lately. But if it's about earning a place back, please compare their performances with so called Karthiks - badrinath's, vijay's, raydu's or even manoj tiwary. I am sure Gambhir and Yuvraj deserve a chance to return if they go well in domestic.
Posted
what's so funny dude? gambhir is a great ODI batsmen and has lot more years of cricket left in him. He's far better than karthik or other batsmen one could consider to walk in
Its typical dude. They have a go at Gambhir due to his form but blame it on his attitude whereas Kohli has had a much worse attitude lately. Pretty hypocrite to admit that. Gambhir had no comments on Kohli's captaincy has been turned into a rude "comment". LOL
Posted
well. we do need a second keeper as wel in the team. he fits multiple roles and is a good fielder as well
Yeah, but Raina has been decent. Karthik is back to getting stars and losing it later on. Much better player than that. I would him give him a series or two more, these pitches aren't suited for DK.
Posted
Yeah, but Raina has been decent. Karthik is back to getting stars and losing it later on. Much better player than that. I would him give him a series or two more, these pitches aren't suited for DK.
still **** away from home dude...... averaged below 30 in both champions trophy and celkon cup
Posted
Yeah, but Raina has been decent. Karthik is back to getting stars and losing it later on. Much better player than that. I would him give him a series or two more, these pitches aren't suited for DK.
raina is fine but is taking his place for granted
Posted
still **** away from home dude...... averaged below 30 in both champions trophy and celkon cup
He did well in England the last time. He rarely got any chance in the middle order during the CT, like Dhoni. He played some half decent knocks here and yes, he has got to improve.
raina is fine but is taking his place for granted
He will get dropped if he fails in a series or two. The last players; Gambhir & Sehwag, took their place for granted were dropped by Patel and Co.
Posted
what's so funny dude? gambhir is a great ODI batsmen and has lot more years of cricket left in him. He's far better than karthik or other batsmen one could consider to walk in
Gambhir is a decent ODI batsman and had a good year in 2010. But calling him a great is lol worthy. I used to like watching him bat during that year when he hit a purple patch, but the way he started poking outside off after that made it embarrassing to watch.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...