vishalvirsingh Posted January 4, 2014 Posted January 4, 2014 Binny is a good powerful batsman .and an intelligent bowler but a trundler hence if he does not manage his bowling he wd be dumped
Vijy Posted January 4, 2014 Posted January 4, 2014 Binny is a true bits-and-pieces player. Since Jaddu is doing well as an all-rounder, I don't see any place for Binny in the team, unless he replaces one of the main bowlers. Ideally, we should look for a second all-rounder who is reliable with the ball and can score a quickfire 20-25 with the bat; Jaddu has an avg of 30+ but his SR isn't that high. If only YK had developed his bowling and batting sufficiently, we could have played them both.
Old guy Posted January 4, 2014 Posted January 4, 2014 that was one ODI,no.didnt play test IIRC as I said can be great in ODIs as for commies,they though Ishant was great selection in SA due to height:cantstop: Binny is a true bits-and-pieces player. Since Jaddu is doing well as an all-rounder' date=' I don't see any place for Binny in the team, unless he replaces one of the main bowlers. Ideally, we should look for a second all-rounder who is reliable with the ball and can score a quickfire 20-25 with the bat; Jaddu has an avg of 30+ but his SR isn't that high. If only YK had developed his bowling and batting sufficiently, we could have played them both.[/quote'] Worst case scenario...Raina bats at 4. Binny at 5 Best case rahane bats at 4 and Rayadu at 5 with both Raina and Binny out
Vijy Posted January 4, 2014 Posted January 4, 2014 Worst case scenario...Raina bats at 4. Binny at 5 Best case rahane bats at 4 and Rayadu at 5 with both Raina and Binny out Agree mostly with above. In place of Rayudu, I'd still go with Raina. He averaged 35 in 2013 which isn't too bad, and Rayudu didn't look very convincing in the Zim series. Raina deserves one more overseas series, esp in NZ snce the conditions are somewhat similar to Oz. He is a slightly better fielder than Rayudu and can bowl a bit too, and his overall record isn't too bad. Mind you, I don't advocate his selection forever, but only during this one series to see what he performs like.
Old guy Posted January 4, 2014 Posted January 4, 2014 Agree mostly with above. In place of Rayudu' date=' I'd still go with Raina. He averaged 35 in 2013 which isn't too bad, and Rayudu didn't look very convincing in the Zim series. Raina deserves one more overseas series, esp in NZ snce the conditions are somewhat similar to Oz. He is a slightly better fielder than Rayudu and can bowl a bit too, and his overall record isn't too bad. Mind you, I don't advocate his selection forever, but only during this one series to see what he performs like.[/quote'] Well I really like Rayadu before judging him we both need to watch him more :two_thumbs_up: Problem with Raina is he is sure flop in Australia and bowling would be useless there too while Rayadu can probably do well in such conditions from what I have seen
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now