Jump to content

ATG India ODI XI vs ATG Pakistan ODI XI - Who will win ?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Mother of all contest 

Series - Bilateral (since India has swept of all in world tournaments so no point of that )

 

ATG PAK XI

  1. Anwar
  2. Afridi
  3. Babar Azam/ Zaheer abbas
  4. Miandad
  5. Inzy 
  6. Imran 
  7. Razzaq
  8. Sarfraz (WK)
  9. Wasim
  10. Saqlain
  11. Waqar

12th man- Akthar

 

 

ATG India XI

  1. Rohit
  2. Sachin
  3. Kohli 
  4. Gambhir 
  5. Yuvi
  6. Dhoni 
  7. Kapil
  8. Kuldeep yadav
  9. Shami
  10. Zak
  11. Bumrah

12th man - kumble 

 

  • Picked gambhir to counter Saqlain n neways he gets senti when it pakistan which is good as he wud be extra motivated. 
  • Kuldeep - coz pakistan has historically struggled against wrist spin

 

 

Pakistan generally pulled their game up against India so who will win ???

Edited by Ankit_sharma03
Posted
  • India has massive advantage in fielding 
  • India top 3 are better
  • Wasim vs Rohit wud be intersting as Rohit had issues with incoming ball but if im not wrong he did fix this issue last Asia cup n hasnt gotten out like that again. 
  • Kohli vs Saqlain- Kohli did play ajmal with ease in the same game where rohit n sachin werent picking him up so i think he shud be able to manage saqlain 
  • Bumrah vs Razzaq- It ll be fun to watch , but i do say i had respect for razzaq how he use to play pacers at death
  • Anwar vs this attack - Saeed anwar was our nightmare and it ll be fun to watch how he plays this attack . 
  • Sledging- That pakistan side had an aura but so does many Modern indian player 
Posted
3 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Zaheer Abbas in ODI. It's like picking Pujara in ODI.

zaheer abbas had a S/r of 84 in ODI and avg of 47 , that is a bloody good s/r for that era . 

 

ganguly s/r is 73

dravid 71

gambhir 85 

 

So how is it like pujara 

Posted
Just now, Ankit_sharma03 said:

zaheer abbas had a S/r of 84 in ODI and avg of 47 , that is a bloody good s/r for that era . 

 

ganguly s/r is 73

dravid 71

gambhir 85 

 

So how is it like pujara 

 Neither would i have Ganguly or Dravid or Gambo in ODI as well.

Posted
16 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Zaheer Abbas in ODI. It's like picking Pujara in ODI.

Abbas was a great ODI bat, a trendsetter. Overrated in tests but in ODIs only the King was better (by a mile) in that era. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Gollum said:

Abbas was a great ODI bat, a trendsetter. Overrated in tests but in ODIs only the King was better (by a mile) in that era. 

He was good for his era but Pak have much better players who can make use of ODI restrictions better than him.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Anwar

Fakhar Zaman

Babar Azam

Miandad

Shoaib Malik

Afridi

Sarfraz Khan

Akram

Waqar

Saqlain

Akhtar

 

jijaji malik was a huge temptation as he always did well against us but not ahead of Inzy for sure.

Fakhar zaman - Zak use to eat such left handers for dinner at his peak 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

He was good for his era but Pak have much better players who can make use of ODI restrictions better than him.

all good players adapt....had those guys had to play in todays era even they wud have developed their games acc

Pak best batsman babar azam in this era s/r 87 and that guy in his era had 84 

Posted
17 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Sehwag

Sharma

Sachin

Kohli

Yuvi

Dhoni

Kapil

Ashwin

Shami

Kuldeep

Bumrah

 

 

 

 

i wont take sehwag, sehwag had a huge issue of left handers ball coming back in . Bracken, vaas had fun exploiting it and sehwag himself confessed how he feared facing wasim in 2003 Wc game coz of his issue . Rohit atleast has ironed that issue out n worked on his stance. 

Ill pick dhawan, ganguly over him. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

jijaji malik was a huge temptation as he always did well against us but not ahead of Inzy for sure.

Fakhar zaman - Zak use to eat such left handers for dinner at his peak 

Every player gets out. What matters in ODI  is how many runs a batsman scores and at what strike rate. Zaman may get out like a clown one day but he is one of their best bat with the new rules. Shame they are playing the tortoise Imam-Ul-Haq.

Posted
21 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Sehwag

Sharma

Sachin

Kohli

 

Sachin avg 10.22 at 3 position in 10 games, why wud u send ur best batsman at that position. Even kohli avg better at 3 then 4

So u changed position of 2 of ur best batsman 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

i wont take sehwag, sehwag had a huge issue of left handers ball coming back in . Bracken, vaas had fun exploiting it and sehwag himself confessed how he feared facing wasim in 2003 Wc game coz of his issue . Rohit atleast has ironed that issue out n worked on his stance. 

Ill pick dhawan, ganguly over him. 

Every player has issues. By that logic you cannot pick anyone.

Posted
29 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

 Neither would i have Ganguly or Dravid or Gambo in ODI as well.

You wouldnt have Gambhir? One of the greatest clutch players India have had.

Sehwag was too inconsistent, despite his good SR

Posted
1 minute ago, Straight Drive said:

Every player gets out. What matters in ODI  is how many runs a batsman scores and at what strike rate. Zaman may get out like a clown one day but he is one of their best bat with the new rules. Shame they are playing the tortoise Imam-Ul-Haq.

their best choice sharjeel is out due to fixing , kamran is good enough to play as batsman but where wud u hide him in the field

I think they have a new batsman righty now

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, Straight Drive said:

Every player has issues. By that logic you cannot pick anyone.

 

yes but he was an underachiever in ODI, even dhawan has issue but he has very good ODI career. Picking someone who has issues and done great is understandable but someone who underachieved and then it changes position of 2 of our best batsman

 

 

On the show of 'What the Duck' hosted by Vikram Sathaye, Sehwag revealed how Sachin Tendulkar pulled Sehwag's leg all the time by suddenly taking the strike to face Wasim Akram.

Sehwag did not want to face the left-arm pacer because in earlier matches he went out to Chaminda Vaas and Nathan Bracken.  The Nawab of Najafgarh has revealed how he requested Sachin Tendulkar to take the strike early on but he refused. 

Pakistan had posted 274 runs in the first innings to which Sachin and Sehwag provided an early start to the team with hitting boundaries to the Wasim Akram.

During the first innings, Tendulkar had kept rejecting Sehwag's offer only to suddenly walk up to striker's end and face deadly Wasim Akram. Sachin went on to take a single on the first ball and Virender Sehwag was back on the crease with insisting him to take quick singles even if the ball goes to the wicket-keeper.

"The story is, we were fielding first, so entire 50 overs I was telling him, Wasim Akram will bowl the first over. And I was so bad with left-arm fast bowlers that I, in the past, had gotten out to Akram, Chaminda Vaas and Nathan Bracken in the first ball," Sehwag said during the chat show of What the Duck.

 

 

 

 

Edited by Ankit_sharma03
Posted
44 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Mother of all contest 

Series - Bilateral (since India has swept of all in world tournaments so no point of that )

 

ATG PAK XI

  1. Anwar
  2. Afridi
  3. Babar Azam/ Zaheer abbas
  4. Miandad
  5. Inzy 
  6. Imran 
  7. Razzaq
  8. Sarfraz (WK)
  9. Wasim
  10. Saqlain
  11. Waqar

12th man- Akthar

 

 

ATG India XI

  1. Rohit
  2. Sachin
  3. Kohli 
  4. Gambhir 
  5. Yuvi
  6. Dhoni 
  7. Kapil
  8. Kuldeep yadav
  9. Shami
  10. Zak
  11. Bumrah

12th man - kumble 

 

  • Picked gambhir to counter Saqlain n neways he gets senti when it pakistan which is good as he wud be extra motivated. 
  • Kuldeep - coz pakistan has historically struggled against wrist spin

 

 

Pakistan generally pulled their game up against India so who will win ???

I dont think it should be a choice between Zaheer and Babar, ideally fit both in- possibly even at Miandads expense, though that is controversial. I also dont like Afridi opening, against other "ATG" new ball attacks he would be easy pickings. Ramiz or Harsh Thakors favourite to open?

 

Majid Khan, Saeed Anwar, Babar, Zaheer, Inzy, Imran, Sarfaraz, Afridi, Wasim, Waqar, Saqlain

 

issue is only 6 bowlers...

 

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...