Jump to content

Done with the old, bring in the new?


Texan

Recommended Posts

52 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

even when biggies were avl , remember that game where akila dananjya ran through us- a washed up dhoni n bhuvi won us the game , bhuvi was the dominating one in that

U think tailenders havent won games when biggies have played

Two things:

1. We won that series 3-0 not 2-1

2. SriLanka were playing there best team where players like Mathews, Dickwella, Mendis, Perea, Malinga, Fernando were all there, we all know that our youngsters played against SRL C. 

So basically the two scenarios are not comparable. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, New guy said:

That might be fantasy but truth is that we havent won wc for 14 years with seniors P.S. take a look at t20 winners in last decade and see who match winners were 

If we are making conclusions like these then I would add one more thing:

We haven't won a single t20 WC since IPL started, surely IPL is degrading the quality of our players. 

 

On topic, the seniors of that era had no clue how to play t20 as they were playing since early 90s, thats the reason they stepped out of t20 WC. 

Imagine Dravid, Laxman, Ganguly playing in a t20 WC lol. The scenarios are hardly comparable. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, Adamant said:

Two things:

1. We won that series 3-0 not 2-1

2. SriLanka were playing there best team where players like Mathews, Dickwella, Mendis, Perea, Malinga, Fernando were all there, we all know that our youngsters played against SRL C. 

So basically the two scenarios are not comparable. 

So SL were C and we were ?

We lost t20 series after barely making an eleven to take the field out of which one was just making a number,it was an Indian D/E that too 10 men,Saini didn't even bowl came out to bat,and last i heard he hasn't been playing all his cricket as batsman

We all know in normal circumstances we would have won both legs,you can't dismiss our younger lot due to that failure especially not after how they fated against Australia in Australia, each one of them is capable

T20WC may not be the right place suddenly,but things need to be changed asap after this WC

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Suhaan said:

So SL were C and we were ?

We lost t20 series after barely making an eleven to take the field out of which one was just making a number,it was an Indian D/E that too 10 men,Saini didn't even bowl came out to bat,and last i heard he hasn't been playing all his cricket as batsman

We all know in normal circumstances we would have won both legs,you can't dismiss our younger lot due to that failure especially not after how they fated against Australia in Australia, each one of them is capable

T20WC may not be the right place suddenly,but things need to be changed asap after this WC

Who said that these youngsters aren't good? It's just that they need more time and they should be mixed up with some experienced guys to strengthen the team. 

The thread topic is suggesting that these youngsters are currently good enough to replace the main players which is hogwash. If they can't even beat a SRL C convincingly how will they be able to face top teams. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Adamant said:

Two things:

1. We won that series 3-0 not 2-1

2. SriLanka were playing there best team where players like Mathews, Dickwella, Mendis, Perea, Malinga, Fernando were all there, we all know that our youngsters played against SRL C. 

So basically the two scenarios are not comparable. 

who is good apart frm malinga who basically was at his end 

Matthews has been poor for ages 

Perera to aaj tak consistent nhin hua

 

Point was even that biggies needed tail n washed up guy to save. In history of cricket ull see tail saving many big sides

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Adamant said:

Who said that these youngsters aren't good? It's just that they need more time and they should be mixed up with some experienced guys to strengthen the team. 

 

time for what ??? Rocket launch krna hai

People are at both extreme- some want all youngsters and somewant all experienced 

It shud be a mix of both (more importantly right kind of player constructing a right side)

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Adamant said:

Who said that these youngsters aren't good? It's just that they need more time and they should be mixed up with some experienced guys to strengthen the team. 

The thread topic is suggesting that these youngsters are currently good enough to replace the main players which is hogwash. If they can't even beat a SRL C convincingly how will they be able to face top teams. 

OP is not saying play them in UAE WC, he's talking about near future,players tke time to gel together

Even if you make an IPLt20 xi from last two years out of Indian youngsters and give them a fair run of 20 games they will become a top side eventually

Edited by Suhaan
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

time for what ??? Rocket launch krna hai

People are at both extreme- some want all youngsters and somewant all experienced 

It shud be a mix of both (more importantly right kind of player constructing a right side)

 

 

We already have a good mix of youngsters and experience 

 

Rohit and Kohli are the only two batsman above 30. 

Kise drop karoge on these pitches? 

Rahul is 29, pant 23, sky 28, Pandya 27

Kishan 23.

I think that's a good mix of experience and young blood. 

What more do you want. Lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, QuarantineTormentino said:

Venky Iyer should be considered as well, can prove to be our Watto. Dube can be monitored, seemed to have turned a new leaf yesterday

He is bloody good man. Look up his ranji performances. He is a stud. He needs to be groomed. 

 

People write these guys off too quickly. 

 

Watch jasiwal explode soon 

 

Like I said earlier, India just. Bloody needs to pick the correct team. They can win all tournaments in every format. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Adamant said:

 

We already have a good mix of youngsters and experience 

 

Rohit and Kohli are the only two batsman above 30. 

Kise drop karoge on these pitches? 

Rahul is 29, pant 23, sky 28, Pandya 27

Kishan 23.

I think that's a good mix of experience and young blood. 

What more do you want. Lol

 

i dnt hve much issue with this side apart from captaincy 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...