Jump to content

How many current players would make it to our All-time Indian Test XI?


Vijy

Recommended Posts

Posted
4 minutes ago, R!TTER said:

You do know who judges man of the match or man of the series right? Can you tell me Ashwin's stats in Oz, or SA, pre 2018? What is good for the goose if afterall great for the gander as well :--D

 

Like on the three spin friendly tracks Eng faced earlier in the year, or Mumbai vs NZ? Do you want me to pull stats for Axar in those games :cantstop:

 

Tell me which series he deserved man of the series lol If Jadeja was like turning up winning matches for India with his bowling overseas you have a point lol  Hey this guy is average. but the other guy is less average haha

Posted
8 minutes ago, sarchasm said:

Imagine arguing with this idiot claiming DRS has benefitted batsman as much as bowlers.

 

It's objectively proven that bowlers - especially finger spinners - have benefited the most from DRS.

 

Ashwin in any other era would be a 35 averaging bowler.

 

 

You can't come up with individual dismissal lol Just google "DRs benefitted batsman" hey i have found one. 

Posted

None of our spinners bar chandra contributed to overseas win significantly. Yea one is slightly better than the other due to type of bowling. Mostly seamers did the damage.  Somehow this SENA worshippig has gone to a new level. Taking wicket of Phil tufnell is way more precious than dismissing cook in India lol

Posted
1 minute ago, sarchasm said:

 

Repeat after me. DRS has meant finger spinners are getting a LOT more LBWs than they did in the era before it. Ergo, Ashwin's average would go up, and his wicket count will come down if there were no DRS.

 

Are you struggling with it still?

 

You have no proof unless you come up with how many such wickets he benefitted because of that. Comprende. I am sure you are not smart enough delve into stats. Try googling some more. 

Posted
Just now, sarchasm said:

 

What did you find, then? Go on, show me a single data based analysis that says finger spinners did not benefit from DRS.

 

No you are the one claiming. I am not. So show the stats.

Posted
11 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

If Jadeja was like turning up winning matches for India with his bowling overseas you have a point lol 

Which series has Ashwin deserved to be MoS overseas & don't bring up minnows WI or SL :hmpf:

Posted
1 minute ago, R!TTER said:

Which series has Ashwin deserved to be MoS overseas & don't bring up minnows WI or SL :hmpf:

 

Well if you discount teams bumrah's west indies blitz should also be discredited.  In SENA Jadeja won man of the match? lol Even at home he has won only one man of the series.Why couldn't Jadeja win man of the series against "minnows"

Posted
3 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Bhajji played 25 tests after that picked 85 wickets at 39

Harbhajan played in 3 games, in SL, where Mahela took reviews after asking the umpires & there was no time back then! He also played in a limited DRS scenario in Eng, 2011 meltdown, where Broad got a hattrick on BS rule thanks to Marais *ing Eramus giving Harbhajan out lbw after he middled the ball :facepalm:

 

Do you know why? If you want someone to keep poking holes in your arguments then just go on, of course you're welcome to do so yourself.

 

4 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

24 november 2009 DRS

DRS was introduced, or trialed, in 2008 in Ind vs SL not 2009.

Posted
Just now, R!TTER said:

Harbhajan played in 3 games, in SL, where Mahela took reviews after asking the umpires & there was no time back then! He also played in a limited DRS scenario in Eng, 2011 meltdown, where Broad got a hattrick on BS rule thanks to Marais *ing Eramus giving Harbhajan out lbw after he middled the ball :facepalm:

 

Do you know why? If you want someone to keep poking holes in your arguments then just go on, of course you're welcome to do so yourself.

 

DRS was introduced, or trialed, in 2008 in Ind vs SL not 2009.

 

That was a trial basis. That is why i did not include. 2009  was the year actually it became official. I am talking about Bhajji's bowling. Now we are going to divide the DRS era into two? lol  Another filter? :) 

Posted
7 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Why couldn't Jadeja win man of the series against "minnows"

How many minnows he's played against? Less than Ashwin that's for sure & in case the last argument went over your head - it's the commentator's bias! Manjrekar was a constant in those days & he always had a bias against Jadeja. Now admittedly some series you could flip a coin, but in some of them Jadeja was the biggest difference!

 

7 minutes ago, vvvslaxman said:

Even at home he has won only one man of the series.

Jadeja deserved it in Eng vs India 2016 just as much as Brat.

Posted
Just now, vvvslaxman said:

 

That was a trial basis. That is why i did not include. 2009  was the year actually it became official. I am talking about Bhajji's bowling. Now we are going to divide the DRS era into two? lol  Another filter? :) 

Drs was around for a while before the Indians also decided to adopt it, wasn't it after Dhoni retired?

Posted
1 minute ago, vvvslaxman said:

Now we are going to divide the DRS era into two? lol  Another filter? :) 

Hey you're the one who brought up his stats post DRS & then you run away when he didn't play tests in any of them? Or do you not know DRS started full time, for us, in Ind vs Eng 2016 at home? Eng 2011 away we had no lbws you could challenge, that's why I brought up that hattrick! Stop acting deliberately dumb :whack3:

Posted
2 minutes ago, sarchasm said:

 

Yes, what a shock that data saying finger spinners have benefited the most from DRS means Ashwin's number would be like Bhajji otherwise.

 

You must be catatonic right now repeating ''show me the proof'' :phehe:

 

 

bobs burgers grasping at straws GIF

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...