Gambit Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 This is what happened. Mills bowled a short ball which Collingwood swayed out of the line for. It was the last ball of the over. Collingwood started to walk towards the middle of the pitch thinking it was the end of the over. Just as he started to walk, McCullum hit the stumps and appealed for a run out. The issue here wasn't whether Colly was out of his crease(he was). It was whether the umpire had already called 'Over' before the stumps got hit. After consultations and 3rd umpire referrals, Colly was given out. Vettori the katori walked to Colly, shook his hand and told him to stay on. Vettori should have taken revenge for the infamous Oval incident and now this largesse can lead to an English win dumping NZ out of the competition. PS - Harper might have overruled the decision in which case Vettori wouldn't be an idiot.
sm332 Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 yeah but a sportsman is a sportsman and a mongrel is a mongrel
Mr. Wicket Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Harper wouldn't have overruled the decision; it had already been referred to the third umpire who had given it out. Really stupid from Vettori, and would have been perfect karma for Collingwobble after that Oval incident where Collingwood acted like a third grade *****.
Zelig Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 "Replays show that Harper had called Over, and the stumps were thrown down shortly after. So Collingwood was not out, and the right decision was made in the end. " So, the third umpire is incompetent.:hmmm:
Sachinism Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Vettori being the bigger man and I'm that mouse Colly will feel like a mouse now
The_beast Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 a good decision. why start all the controversial hoohaa again?
Guest gaurav_indian Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 colloingwood is also :dd: player tabhi toh bol raha hu bhai :dd:
Lord Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Harper wouldn't have overruled the decision; it had already been referred to the third umpire who had given it out. Really stupid from Vettori, and would have been perfect karma for Collingwobble after that Oval incident where Collingwood acted like a third grade *****. two wrongs dont make a right.Vettori did right
Ram Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 I think Vettori did it just make to Collingwood look like an absolute t-w-a-t.
EnterTheVoid Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Vettori should have taken revenge for the infamous Oval incident and now this largesse can lead to an English win dumping NZ out of the competition. He could have yet he didn't. An illustraton of the calibre of the man. Respect Dan, respect.
Mr. Wicket Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 two wrongs dont make a right.Vettori did right But old testament type revenge, Eye for an eye and all that jazz is so much fun!
yoda Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 In this age of meaningless showmanship, Daniel Vettori, :hatsoff:
Celeste Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Umpire called over before ball hit stumps. The ball was dead any way.
The_beast Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 if collingwood goes on to hit a century LOLZ!!
The_beast Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Umpire called over before ball hit stumps. The ball was dead any way. yes but 3rd umpire had said out. so if dan the man said colly is out he would have to walk
Zelig Posted September 29, 2009 Posted September 29, 2009 Colly should deliberately get out. During my school days, in one of the matches in gully cricket, I edged a ball to the wicket keeper but the umpire (good friend of mine who still owes me Rs.100) gave me not out. I batted for the next two balls but then my conscience started to hurt me and I deliberately hit the ball straight to a fielder and got out. Colly should just follow my steps:grin:.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now