Hats off to the Review System

[kabira]

If Review System was not in place, England would have lost today's game by tea. If collingwood had gone early, that meant lower order exposed early and much before new ball was due. Saffers would have wrapped up the game by tea. But thanks heaven review system was there adn Collingwood without any hesitation called for it and rightly he was given not out. Long Live Review System

[flamy]

:isalute:

[cowboysfan]

was it daryl harper?

[kabira]

no it was Tony Hill. He otherwise had a good game

[Ram]

:hmmm:

[DomainK]

When will we accept this system??

[cowboysfan]

When will we accept this system??

when will sachin retire?

[Laaloo]

When will we accept this system??

After our senior players retire. :isalute:

[Guest BossBhai]

-- Removed on request of the user --

[kabira]

system is not yet full proof, but its better than having nothing. I have noticed more its used, teams are getting smarter using it.

[yoda]

also, in the poyzz vs aussie game there was a very minor nick shown via hot-spot.

[kabira]

^yes, that could have been crucial, Sami can be stubborn batsman.

[Guest BossBhai]

-- Removed on request of the user --

[kabira]

^I think Bossbhai he ias talking about Sami dismissal, umpire gave not out and Haddin/Ponting immediately called for review

[achilles]

^yes' date=' that could have been crucial, [b']Sami is stubborn.

Corrected :giggle:

[yoda]

but they did not appeal :haha:

no, aussies appealed and got the wicket. it was malcom sami batting as kabira pointed out.

[The Outsider]

It has been as successful as any introduction of a new aspect to a game can be. The best thing about it is the "umpire's call" part of it, which gives priority to an on field judgment in case of a doubt. There are still improvements that can be made like making similar technology available in all matches and perhaps reducing the number of incorrect challenges from 2 to 1 per innings, but those are all minor bumps. Overall, it has been a success and I still don't see 2 day test matches that people were anticipating.

[achilles]

Malcomn Sami? :((

[yoda]

Malcomn Sami? :((

Yea Sami is referred to fondly as Malcom Sami here cause Imran Khan once compared him to Malcom Marshall.

[kabira]

It has been as successful as any introduction of a new aspect to a game can be. The best thing about it is the "umpire's call" part of it' date=' which gives priority to an on field judgment in case of a doubt. There are still improvements that can be made like making similar technology available in all matches and perhaps reducing the number of incorrect challenges from 2 to 1 per innings, but those are all minor bumps. Overall, it has been a success and I still don't see 2 day test matches that people were anticipating.[/quote'] I dont think 2 is too many. thats perfect number as of now. I also see ppl walk more now.