Zelig Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 actually he has done decent job as under-19 captain' date=' when he was relatively less mature.[/quote'] Are you going to rate him based on what he had achieved at U19 level? From what I heard, Saurabh Tiwari was a prolific batsman at Youth level. Not many peeps know him outside the IPL circles now. I'm not saying Kohli won't be a good cappo. He needs to be aggressive but controlled at the same time...sort of Ganguly, if you may. If he is going to keep cussing after taking a catch, scoring a ton, jump up and down like a lil gal, he will only be setting a bad example for his team and the media will be all over him in no time when the team is having a bad run under his captaincy. When was the last time you saw him smile after taking a catch or getting a wicket? You play any sport to have fun, that's my ideal anyway.
zen Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 But we definitely do not need your approval. :finger: This comes from a guy who wrote to mods abt merging my thread because 'he' (who?) thought I should post in the match-tracker :haha: Who the hell are you to be making recommendations to anyone?
Vijy Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 Are you going to rate him based on what he had achieved at U19 level? From what I heard, Saurabh Tiwari was a prolific batsman at Youth level. Not many peeps know him outside the IPL circles now. I'm not saying Kohli won't be a good cappo. He needs to be aggressive but controlled at the same time...sort of Ganguly, if you may. If he is going to keep cussing after taking a catch, scoring a ton, jump up and down like a lil gal, he will only be setting a bad example for his team and the media will be all over him in no time when the team is having a bad run under his captaincy. When was the last time you saw him smile after taking a catch or getting a wicket? You play any sport to have fun, that's my ideal anyway. Kohli, the "lil gal", the Girl Friday of Indian cricket :hysterical:
Magneto Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 Are you going to rate him based on what he had achieved at U19 level? From what I heard, Saurabh Tiwari was a prolific batsman at Youth level. Not many peeps know him outside the IPL circles now. I'm not saying Kohli won't be a good cappo. He needs to be aggressive but controlled at the same time...sort of Ganguly, if you may. If he is going to keep cussing after taking a catch, scoring a ton, jump up and down like a lil gal, he will only be setting a bad example for his team and the media will be all over him in no time when the team is having a bad run under his captaincy. When was the last time you saw him smile after taking a catch or getting a wicket? You play any sport to have fun, that's my ideal anyway. As much as I dislike Kohli's MC-BC nonsense, I have now accepted the fact that it is part of Kohli's personality and that's how he plays his cricket. He is maturing slowly, and by the time he turns 27-28, his juvenile outbursts would be much more sporadic. Attitude wise he's a lot like Punter, and Punter hasn't done too badly as a captain. I guess the point was that Kohli has prior leadership experience, and as a junior leader he did win the most important trophy in junior cricket.
Stuge Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 I don't want to say this ,but its end of Gentlemen era in Cricket .Its no more a Gentlemen's game.
Vijy Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 It never was anyway. Haven't you heard the anecdote where the great "gentleman" W.G. Grace after getting bowled, put the bails back on, and proceeded to bat on?
Number Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 He shouldn't abuse umpires , that's it. Rest is okay.
Magneto Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 I don't want to say this ' date='but its end of Gentlemen era in Cricket .Its no more a Gentlemen's game.[/quote'] I think most current Pakistani players are pretty much gentle with the exception of the Beastretard.
Zelig Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 As much as I dislike Kohli's MC-BC nonsense' date=' I have now accepted the fact that it is part of Kohli's personality and that's how he plays his cricket. [b']He is maturing slowly, and by the time he turns 27-28, his juvenile outbursts would be much more sporadic. Attitude wise he's a lot like Punter, and Punter hasn't done too badly as a captain. I guess the point was that Kohli has prior leadership experience, and as a junior leader he did win the most important trophy in junior cricket. Hope so. And, I don't want to read much into doing well as a cappo at Youth levels. Most of the matches won at that level are down to sheer talent and skill and not due to strategy. In all likelihood, he looks certain to replace Dhoni as the long term cappo of the team. It would serve well if the Delhi Cricket Board (or whatever it's called) instates him as their cappo for the Ranjis next season and groom him for the next two years before he takes up the reins of MSD.
mishra Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 I don't want to say this ' date='but its end of Gentlemen era in Cricket .Its no more a Gentlemen's game.[/quote'] Everyone wanted Aussie style batsman... When u got it, Now u want gentleman... :facepalm:
Stuge Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 Everyone wanted Aussie style batsman... When u got it' date=' Now u want gentleman... :facepalm:[/quote'] I'm talking about MC BC MC BC . I did not made any comment on his style of batting .
Magneto Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 Hope so. And, I don't want to read much into doing well as a cappo at Youth levels. Most of the matches won at that level are down to sheer talent and skill and not due to strategy. In all likelihood, he looks certain to replace Dhoni as the long term cappo of the team. It would serve well if the Delhi Cricket Board (or whatever it's called) instates him as their cappo for the Ranjis next season and groom him for the next two years before he takes up the reins of MSD. He can be made captain of the RCB team anyway. I don't think he'll play many domestic matches in the next few years, so he'll have valuable experience in the IPL. As regards to sobering team, I think nowadays he shows much more composure in media and post-match interviews than he used to show a few years back.
mishra Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 I'm talking about MC BC MC BC . I did not made any comment on his style of batting . I am talking about the same too
achilles Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 He can never be a good cappo' date=' if he can't control his aggression. [/quote']
Zelig Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 http://crickethighlights.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/cricketers/Sourav_Ganguly-3.jpg So?
Cricket Tragic Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 He can never be a good cappo, if he can't control his aggression. I remember him acting like a puppy in one of the IPL matches (vs KKR?) coz Gambhir (?) said something to him. :headshake: Gambhir vs Kohli? :woot: What happened?
akshayxyz Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 This comes from a guy who wrote to mods abt merging my thread because 'he' (who?) thought I should post in the match-tracker :haha: Who the hell are you to be making recommendations to anyone? Abey lafandar... gather your brain cells and get your facts right. Show me the proof before making rettarded claims. In fact, I can show you the proof where mods asked me whether I want certain posts with personal-remark against me deleted. And I always said NO. Ohh, and you do remember your messages to "transparent" - along the lines - "gujju gujju bhai bhai, why against me" :finger:
akshayxyz Posted March 19, 2012 Posted March 19, 2012 Are you going to rate him based on what he had achieved at U19 level? From what I heard, Saurabh Tiwari was a prolific batsman at Youth level. Not many peeps know him outside the IPL circles now. I'm not saying Kohli won't be a good cappo. He needs to be aggressive but controlled at the same time...sort of Ganguly, if you may. If he is going to keep cussing after taking a catch, scoring a ton, jump up and down like a lil gal, he will only be setting a bad example for his team and the media will be all over him in no time when the team is having a bad run under his captaincy. When was the last time you saw him smile after taking a catch or getting a wicket? You play any sport to have fun, that's my ideal anyway. But, that is all the evidence we have (of captaincy and leadership), and which is positive. It certainly is not enough to claim he would be a good captain, but does show some potential.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now