Dhoni should be sacked as captain in all 3 formats!

[The Outsider]

And probably old generation of fans do not read posts completely? Read the last line once again.

What has "Dhoni should be sacked" got to do with comparing ODI and test whitewashes? Australia just got whitewashed in England in ODIs - probably the same thing as getting whitewashed in the Ashes, right? And where did I say anything about generation of fans?

[Sachin=GOD]

South Africa were "demolished" in all senses - 10 consecutive ODI losses and were pathetic in Tests. #TrueStory Here's Neil Manthorp's article excerpt http://www.espncricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/143069.html It does not mean Dhoni shouldn't be sacked though.

10 ODIs in a row is not equal to 8 Tests in a row (out of which 4 we lost by an innings and others by margin of well over 100 runs. )

[Crookbond]

What has "Dhoni should be sacked" got to do with comparing ODI and test whitewashes? Australia just got whitewashed in England in ODIs - probably the same thing as getting whitewashed in the Ashes, right? And where did I say anything about generation of fans?

Oops! I was replying to Post 206 - I never meant to compare Tests and ODIs and I do not believe they are the same either. Apologies for the "old generation" barb; I confused your posts with KT's post. I'm nauseated after the display in the last 3 days.

10 ODIs in a row is not equal to 8 Tests in a row (out of which 4 we lost by an innings and others by margin of well over 100 runs. )

I never said they were equal! Post 206 says "no captain has survived whitewashes" (without the Test/ODI qualifier) - I just corrected it. I did not mean to compare or contrast or even suggest that they are equal!

[CG]

Oops! I was replying to Post 206 - I never meant to compare Tests and ODIs and I do not believe they are the same either. Apologies for the "old generation" barb; I confused your posts with KT's post. I'm nauseated after the display in the last 3 days. I never said they were equal! Post 206 says "no captain has survived whitewashes" (without the Test/ODI qualifier) - I just corrected it. I did not mean to compare or contrast or even suggest that they are equal!

Come on You are nitpicking now.

[SLICKR392]

10 ODIs in a row is not equal to 8 Tests in a row (out of which 4 we lost by an innings and others by margin of well over 100 runs. )

What has "Dhoni should be sacked" got to do with comparing ODI and test whitewashes? Australia just got whitewashed in England in ODIs - probably the same thing as getting whitewashed in the Ashes, right? And where did I say anything about generation of fans?

Where was the comparison of Tests & ODIs in all this?

[The Outsider]

Oops! I was replying to Post 206 - I never meant to compare Tests and ODIs and I do not believe they are the same either. Apologies for the "old generation" barb; I confused your posts with KT's post. I'm nauseated after the display in the last 3 days.

Oh come on! Quite obviously the context is test cricket. You could have given some examples of T20 whitewashes as well.

[EnterTheVoid]

Yea, lets sack Dhoni and replace him with Nohit Sharma. After all, Nohit Sharma has class you know :hysterical:

[CG]

Yea, lets sack Dhoni and replace him with Nohit Sharma. After all, Nohit Sharma has class you know :hysterical:

Good idea He wont do worse .

[Crookbond]

Come on You are nitpicking now.

Oh come on! Quite obviously the context is test cricket. You could have given some examples of T20 whitewashes as well.

Yes - I was nitpicking! I accept that - now thinking back I shouldn't have added that to the discussion at all.

[King Tendulkar]

Looks like selctors agreed with me. Yet CSK brand came first over the indian national team. BCCI sinking to new lows. Sack DHONI NOW!

[CG]

Looks like selctors agreed with me. Yet CSK brand came first over the indian national team. BCCI sinking to new lows. Sack DHONI NOW!

B->B->

[King Tendulkar]

O for gods sake, just sack him in 1 format at least

[Tridibans_16]

O for gods sake' date=' just sack him in 1 format at least[/quote'] HAHAHAHA Nobody could touch him after 10 test defeats and you want him sacked after losing 1 t2o? Get used to it. He will be the captain as will Tendulkar be thw god...... FOREVER..... :(( RIP Indian cricket!!!!

[Lord]

expecting things to change during Srinivasan's reign is foolhardy wen is his term gonna be over

[King Tendulkar]

The fact dhoni is not resigning shows the type he is. No self respect. Clearly focused on his brand value which must go above the india team

[King Tendulkar]

Suddenly get rid of dhoni as test captain has all gone quiet. Looks like the csk brand is taking precedent over the indian test team.

[CG]

He is one selfish ,Gutless, Moron.Who else could hold on to even t20 captaincy.

[Tridibans_16]

He is one selfish ' date='Gutless, Moron.Who else could hold on to even t20 captaincy.[/quote'] Selectors and BCCI are equally responsible if not more. Look at CA and ECB. BCCI is only after money and brand. No cricket interest whatsoever. What else can be expected from a profit making private company BTW.

[Shunya]

He is one selfish ' date=Gutless, Moron.Who else could hold on to even t20 captaincy.

bas itna hi?

[Hafeez]

to be honest Dhoni is good Captain