Your Best Indian Test XI against SA

[Lord]

If Sehwag clicks in the middle order (if plays in the middle order I would play him at no 5 and Kohli at no 6) he will playing mostly when ball is old and bowlers are little bit tired he can take away the game from any team. The question is can he become fit and doesn't become a liability on the field and he is far better slip catcher than any of new comers.

not lately,he reacts to ball coming towards him as if its a missile

[cowboysfan]

sehwag is done,he cant even see the ball properly.

[adi B]

sehwag is finished,better play rahane/nohit #6

[putrevus]

wow Sehwag is finished but Sachin is not finished.

[Lord]

wow Sehwag is finished but Sachin is not finished.

both are tbh,but Sachin will be there:((

[adi B]

wow Sehwag is finished but Sachin is not finished.

sachin is ultra finished but selectors would defo take him to saf

[cowboysfan]

wow Sehwag is finished but Sachin is not finished.

sachin is doing a disservice to india, he hasnt played cricket in ages and will waltz into the team without any preparation and a terrible form to boot,he should ideally prove himself in the SA a tour.

[putrevus]

sachin is doing a disservice to india' date=' he hasnt played cricket in ages and will waltz into the team without any preparation and a terrible form to boot,he should ideally prove himself in the SA a tour.[/quote'] He has been doing this nonsense of waltzing into team as when he wishes without a iota of preparation making himself above the game for long time. I am not saying Sehwag should walk into the team but both he and Sachin if they prove fitness and form they should be considered for the tour. I have no confidence in both Rahane and Nohit.

[virufan]

Rayudu should be tried in SA. I don't know which spot as there is tough competition for places, which is good.

[Sidhoni]

Because Sehwag is Sehwag. You won't find a single opener in the 130 year old history of cricket with the kind of destructive record he has - he is to opening what Gilchrist is to keeping. He was never an opener to begin with and now that his reflexes might have slowed down for a new ball and fresh pitch' date=' he certainly deserves a 4-5 test run in the middle order, where he initially started off his career.[/quote'] Lots of others have amazing records. Shall we keep playing them too then? Why I disagree is more about Rohit/Rahane not getting a chance than Sehwag getting another.