Sachin tendulkar vs Ms Dhoni :Who is India`s greatest Odi cricketer of all time ??

[ganeshran]

In pressure situations, I'd trust Dhoni more than Sachin. That's all. WC 2003 comes to mind.

So you'd trust Dhoni with chasing 360+ against the aussies in the world cup final? :haha:

[Crookbond]

And' date=' I think I'm done with this thread. Can't believe I got sucked into this.[b'] India just won the SILICON MOBILE CUP!!!

:hysterical: :hysterical: :hysterical: :hysterical: Best comment in the whole thread!

[adi B]

Que?

is that theonly aspect of an odi game to consider?

[velu]

Yoda has already said in that other thread that Dhoni is better than Sir Viv Goddy, Sir Viv toh ho gaye. Ab bas Sobers, Bradman bache hain - create a thread with a poll about this tomorrow :idea:

some aggressive and militant fans already proved goddy is ahead of bradman :giggle: MSD fans are bit slow .. lets see what Sidhoni do 2maro :--D

[Yoda-esque]

some aggressive and militant fans already proved goddy is ahead of bradman :giggle: MSD fans are bit slow .. lets see what Sidhoni do 2maro :--D

Playing both sides?:cantstop:

[adi B]

+1 i still think gambhir's inning was much more important than msd's in 2011 world cup final

pretty close but yeah bit more important

[CSK Fan]

you are repeating the same formula in your replies :phehehe: recently when i was anti-sachin you said i will pick agarkar ahead of sachin :giggle:

Which is again true. I can pull both Jusarrived's thread from few years before and your posts from someplace else if you want. And how in every compariosn with any player under the sun, you have always chosen the other player. It's pretty easy to spot patterns about anti-Sachin people from a while ago. And co-incidentally, you both are from same/similar place in India. If you know what I mean

[velu]

Playing both sides?:cantstop:

nah .. i am moderate sachin fan who will accept his limitations :icflove: some of the sachin fans declare jihad if anything goes against sachin anyway i like MSD and sewhag more than sachin :secret:

[Old guy]

pretty close but yeah bit more important

its hard if u just look at stats but when he came out it was bad situation for us .. i have felt this when i saw the game even before i joined icf no no baised there :giggle: before joining icf i liked everyone :cantstop:

[ganeshran]

Yoda has already said in that other thread that Dhoni is better than Sir Viv

:hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:

[mastana]

Stop talking like a retard . This why I said I cant stand tendulkar fans ...

Stop posting like Rajnikanth. Shifting arrows towards dhoni won't make him better than Sachin. :finger:

[akshayxyz]

So you'd trust Dhoni with chasing 360+ against the aussies in the world cup final? :haha:

just need to tell Dhoni, that every over is last over, and 15 required everytime. should be over in 25 (last) overs max...:dontknow:

[Austin 3:!6]

Hey Velu....Its still Sachin who is the best Indian ODI player handsdown. I am talking as a batsman. There is no debate there. But yes - Dhoni >>>>> any other captains

[ganeshran]

Stop talking like a retard . This why I said I cant stand tendulkar fans ...

The only retard here is the one who posts that there is no contest between Dhoni and Sachin. :giggle:

[Sachin=GOD]

+1 i still think gambhir's inning was much more important than msd's in 2011 world cup final

it certainly was.

[velu]

Which is again true. I can pull both Jusarrived's thread from few years before and your posts from someplace else if you want. And how in every compariosn with any player under the sun' date=' you have always chosen the other player. It's pretty easy to spot patterns about anti-Sachin people from a while ago. And co-incidentally, you both are from same/similar place in India. If you know what I mean[/quote'] :poink: nah .. i usually claim sachin is selfish and bit brittle when handing pressure and nothing more against him.. and again i might have posted like i would pick dravid or sehwag ahead of sachin in tests :--D even recently i told i would pick 40yr old sachin ahead of 25 yr old Rohit :icflove: i am basically frm coimbatore staying in blore but i guess jusarrived is a coorgi

[velu]

Hey Velu....Its still Sachin who is the best Indian ODI player handsdown. I am talking as a batsman. There is no debate there. But yes - Dhoni >>>>> any other captains

all down to preference .. bets opener vs best finisher if Dhoni does the samething for another 4 or 5 years , i would choose MSD ahead of sachin in ODIs irrespective of captaincy

[velu]

it certainly was.

you would choose dinesh karthik ahead of MSD :MTC :poink:

[CSK Fan]

:poink: nah .. i usually claim sachin is selfish and bit brittle when handing pressure and nothing more against him.. and again i might have posted like i would pick dravid or sehwag ahead of sachin in tests :--D even recently i told i would pick 40yr old sachin ahead of 25 yr old Rohit :icflove: i am basically frm coimbatore staying in blore but i guess jusarrived is a coorgi

Lets call it a truce for now. Am sure you fiancee' will punish you in the future if you say a word against Sachin so will leave it in her able hands :giggle:

[Old guy]

Lets call it a truce for now. Am sure you fiancee' will punish you in the future if you say a word against Sachin so will leave it in her able hands :giggle:

from pure hater to fan..she is already doing her job :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical: