Irfan Pathan vs Rishi Dhawan

[BlueBee]

Who would you pick as India's Genuine All rounder for the WC15?

[Lord]

Rishi Dhawan is still an unknown quantity.specially in batting.needs few chances in ODIs.hope he can do well in IPL atm defintely Irfan if fit

[G_B_]

Does Irfan even bowl now a days? read he plays for Baroda as a batman. not sure how true that is. Rishi has a terrible list A record but his Ranji stats are good. Not sure he is odi material atm.

[Lord]

Does Irfan even bowl now a days? read he plays for Baroda as a batman. not sure how true that is. Rishi has a terrible list A record but his Ranji stats are good. Not sure he is odi material atm.

Irfan has started bowling now

[JyoLP]

Irfan Irfan pathan.

[sandeep]

A fit Irfan with good bowing rhythm is an asset to the team - only if both those conditions are met.

[JaiRamesh2]

Rishi Dhawan. It is t20 wc, best time to throw in newbies and experiment. I can never understand why Dhoni still leads and plays in India's t20s.

[tweaker]

Rishi Dhawan is consistent player in the last 2 ranji season in both batting & bowling department.Whereas Irfan Pathan has not performed in the last 2 season.By now Rishi Dhawan should have been in the squad,but strangely Binny is in the squad.

[Lord]

btw who is Irfan playing for in IPL?DD?

[tweaker]

India batting is strong,we need bowling All-rounder more than batting All-rounder.

[tweaker]

Rishi Dhawan should be selected in England tour

[vvvslaxman]

Bhuvaneswar has some potential. Hoipe he gets to stage where he can score occasional 50s. Don't go by domestic cricket much. When Irfan pathan played some good test knocks he did not have any domestic record to speak of. Same with Ashwin. He is not exactly a domestic giant.

[Sidhoni]

We needed to try Dhawan out in the Asia Cup