coffee_rules Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Glad we dropped him. We are now able to enjoy all the ODIs we won in SA and NZ this year.
gattaca Posted March 20, 2014 Author Posted March 20, 2014 thats the dilemma right. ideally we should be picking on domestic performance. but past international outings matter too. The problem with him since now he has performed he will be picked again. The perth test was a disaster. I didnt like that at all. Trundling on one of the fastest pitches in the world.
gattaca Posted March 20, 2014 Author Posted March 20, 2014 Glad we dropped him. We are now able to enjoy all the ODIs we won in SA and NZ this year. Now that he has performed he will be selected again. I know you are from Karnataka but please dont say he deserves a place in the indian team.
bulbul Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 I guess VK is standby for T20 WC in case of any injury.
vijay50 Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Anotger domestic bully, unfit for international cricket.
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Why is this performance been brought up now? He was dropped after this wasn't he......but he really looked a beast this season with the ball :--D
Old guy Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Why is this performance been brought up now? He was dropped after this wasn't he......but he really looked a beast this season with the ball :--D Just a reminder that he has always been best here but crap for India
bulbul Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 May be time to start reminder thread for some phassssst bowlers :woot:
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Just a reminder that he has always been best here but crap for India He has always been a good ODI performer but this year he was the captain as well(not sure if he was before),seemed like he had a plan for him and his bowlers every time,very impressive. I want us to move on from Vinny but can't discredit his performance this year People keep bringing up Pankaj Singh and hating on Vinay which is unfair.....Pankaj Singh is a tundler as well.
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Majrity of ICF Always have have their darlings Ishant wins a M.OM in a ODI-It was Thanks to pressure created by Bhuvi Ishant gets 3 4+wkt hauls in 3 back to back tests-It was Thanks to the pressure created by Shami Ishant doesn't get wickets despite bowling well-He sucks,He is a Panauti etc. Vinay Kumar bowls well in domestics-He sucks,Domestics suck Pankaj Singh or some other unknown trundler does well-He is the real deal. Jadeja(before the Sir thing caught on) was still a decent ODI spinner-check his stats and did play some decent innings but he was ridiculed every step of the way.
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Have countless other examples as such....I am not even going all out and defending them but sometimes an argument or a hate on a player needs to subjective and constructive,not with pre-conceived notions
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 No more trolling. Me neither....comeback when you have a constructive argument rather than blind hate. Firstly did you even watch him bowl this season?
Old guy Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Me neither....comeback when you have a constructive argument rather than blind hate. Firstly did you even watch him bowl this season? Please if u want argument to convince u guy is not good enough than u should stop watching cricket and just follow arguments here :two_thumbs_up: Well fact is he has always been great in domestic cricket and another fact is no matter how he does in domestics he has always been crap in internationals and very same bowlers he will replace that is Bhuvan did much better than him last time they played together And about ishant..u ur self accepted he is crap when u left the side temporarily ..so please do not waste my time ..u think trolling is funny but there is a limit and I don't want to reply to u anyway cos at every opportunity u try to make snide remarks about how I post . U started supporting these mediocre players during ipl and since it was funny u continued but now it's hard to take anything u say serious...u seriously said ishant sucks and now again hype his fluke performance in ct Some article on cricinfo said vinay kumar is 10 th rate tundler ..and he will remain like that forever..while I appreciate his hardwork and performance at domestic level he is just simply not good enough for internationals ..it's sad reality but not every one is good enough for internationals and even now I will rather have some one like ishant who has some hope of I proving than vinay who is just mediocre and anyone who knows bit about cricket knows that and his performance back it up
Old guy Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Also next time please show me one post hyping up pankaj or any other bowler for that matter People here just say he is good enough to be part of side or atleast a side ...no one said he is world beater but deserves a chance which guys like vinay kumar and ishant have gotten again and again even after failing plenty of times ...get the perspective of comment right.
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Please if u want argument to convince u guy is not good enough than u should stop watching cricket and just follow arguments here :two_thumbs_up: Well fact is he has always been great in domestic cricket and another fact is no matter how he does in domestics he has always been crap in internationals and very same bowlers he will replace that is Bhuvan did much better than him last time they played together And about ishant..u ur self accepted he is crap when u left the side temporarily ..so please do not waste my time ..u think trolling is funny but there is a limit and I don't want to reply to u anyway cos at every opportunity u try to make snide remarks about how I post . U started supporting these mediocre players during ipl and since it was funny u continued but now it's hard to take anything u say serious...u seriously said ishant sucks and now again hype his fluke performance in ct Some article on cricinfo said vinay kumar is 10 th rate tundler ..and he will remain like that forever..while I appreciate his hardwork and performance at domestic level he is just simply not good enough for internationals ..it's sad reality but not every one is good enough for internationals and even now I will rather have some one like ishant who has some hope of I proving than vinay who is just mediocre and anyone who knows bit about cricket knows that and his performance back it up Lol.....I don't need a judgement from you or for the matter of fact any one questioning my cricketing accumen or Credibility. I said Ishant sucks the way he bowled in the 2nd test in S.A and it was Dhoni's fault for giving him another shot but when he performed what is the problem? Maybe you look for my hilarious posts and miss out the more serious ones. You come in here and start rambling about Vinay Kumar when you don't even know what is going on since that terrible game he had.SImilarly,I have seen posters ridiculing good performances by players they didn't think deserved a chance,which is stupid. I think Dhoni sucks as a captain but doesn't mean I won't him to fail when he is playing for India....there is a difference between criticisng a players performance and praying for him to fail when he plays for India.
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Finally going back to the topic of discussion here......Vinay Kumar failed at international level and rightfully so got kicked out but what has been exceptional and impressive is he went back to domestics,took on the responsibility of leading his team and came out trumps in both aspects which is inspirational. Now does he deserve a chance based on that?That i for the selectors to judge and I prsonally may not be in favor but at the same time I wont totally ridicule that either
Old guy Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Lol.....I don't need a judgement from you or for the matter of fact any one questioning my cricketing accumen or Credibility. I said Ishant sucks the way he bowled in the 2nd test in S.A and it was Dhoni's fault for giving him another shot but when he performed what is the problem? Maybe you look for my hilarious posts and miss out the more serious ones. You come in here and start rambling about Vinay Kumar when you don't even know what is going on since that terrible game he had.SImilarly,I have seen posters ridiculing good performances by players they didn't think deserved a chance,which is stupid. I think Dhoni sucks as a captain but doesn't mean I won't him to fail when he is playing for India....there is a difference between criticisng a players performance and praying for him to fail when he plays for India. Why are u even talking about others ? My stand about dhoni is pretty clear..he is just average captain mainly cos of selections he makes and composition of teams he selects otherwise one of the best cricketers india produced . About rambling about other players by other people ...why are u telling me this ? Vinay kumar is still crap even if people were wrong about jadeja that does not mean they are wrong about vinay One is youngster other is not One performed during second chance while other did not ... Heck it's not even same thing...vinay has consistently looked mediocre atleast some one like ishant shows some glimpses of brilliance but with vinay u cannot even remember good performance in international level other than 4 wicket haul against England Also pleae share what u actually think about ishant ? Is he crap or not ?so u changed ur mind after series against New Zealand and he was crap before ? Seems like ur committing same thing which ur accusing others off :haha:
maniac Posted March 20, 2014 Posted March 20, 2014 Why are u even talking about others ? My stand about dhoni is pretty clear..he is just average captain mainly cos of selections he makes and composition of teams he selects otherwise one of the best cricketers india produced . About rambling about other players by other people ...why are u telling me this ? Vinay kumar is still crap even if people were wrong about jadeja that does not mean they are wrong about vinay One is youngster other is not One performed during second chance while other did not ... Heck it's not even same thing...vinay has consistently looked mediocre atleast some one like ishant shows some glimpses of brilliance but with vinay u cannot even remember good performance in international level other than 4 wicket haul against England Also pleae share what u actually think about ishant ? Is he crap or not ?so u changed ur mind after series against New Zealand and he was crap before ? Seems like ur committing same thing which ur accusing others off :haha: No I am not...I seriously backed Ishant even after Fualkner's assault as we seem to ignore all the bashing the Aussie bowlers got in the series as well and I thought he was done and dusted after the 2nd test in S.A....He was unfairly given another shot ahead of Yadav but when he was our best bowler in the tests(Yes Wickets matter) why the hate? He should be picked for the next test series....Period.......Yadav has Zak's slot. You need to come up with a subjective argument than just say a player sucks because that is the popular notion
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now