What if Stuart binny plays next test match?

[Maratha]

What would you do? A. Stop watching cricket B. Start supporting Pakistan C. Start watching SaaS bahu serials D. Don't give a eff. Keep watching cricket for virat. mods please add poll. I don't know how to do it.

[gaurav92]

Continue backing Binny and hope he gets a proper chance this time round :icflove:

[vvvslaxman]

:hysterical: @ Option A

[CG]

He will play certainly,knowing dhonis history and drawn test .

[gaurav92]

He will play certainly' date=knowing dhonis history and drawn test .

He will not play for that very reason.

[cricketfan28]

stop watching cricket for some time (may be an hour)..and then resume...

[CG]

He will not play for that very reason.

Dhoni rarely changes team even if loose so drawn test is like victory.

[jf1gp_1]

Fletcher has to take some responsibility before he arrived we atleast under Dhoni atleast did alright like in NZ and SA post 2011 we have just been crap

[gaurav92]

Dhoni rarely changes team even if loose so drawn test is like victory.

But if he hates a player, he will change him as soon as he can. And with what has happened with Binny, he definitely is not playing him unless Binny does something dramatic with the bat :nice:

[gakgupta]

If pitch has something in it ... then he has a role to play .....

[skindia]

pitch is flat...binny would make ton...but dhoni playing politics here too sending him after jaddu...I think outside subcontinent binny>jaddu in batting and bowling

[skindia]

binny can bowl better than ishant with new ball...even binny would have done better than ishant 147/3 something if so many overs were given to him

[vvvslaxman]

When was last tme we defended a total of 105.. If Varun Aaron had been in the match instead of binny i bet my bottom dollar BD would have won. It is not like Anderson, Boad were ripping through our line up lol SHami and Bhuvan were making them look like part timers.

[gaurav92]

pitch is flat...binny would make ton...but dhoni playing politics here too sending him after jaddu...I think outside subcontinent binny>jaddu in batting and bowling

Agree

[CG]

But if he hates a player' date=' he will change him as soon as he can. And with what has happened with Binny, he definitely is not playing him unless Binny does something dramatic with the bat :nice:[/quote'] why did he play him if he hates him.

[gaurav92]

That is precisely what I have not understood.

[rkt.india]

When was last tme we defended a total of 105.. If Varun Aaron had been in the match instead of binny i bet my bottom dollar BD would have won. It is not like Anderson' date=' Boad were ripping through our line up lol SHami and Bhuvan were making them look like part timers.[/quote'] Sometimes, conditions can make mediocre players look great. Those were the conditions for him which will never get here. He just had to ball in good length area and conditions did the rest. You cannot give an example of a Yadav who was completely out of sorts. Every medium pacer form both sides other than him was a hot cake in those conditions, likes of Mortaza, Al-Amin. You expect Murtaza, Al-Amin to create any problems on pitches like these? No. They wont. Similarly Binny wont too, but Yadav can if he can get his right areas because of his pace which he is not doing right now. It was like Ganguly picking 5-fer in Toranto and Binny isnt much better than Ganugly as a bowler.

[dragonfly]

I'd bet on a Binny double century and 10 wicket haul. Become a bajillionaire. Buy my IPL franchise. And make Binny the captain of the franchise.

[vvvslaxman]

Sometimes' date=' conditions can make mediocre players look great. Those were the conditions for him which will never get here. He just had to ball in good length area and conditions did the rest. You cannot give an example of a Yadav who was completely out of sorts. Every medium pacer form both sides other than him was a hot cake in those conditions, likes of Mortaza, Al-Amin. You expect Murtaza, Al-Amin to create any problems on pitches like these? No. They wont. Similarly Binny wont too, but Yadav can if he can get his right areas because of his pace which he is not doing right now. It was like Ganguly picking 5-fer in Toranto and Binny isnt much better than Ganugly as a bowler.[/quote'] Same conditions should make better bowler even better. right? I dont say he is Philander next coming. All i am just saying he is getting slagged off after just 10 overs over the course two days on a patta wicket. It is Dhoni who should get bulk of criticism for selecting him in the first place. Binny sure should not have been with this squad. Now that he is ther he should use hm or not t pick him at all.

[rkt.india]

]Same conditions should make better bowler even better. right? I dont say he is Philander next coming. All i am just saying he is getting slagged off after just 10 overs over the course two days on a patta wicket. It is Dhoni who should get bulk of criticism for selecting him in the first place. Binny sure should not have been with this squad. Now that he is ther he should use it not pick him at all.

Not when bowler is not in rhythm and lacking confidence or if trying a bit too hard. It is not the case always. Like I gavce you example of Ganguly 5-fer in Toranto, Theere were other bowlers too but they did not pick 5-fer but Ganguly but it does not make Ganguly a test bowler and neither Binny as good as bat as Ganguly was. You need to see the potential and back the right guy and this is what Dhoni does not do. There is nothing which suggests Binny can be a successful test cricketer. Cant bat, cant bowl. Regarding the pitch, BK made the ball talk on the same flat track and I am not criticizing Bininy but Dhoni. He does not even have decent 4th bowler who can take a wicket let alone 5th bowler who is just bits and pieces. First fix your 4th bowler then worry about 5th. I am saying this for last 2 tours.