Dhoni vs Bhuvi vs Cook vs Anderson- who is the better test batsmen

[Straight Drive]

Voted for Dhoni.

[velu]

This has to be the OTT thread of the decade. When I opened this thread in the morning, it was 22-0 for Bhuvi till I made it 22-1. Two 50s and Bhuvi is now better than Dhoni, one more fifty and then he'll be better than Dhawan I am sure! Bleddy nonsense to the power infinity. Maybe Anderson is better at home than Prior as well.

++1 forum is infested with trolls who hate dhoni for one single reason :((

[velu]

Cook vs viRAT vs Dhoni [india in England 2014] Cook and Rat are expected to be the best batsmen frm their respective sides. Lest see how they fare vs our useless tets batsmen Dhoni. :--D After 3 innings. Cook - 15 RAT - 34 Kewl - 94 Will be updated.

[CSK Fan]

Cook and Rat are expected to be the best batsmen frm their respective sides. Lest see how they fare vs our useless tets batsmen Dhoni. :--D After 3 innings. Cook - 15 RAT - 34 Kewl - 94 Will be updated.

Lol, there was a reason people were not comparing Cook and Anderson. Am locking this thread for now

[velu]

Mr.MTC can you lock this too ??

[Yoda-esque]

Mr.MTC can you lock this too ??

:cantstop:

[CSK Fan]

Mr.MTC can you lock this too ??

Why, this is a valid thread discussing overseas technique. No one compared Cook or Kohli with Bhuvi or Anderson for a reason

[fineleg]

valid poll. MSD is not fit to tie laces of a proper Test batsman. Hence he is compared with a tailender BK.

[velu]

valid poll. MSD is not fit to tie laces of a proper Test batsman. Hence he is compared with a tailender.

dhoni scored 4 times more runs than cook and 3 times than rat in 2 tests so far .. mine is valid

[CSK Fan]

dhoni scored 4 times more runs than cook and 3 times than rat in 2 tests so far .. mine is valid

One fluke innings where no 11 of both teams scored 50? Hardly a valid comparison. Here there seems to be a genuine reason to compare techniques of both batsmen. However, I have asked people for feedback in the site feedback thread. If enough people agree, your thread will also be unlocked. I would request you to stop spamming other threads till that happens

[Magneto]

my thread is more valid than this .. i am comparing their technique but the runs they are going to score .. not that diffcult to understand if u r in stable mnd cook averages -47 rat averages - 46 dhoni - 40

See, it's not about averages. It's about blind hate. Otherwise no one compares a batsman who averages a piddly 30 in FCs with a Test double centurion.

[velu]

One fluke innings where no 11 of both teams scored 50? Hardly a valid comparison. Here there seems to be a genuine reason to compare techniques of both batsmen. However' date=' I have asked people for feedback in the site feedback thread. If enough people agree, your thread will also be unlocked. I would request you to stop spamming other threads till that happens[/quote'] if i apply same MTC logic Bhuvi scored 2 fifties in the same tests where both No.11 scored a 50.. so bhuvi too scored 2 fluke 50s

[CSK Fan]

if i apply same MTC logic Bhuvi scored 2 fifties in the same tests where both No.11 scored a 50.. so bhuvi too scored 2 fluke 50s

Of course, Thats why we are comparing techniques and not scores. However, have merged both threads now, so please continue

[velu]

Of course' date=' Thats why we are comparing techniques and not scores. However, have merged both threads now, so please continue[/quote'] :two_thumbs_up: i am happy now .. we will be talking after this series if dhoni scores more than either one of rat or kolhi :finger: tomorrow ll be going to temple for dhoni

[Magneto]

Of course' date=' Thats why we are comparing techniques and not scores. However, have merged both threads now, so please continue[/quote'] LOL, we are talking volumes about a cricketer's technique who has been a successful Test batsman in India despite having no technique. What a waste!

[saneindian]

Super! So since Dravid had praised Bhuvi's technique, I had created the 'Bhuvi batting watch' thread. And you locked it just because a poster requested for the same (for no logical reason). So that poster's word is more important than Dravid's word? (On the basis of which I created the thread).

Are dada, your jinxing powers Rehem khao bechare Bhuvi par

[velu]

MTC is really losing it with the blind Dhoni hate :cantstop:

:agree: not only MTC .. many posters are hating dhon blindly.. waiting for this series to get over :weights:

[Sachin=GOD]

Bhai mere' date=' I have long given up trying to do that[/quote'] I meant a Dhoni fan, not just you. But yeah, if others also stopped taking things so personally then quality of discussion will improve.

[CSK Fan]

Please continue this discussion in the site feedback thread.

[Yoda-esque]

I meant a Dhoni fan, not just you. But yeah, if others also stopped taking things so personally then quality of discussion will improve.

I think people should stop abusing cricketers this way. Once or twice is also ok but pages dedicated with posters posting the same stuff is boring and beneath them Otherwise what's the difference between the fans that posted on Sharapovas page and the ones here