10 years of MS Dhoni - Debate thread

[BlueBee]

:reddy:

[Sachin=GOD]

Whitewashed in England and in Aus. Lost to Eng at home. On course to lose to Aus again :adore:

[fineleg]

Lame attempt to defend the Cancer of Indian cricket

[StriKe]

Lame attempt to defend the Cancer of Indian cricket

:facepalm: Even in this thread? You can bash him more after 4th day of 3rd test but Dhoni is best LOI player :hatsoff:

[tweaker]

Every good thing have a end.Dhoni 's tenure should end after whitewash in Australia.

[Sidhoni]

Whitewashed in England and in Aus. Lost to Eng at home. On course to lose to Aus again :adore:

Remind who batted at no 4 during all these series? Was it a certain God who just won't let go of the fact his career is done with?

[bulbul]

Remind who batted at no 4 during all these series? Was it a certain God who just won't let go of the fact his career is done with?

You are turning this into fight between 2 :cantstop:

[Austin 3:!6]

Good ODI player but a liability in tests

Liability as a test captain overseas Only People forget he has better win % than any other Sub continent skipper in test matches: MS Dhoni - 45.76 S.Ganguly - 42.85 I.Khan - 29.16 :phehehe: Azharuddin - 29.78 A.Ranatunga - 21.42 He is also STILL our best Wk Bat in Subcontinent pitches.

[Sachin=GOD]

Remind who batted at no 4 during all these series? Was it a certain God who just won't let go of the fact his career is done with?

Remind me of the test results since he retired...

[sscomp32]

Liability as a test captain overseas Only People forget he has better win % than any other Sub continent skipper in test matches: MS Dhoni - 45.76 S.Ganguly - 42.85 I.Khan - 29.16 :phehehe: Azharuddin - 29.78 A.Ranatunga - 21.42 He is also STILL our best Wk Bat in Subcontinent pitches

And England . He has a good Record in England too.

[vvvslaxman]

His overseas record as captain is on par with bangladesh captains past, present

[Sidhoni]

Remind me of the test results since he retired...

MUCH better than before. This team is giving a fight in every match except last 3 matches of England tour. Oh and they won a match too at Lords, something God couldn't manage.

[Sachin=GOD]

MUCH better than before. This team is giving a fight in every match except last 3 matches of England tour. Oh and they won a match too at Lords' date=' something God couldn't manage.[/quote'] 11 matches. 1 win. 7 losses. 3 draws. You have to be absolutely blind to his faults to not see the fact that he is destroying the test team with his pathetic captaincy (and his own lack of contribution with the bat in most series') and he should (would) have been gone if not for Srini. Just 2-3 losses more and he will have the most number of losses overseas by any captain in the history of test cricket - thats in a game where Bangladesh and Zimbabwe also play......think about that....

[Marut]

His overseas record as captain is on par with bangladesh captains past' date=' present[/quote'] One reason is India keeps touring the tougher teams for the damned $$$. India has been touring Eng, Australia, SA, NZ, Eng, Aus in that order since July 2011 - my god, that would be a nightmare for any captain and much more so for a SC captain. And considering India has been a team in transition during this period, having lost Tendulkar, Dravid, Laxman, Sehwag, Gambhir, Bhajji and Zaheer - and replacing them with youngsters. Dhoni is bad but he is not as bad as we project him to be. His time is up, he needs to vacate his test captaincy, but we have to agree that Dhoni has had a horrid time with the tour schedule and the resources available to him. India would not have won too many matches on these tours, but they would not have lost that many under normal circumstances.

[Marut]

Liability as a test captain overseas Only People forget he has better win % than any other Sub continent skipper in test matches: MS Dhoni - 45.76 S.Ganguly - 42.85 I.Khan - 29.16 :phehehe: Azharuddin - 29.78 A.Ranatunga - 21.42 He is also STILL our best Wk Bat in Subcontinent pitches.

Lots of draw in those days. Not Imran's fault.

[Raghav_12]

MUCH better than before. This team is giving a fight in every match except last 3 matches of England tour. Oh and they won a match too at Lords' date=' something God couldn't manage.[/quote'] God was even winning test tours of England until this guy forced on team as captain. We were winning test matches on Australian your regularly and was close to winning two tours. And then Dhoni came as the captain..!!

[BlueBee]

Dhoni supporters are pissing me off :mad: Every time you say something bad about his captaincy they come out with the ICC trophies we've won under him and that we were ranked #1 in tests under him too :mad: Don't know why don't they accept the fact that he is **** in captaining in tests.

[Austin 3:!6]

Dhoni supporters are pissing me off :mad: Every time you say something bad about his captaincy they come out with the ICC trophies we've won under him and that we were ranked #1 in tests under him too :mad: Don't know why don't they accept the fact that he is **** in captaining in tests.

Why don't you reply to Post #18?

[gattaca]

Liability as a test captain overseas Only People forget he has better win % than any other Sub continent skipper in test matches: MS Dhoni - 45.76 S.Ganguly - 42.85 I.Khan - 29.16 :phehehe: Azharuddin - 29.78 A.Ranatunga - 21.42 He is also STILL our best Wk Bat in Subcontinent pitches.

Win percentage ? Can you divide in to home vs abroad excluding subcontinent ?

[Austin 3:!6]

Lots of draw in those days. Not Imran's fault.

Thats why Viv Rictahrds had win % of 54, Clive Lloyd with 49, Border with 36 playing in the same era? Heck even Javed Miandad had an win % of 41 :phehehe: So much for Parosis claiming him to be the best Asian captain...yeah right.