Indian players who played, did well, and yet were discarded

[Ankit_sharma03]

Just now, Lord said:

 

Did well in WI and okay in SA. Both Ashwin and Jaddu were also terrible in SA.

 

Yaar WI to ko ireland ke spinner bhi tang krte hai 

Ash n jaddu have bowled mostly at time when fingers spinners in white ball have become the toughest job in world cricket. Had they bowled in previous rules they wud have done far far better

 

Just now, Lord said:

Atleast should have got some chances to prove it.

 

Kuldeep did better in SA and NZ than India.

 

Atleast these guys can beat batsmen in air. Darters depend on pitch more. Ofcourse ideally both should vary pace.

kuldeep was a chinamen which has been a rare breed, if u see alll his dismissals teams has no idea before he even bowled the ball. Mishra was a leggie which was not something rare

To beat someone in air u need pace, which chahar n bishnoi had even chawla 

Darterers shudnt be compared with them 

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

4 minutes ago, Lord said:

Atleast should have got some chances to prove it.

 

in such a big country u cnt give every one a fair run

We had many captains from ganguly to kohli and many batsman these yrs if he was that good someone wud have backed him . Cant doubt integrity n judgement of so many players

[Lord]

1 minute ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

Yaar WI to ko ireland ke spinner bhi tang krte hai 

Ash n jaddu have bowled mostly at time when fingers spinners in white ball have become the toughest job in world cricket. Had they bowled in previous rules they wud have done far far better

 

exactly so atleast one of them could have been replaced by available wrist spinner for few games. Nothing much to lose.

1 minute ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

 

kuldeep was a chinamen which has been a rare breed, if u see alll his dismissals teams has no idea before he even bowled the ball. Mishra was a leggie which was not something rare

To beat someone in air u need pace, which chahar n bishnoi had even chawla 

Darterers shudnt be compared with them 

 

so why did Kuldeep do badly in India? everything else is same but he actually did better overseas.

 

Bishnoi is quick like Rashid Khan or Kumble. Mishra was more Warne/LSRK(little slower). Old school but could have worked.

[Lord]

12 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

in such a big country u cnt give every one a fair run

We had many captains from ganguly to kohli and many batsman these yrs if he was that good someone wud have backed him . Cant doubt integrity n judgement of so many players

 

nah I'm not doubting integrity. Since question is asked in OP,I thought of example.

 

Giving someone long run will obviously mean others get very less chances.

[coffee_rules]

5 hours ago, Vijy said:

I would not say that these folks meet criteria #2 IMO.

They did well, but we had alternate options and decided to give them a longer rope for some reason.