Dhoni should be sacked as captain in all 3 formats!

[adi B]

Warne: Dhoni has no common sense and match awareness. Couldn't agree more.

he has been saying that about dhoni for a long time lol

[CSK Fan]

i thought this topic is not about sachin .. and did you think about your qulaity of posts before posting this offtopic reply ? :hmmm:

Nope, I am just pointing out that dead weights were removed and the excuse of just scoring more than others didn't count. I thought this was pretty solid argument, don't know how is this off topic. I am just pointing out that removing dead weights worked for us for a while so we need to remove one more

[someone]

"Bizarre and weird. No common sense or logic whatsoever." - Shane Warne's opinion on MS Dhoni's unusual bowling changes and field placements Then again, what does Shane Warne know about cricket.

Well, not that Shane Warne is wrong. But just following the experts doesn't bring success. Let's be honest, in this test match, we played the perfect team, the team which most experts and fans wanted to play. And yet, we did poorly in all departments. It's easy to raise questions but much harder to find solutions. Today, we all know the questions, issues which are of plenty, but yet, we don't have a single solution. Next, nor will a single solution solve it so the idea that changing the captain is very incomplete. As the bigger question lies in who is the alternative?

[CSK Fan]

Well, not that Shane Warne is wrong. But just following the experts doesn't bring success. Let's be honest, in this test match, we played the perfect team, the team which most experts and fans wanted to play. And yet, we did poorly in all departments. It's easy to raise questions but much harder to find solutions. Today, we all know the questions, issues which are of plenty, but yet, we don't have a single solution. Next, nor will a single solution solve it so the idea that changing the captain is very incomplete. As the bigger question lies in who is the alternative?

As I used this example before, in 2007, in LOIs, we were going nowhere. Then we made a young Dhoni captain and team transformed over night. Batting, bowling, fielding, everything changed 180 degrees. All the experts pointed this out. Sometimes removing something stale changes everything. Our youngsters like Pujara, Kohli have lots of potential. But team looks dead now

[someone]

It is extremely myopic if we are crucifying the young Pujara and Kohli on their first overseas tour of England when they scored big on their previous overseas tours, yet give Dhoni a free pass for couple of 50s when he was pathetic for a long time overseas

:whack: You said let's not give Dhoni a free pass but yet you want to give a free pass to the rest of our batsman. :haha::haha: Of course, Dhoni is at fault but he isn't the only one at fault. Many others are at faults including your Kohli and Pujara. We lost comprehensive, so everything was wrong.

[CG]

Why you do not get the simple point Dhoni is senior and captain.

[CSK Fan]

:whack: You said let's not give Dhoni a free pass but yet you want to give a free pass to the rest of our batsman. :haha::haha: Of course, Dhoni is at fault but he isn't the only one at fault. Many others are at faults including your Kohli and Pujara. We lost comprehensive, so everything was wrong.

Because for Kohli, Pujara it is one bad series while for Dhoni it is 3 bad years now overseas. Kohli, Pujara are on their first England tours and are completely green. Dhoni is the senior most player. Surely you can see the difference

[someone]

As I used this example before' date=' in 2007, in LOIs, we were going nowhere. Then we made a young Dhoni captain and team transformed over night. Batting, bowling, fielding, everything changed 180 degrees. All the experts pointed this out. Sometimes removing something stale changes everything. Our youngsters like Pujara, Kohli have lots of potential. But team looks dead now[/quote'] The difference at that time was Dhoni was settled in our team, everyone knew he is gonna be the keeper for the next many years. He was a safe option as he was always gonna be in our first XI. Today, that isn't true. Alternatives like Pujara, Kohli first need to cement and be settled in our test team. Only then, can we think about them being captains. Imo, the first step now is to remove Dhoni from T20 team and give the captaincy to another player. That can be the start.

[King Tendulkar]

The man is an idiot. That's proven But forget tactics etc. He also is disgustingly corrupt etc etc As I have explained many a time before and all know about it. Can you imagine and its quite obvious by the results etc what effect this has on the team? This skipper who they all know what is up to and his agendas, how this effects the team dynamics and spirit. No wonder we are pathetic and fold like a pathetic pack of cards.

[King Tendulkar]

The difference at that time was Dhoni was settled in our team, everyone knew he is gonna be the keeper for the next many years. He was a safe option as he was always gonna be in our first XI. Today, that isn't true. Alternatives like Pujara, Kohli first need to cement and be settled in our test team. Only then, can we think about them being captains. Imo, the first step now is to remove Dhoni from T20 team and give the captaincy to another player. That can be the start.

**** T20 , don't care Sack his **** from test captaincy. We need a new man, ne vision, new ethics If you plonkers want to judge it by runs, no problems. Give rahane the captaincy. Sack him. Otherwise more humiliations will flow, aus tour coming shudder to think how we will do under idiotic captain corrupt

[asterix]

Perfect result... Serves him well....

[King Tendulkar]

His results are pathetic. In fact its embarrassing. You are judged by results. People not saying judging him on one series or even one year. This is years of losses and total himiliations We have just lost to pathetic englkand team and made them look lime world beaters. The man is scum that cant even resign. Money hgungry gangster with his sugar daddie to protect him and paid comms to defend and lavish praise and naïve indian public Hate this man

[velu]

[adi B]

dhoni and bcci missed the trick by not boycotting the series after southampton test.would have gone back with our heads held high :vroam:

[someone]

**** T20 , don't care Sack his **** from test captaincy. We need a new man, ne vision, new ethics If you plonkers want to judge it by runs, no problems. Give rahane the captaincy. Sack him. Otherwise more humiliations will flow, aus tour coming shudder to think how we will do under idiotic captain corrupt

And what when Rahane fails? Another new captain? New captain every series? It's not such a simplistic situation where removing Dhoni will automatically make our team do well. Of course, Dhoni staying as captain also doesn't neccessary make our team do well. Yet, Dhoni still is the safest bet given his place in team is secured completely.

[King Tendulkar]

And what when Rahane fails? Another new captain? New captain every series? It's not such a simplistic situation where removing Dhoni will automatically make our team do well. Of course, Dhoni staying as captain also doesn't neccessary make our team do well. Yet, Dhoni still is the safest bet given his place in team is secured completely.

We are not sacking caoptains cos of runs they make. But 3 years of losses, what rubbish you saying replace a skipper after one loss. Safe option lol From what? You act as if dhoni statying as captain is risking us appointing a rapist!! Deluded idiotic post from fan boys. Pathetic. You shpuld be ashamed to say you support Indiia, as you don't, you support the fat corrupt ****

[King Tendulkar]

His place is only secured in team compoletely cos he is corrupt with his fat cement man srini. That's all!! Would not be in most test teams of knowlegable fans, only pathetic fan boys can say such a stupid thing

[maniac]

Dhoni is made out to be some kind of a great leader in other formats and the excuse given is tests are his achillies heel but not true,He has been bombing as a captain in overseas ODI series as well-CB Series 2012,Nzl,SA.....even lost to Pak at home. In T20's less said the better

[someone]

We are not sacking caoptains cos of runs they make. But 3 years of losses, what rubbish you saying replace a skipper after one loss. Safe option lol From what? You act as if dhoni statying as captain is risking us appointing a rapist!! Deluded idiotic post from fan boys. Pathetic. You shpuld be ashamed to say you support Indiia, as you don't, you support the fat corrupt ****

Well, as you believe your abuses can solve it, you should instead support the padosi team as your lunatic behavior would be much welcomed there. On the issue, to get test captaincy, you need experience. Even Dhoni didn't get it right away, played under Kumble before getting it. Today, none of our players have such experience. We don't need to change the captain just for the sake of it. Instead, we should address the core issue, why does our whole batting unit fail overseas ? Do we lack the mentality?

[King Tendulkar]

Well, as you believe your abuses can solve it, you should instead support the padosi team as your lunatic behavior would be much welcomed there. On the issue, to get test captaincy, you need experience. Even Dhoni didn't get it right away, played under Kumble before getting it. Today, none of our players have such experience. We don't need to change the captain just for the sake of it. Instead, we should address the core issue, why does our whole batting unit fail overseas ? Do we lack the mentality?

WTf:hysterical: Have you been watching these ass rapes for last 3 years in away tests, or this first match you seen? Delusional fan boy. Sad to see