Dhoni should be sacked as captain in all 3 formats!

[express bowling]

Yes.. we should remove Dhoni immediately We should follow paki model. Remove captain after every series. Every match. Announce retirement every series. Comeback after that series.

We follow the reverse Paki model. Even after consecutive 0-4 defeats in tests, followed by loss at home to England, -- our captain stays. :cantstop:

[King Tendulkar]

^ Yeah removing a skipper with 8 straight away test losses is knee jerk paki style reaction:cantstop: Frankly if the man had any dignity would have resigned but then too much money to be made

[Yoda-esque]

This thread has proved that we are no different from padosi fans. Conspiracy theories,arm chair judgements,vacuous strategies .... They blame Misbah and we blame Dhoni.lol

[skindia]

He should be captain for home conditions and for away tours,pujara should be captain

[CG]

Home :cantstop:

[maniac]

Dhoni's attitude reflects on the team for sure.......India's rise coincides with a group of players SRT,Dravid,VVS,Saurav,Kumble whose sole passion was cricket and pride for the country. We are talking about a guy who a naturally gifted athlete like MS is,wanted to play cricket so that he could score a sarkaari job as a ticket collector,TBF to him was talented in his own way and had the charisma to be marketable,now is making as much money as possible. Dhoni is not in the same league as the names I have mentioned.The guy should be used as a player because he is good,no doubt about it,let him make his millions with his on-field performances,Captaincy should be given to guys who care about Indian cricket.

[maniac]

^Also I am not suggesting or calling Dhoni an unpatriotic guy,Just questioning his passion for the game of cricket.He has 0 interest and I think once he is done with the game will be done with the game period.

[Yoda-esque]

Dhoni's attitude reflects on the team for sure.......India's rise coincides with a group of players SRT,Dravid,VVS,Saurav,Kumble whose sole passion was cricket and pride for the country. We are talking about a guy who a naturally gifted athlete like MS is,wanted to play cricket so that he could score a sarkaari job as a ticket collector,TBF to him was talented in his own way and had the charisma to be marketable,now is making as much money as possible. Dhoni is not in the same league as the names I have mentioned.The guy should be used as a player because he is good,no doubt about it,let him make his millions with his on-field performances,Captaincy should be given to guys who care about Indian cricket.

He played with a broken nail the previous game and that too faced fast bowlers in that condition...

[maniac]

He played with a broken nail the previous game and that too faced fast bowlers in that condition...

What a brave guy.....braved a broken nail :two_thumbs_up:

[Yoda-esque]

What a brave guy.....braved a broken nail :two_thumbs_up:

Try that

[maniac]

Try that

I walked with a dry,itchy,burning skin in my crotch area for nearly half a mile in sub 0 temperature to work once,surely more difficult than a broken nail :--D and better commitment

[maniac]

^PS:No I dont have passion for what I do,just like the paycheck.....

[Yoda-esque]

I walked with a dry' date='itchy,burning skin in my crotch area for nearly half a mile in sub 0 temperature to work once,surely more difficult than a broken nail :--D and better commitment[/quote'] Nah,try harder

[saneindian]

The guy who has probably played the most no of days of international cricket in last 6-7 years doesn't have a passion for the game and is only interested in making money!! I can understand Dhoni being called a poor naive even a clueless foolish captain but to question the commitment of someone is the worst thing to do.

[Old guy]

The guy who has probably played the most no of days of international cricket in last 6-7 years doesn't have a passion for the game and is only interested in making money!! I can understand Dhoni being called a poor naive even a clueless foolish captain but to question the commitment of someone is the worst thing to do.

seriously..i dont know why there is so much over reaction .. this is probably the reason i siad dont hype team too much and dont expect much cos this isfirst away tour and we are not magically going to beat south africa cos we have not done that even once in our history! this over reaction here on icf is shocking cos even after 8-0 most people did not whined like this and had valid arguments

[Raghav_12]

The guy who has probably played the most no of days of international cricket in last 6-7 years doesn't have a passion for the game and is only interested in making money!! I can understand Dhoni being called a poor naive even a clueless foolish captain but to question the commitment of someone is the worst thing to do.

These ODI's also included the ODI that he played even after being ruled out of the series in WI. And No, India didn't need him for those matches. In fact India was doing better without him. Still out of his insecurity, he decided to stay back and waited to get fit and play final. This kind of luxury had never been afforded to any player in history. Surely Dhoni didn't play that final out of passion, but out of insecurity.

[rkt.india]

These ODI's also included the ODI that he played even after being ruled out of the series in WI. And No' date=' India didn't need him for those matches. In fact India was doing better without him. Still out of his insecurity, he decided to stay back and waited to get fit and play final. This kind of luxury had never been afforded to any player in history. Surely Dhoni didn't play that final out of passion, but out of insecurity.[/quote'] That's a lame argument. Can never doubt Dhoni's commitment. Criticize his captaincy, his thought process, not the commitment.

[King Tendulkar]

That's a lame argument. Can never doubt Dhoni's commitment. Criticize his captaincy' date=' his thought process, not the commitment.[/quote'] What if his commitmnet to India winning is comprimsed bu his fianical interests. Hence picks and selcts players based on this. What then?

[King Tendulkar]

Home :cantstop:

And people brush this under carpet.

[saneindian]

These ODI's also included the ODI that he played even after being ruled out of the series in WI. And No' date=' India didn't need him for those matches. In fact India was doing better without him. Still out of his insecurity, he decided to stay back and waited to get fit and play final. This kind of luxury had never been afforded to any player in history. Surely Dhoni didn't play that final out of passion, but out of insecurity.[/quote'] And won the match nearly single handedly for India, But obviously that is not important, his assumed insecurity is much more important.