M Tiwary is not good enough to be a test player!!

[King Tendulkar]

He is being touted by a lot of people. Let me tell you know he is simply not good enough for test cricket and his technique is suspect and in aprticular would be exposed there. I think he may have a role in odis etc But tests , no way!!

[CG]

Yeah when he faces a fast bowler he just hangs back and if somebody bowls him a bouncer he just gets in to the mindset expecting every ball to be a bouncer and just makes a mess of it.

[Lord]

yes if he plays,he will be wolloped by bowlers

[Lord]

Yeah when he faces a fast bowler he just hangs back and if somebody bowls him a bouncer he just gets in to the mindset expecting every ball to be a bouncer and just makes a mess of it.

wat do u base that on?

[Lord]

always said technique is overrated.

[CG]

wat do u base that on?

Watching him in odis and domestic matches.He just hangs back even when he made a century against wi he just hang back i was worried he would be bowled but he did manage.

[Lord]

Watching him in odis and domestic matches.He just hangs back even when he made a century against wi he just hang back i was worried he would be bowled but he did manage.

thats the key no,he managed.u need to manage with your technique.good technique isnt everything

[CG]

thats the key no' date='he managed.u need to manage with your technique.good technique isnt everything[/quote'] Thats in odis in tests he could be exposed big time .

[King Tendulkar]

He is another raina/yuvi type player. Not a TEST match player

[Lord]

Thats in odis in tests he could be exposed big time .

could be,but lets give him the chance before that.that applies to any player

[ravishingravi]

Yes

[NareshK]

You cant rule out any player because you never know what he is capable of given the right chances but having said that, the pitches in India have generally become very flat because of ODIs and IPL. That's why in Ranji trophy, every team is scoring 500 or 600 in every game and there havent been many quality spinners and pacers coming through the ranks while there are lots of batsmen without proper technique averaging above 55. This is a trend that's happening all across the world, not just in India and most of these batsmen will be found out in conditions which are helpful for bowlers.

[daindian]

Give him a chance!!! He can't do any worse than yuvraj, raina, badri, and also why is it every upcoming Batsman has bad technique or temperament for tests?? Tiwarys technique might not be the best but I'd rather have him if we need to bat a day out than raina, nohit yuvraj, badri. Flaws in technique can be worked on eg kp and left arm spin,. Flaws in temperament can't Sent from my GT-I9300 using Tapatalk 2

[Lord]

He is another raina/yuvi type player. Not a TEST match player

Raina,Yuvi averaged in 40s even in FC.Tiwary averages 59.surely thats an indicator

[Pagalpanti]

Technique isn't everything. Laxman used to hang back as well, but he scored runs in tests didn't he? Tiwary has temperament for big innings, at least he's shown that in his few outings. Not the best technique around but if he can be a grinder, he'll be perfect for no.6 spot India are vying to fill ever since Dada quit.

[rkt.india]

We need to try whatever options we have and then see who clicks. Raina and Yuvraj should not be anywhere near tets team for now. Selectors need to punt on new guys and we have plenty at FC level.

[King Tendulkar]

Raina' date='Yuvi averaged in 40s even in FC.Tiwary averages 59.surely thats an indicator[/quote'] You being lazy like our selctors:winky: By that I mean looking at numbers and picking from there. When many other factors wether can take step up to test level. To me its obvious he will not be a good test match player, I hope I am wrong but he simply does not look a test match player. Again hope I am proved wrong. But think must look at other options amongst youngsters first

[Magneto]

You being lazy like our selctors:winky: By that I mean looking at numbers and picking from there. When many other factors wether can take step up to test level. To me its obvious he will not be a good test match player, I hope I am wrong but he simply does not look a test match player. Again hope I am proved wrong. But think must look at other options amongst youngsters first

Scored a pretty decent 93 against England in the tour game. Does not fish around pointlessly, and takes his time. Good temperament.

[Lord]

You being lazy like our selctors:winky: By that I mean looking at numbers and picking from there. When many other factors wether can take step up to test level. To me its obvious he will not be a good test match player, I hope I am wrong but he simply does not look a test match player. Again hope I am proved wrong. But think must look at other options amongst youngsters first

if selectors looked at FC numbers,Yuvi n Raina would never hv played test cricket apart from technique why do u think hes not test material,surely he must be doing something right to average 59 in FC

[Number]

His average in FC games tells that he should be given a chance in the test team. We can't write off a player like this.