translocating gir lions is dangerous

[FischerTal]

Ardent lion lover, Rajya Sabha MP Shri Parimal Nathwani in this note expresses worries about the Supreme Court verdict directing translocation of Gir lions to Madhya Pradesh: The news that the Honorable Supreme Court has accepted in principle the translocation of Gir’s Asiatic lions came as a shock-wave for the wild life lovers of Gujarat. Supreme Court is understood to have formed a committee to recommend the number of lions to be shifted within six months from the date of the order. Whereas the wisdom and Jurisprudence of the highest court of our land is unquestionable and beyond doubt, the order is unfortunate for the state of Gujarat. Gir lions are the pride of Gujarat; The several centuries old habitat of this rare specie in Gir has been the most appropriate location because of its geographical, climatical, environmental and bio-diverse peculiarities. Gir’s characteristics are unique and rare; there is no parallel to Gir in the country or the world. There is every possibility that the new habitat may prove unsuitable to the translocated lions because of a variety of reasons, the main being that they are shifted and made to live in a new area, where everything from climate, vegetation, land and water would be different. Their food which they get by hunting the animals would be changed. We should not forget that this specie has survived only in Gir all these years. Wild life experts still believe that translocating or shifting the lions would tantamount to make them more ‘endangered’ a specie than what it is to-day. Exposing matured lions or even the cubs to alien and unfamiliar locations is less-likely to suit this rare animal which has found abode in Gir since several centuries and have sustained so far.Many a times it has been noticed that translocation and changed habitat do not suit the animals, impacting upon their mental and physical health. It is also noticed, worldwide that the animals do not mate and procreate progeny in changed habitat or environment. This is especially true and correct in case of rare specie like lions. If this apprehension comes true we may see a fall in Lion population which would be an irreversible phenomina. The apprehension that the huge forest-fire or an epidemic would completely finish the specie is unfounded as nothing of such things happened in known history of Gir and Gir lions. The numbers are on increase. The human being- maldharis and their animals cohabitate with lions since their generations without any difficulty. The honorable Apex Court which directed the centre not to import cheetahs from Africa to Kuna sanctuary in the humble opinion of mine and others, should have been pleased to refuse translocations of Gir Lions also. The honorable Supreme Court must have surely considered all the aspects fully and wholly; but as a lion-lover and one who has taken the cause of Gir lions so fondly, it is unconvincing to think of shifting of lions. In my humble opinion the future of Gir Lions could have been more secured by ensuring that they continue to live at Gir. The union and the State Government can invite the best of the experts from the world and obtain their recommendations for making the Lions more safe and free from any possible hazard, while allowing them to continue to stay in their own habitat.

Source: DeshGujarat What are your opinions?

[hhunaeh]

Why are they translocating the lions?

[sankarnarayan]

translocating lions is perhaps a good idea ... they have done similar translocating in africa ...

[Tiger80]

They want to translocate Lions to Kuno and few tigers their were already translocated.It is going to be dangerous experiment that lion and tiger live together in wild or not

[carnish]

Bad Idea. Change of Air and Water is never good for any species. Humans can easily adopt but it will be difficult for Tigers.

[tk__]

articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-04-22/flora-fauna/38735322_1_gir-lions-kuno-craig-packer "The world's leading lion experts are quite convinced that the move to relocate the Gir lions is an apt one. "It is important to have a second population to save the last wild Asiatic lions,"" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asiatic_Lion_Reintroduction_Project#Lion_reintroduction_at_Kuno_Wildlife_Sanctuary "The Gir Wildlife Sanctuary is now highly overpopulated with lions, the 2010 census showed the strength to be 411 lions.[4] There are large scale deaths in the population annually because of ever increasing competition between the human and animal overcrowding." ......... "The single population faces the threats of epidemics, natural disasters and other anthropogenic factors. The project aims to establish a second independent population of Asiatic Lions at the Kuno Wildlife Sanctuary in the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh"

[Mariyam]

Appeasement politics by Modi. :mad: He's doing this just to get votes from the other animals of the Gir forest who are generally hunted by the Lions. He clearly has started in earnest for 2014 elections. Its all an eyewash. Can't believe that you guys can't see through this.

[Clarke]

^ It could also mean Modi, who dreams about moving to New Delhi next year, is asked to relocate to Chambal ki ghati. His supporters after all refer to him as 'Gujarat ka sher'

[cowboysfan]

it s a good idea,lions roamed in most of africa and asia (even cheetahs by the way) before human population rise decimated their population.

[Crookbond]

articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-04-22/flora-fauna/38735322_1_gir-lions-kuno-craig-packer "The world's leading lion experts are quite convinced that the move to relocate the Gir lions is an apt one. "It is important to have a second population to save the last wild Asiatic lions,"" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asiatic_Lion_Reintroduction_Project#Lion_reintroduction_at_Kuno_Wildlife_Sanctuary "The Gir Wildlife Sanctuary is now highly overpopulated with lions, the 2010 census showed the strength to be 411 lions.[4] There are large scale deaths in the population annually because of ever increasing competition between the human and animal overcrowding." ......... "The single population faces the threats of epidemics, natural disasters and other anthropogenic factors. The project aims to establish a second independent population of Asiatic Lions at the Kuno Wildlife Sanctuary in the Indian state of Madhya Pradesh"

:two_thumbs_up:

[Vilander]

Very positive development, this would mean Asiatic lions survive the century.. Should not take any Guj seriously on this, they will try to say lions should stay in guj so that they can have monopoly, but its the future of a whole species of a magnificent animal.

[FischerTal]

Very positive development, this would mean Asiatic lions survive the century.. Should not take any Guj seriously on this, they will try to say lions should stay in guj so that they can have monopoly, but its the future of a whole species of a magnificent animal.

we were the ones who made sure this animal did not go extinct. do you know what happened to tigers in MP?

[Clarke]

Very positive development, this would mean Asiatic lions survive the century.. Should not take any Guj seriously on this, they will try to say lions should stay in guj so that they can have monopoly, but its the future of a whole species of a magnificent animal.

While I'm all for policy based on scientific reasoning, who's giving the guarantee for the safety of 'half the species' in MP ?

[tk__]

While I'm all for policy based on scientific reasoning' date=' who's giving the guarantee for the safety of 'half the species' in MP ?[/quote'] That is a valid question and the people who will be in charge of the MP operation would have to be appropriately chosen. But the issue raised here is not about the credibility of the MP sanctuary but the Lions need to be translocated out of Gir at all. Given the various issues facing the Lions, that would have to be done. The focus should be more about how the lessons learned/expertise gained from Gir can be applied and how this knowledge can be shared.