Sachin tendulkar vs Ms Dhoni :Who is India`s greatest Odi cricketer of all time ??

[Old guy]

Take that haters :finger: i thought you are a chachin paaji hater

hater ? why would i do that ? :cantstop:

[saneindian]

Yes' date=' [b']when Dravid plays slow its because that's how he plays. When Sachin does it because he is struggling to time he is selfish BTW, when you go into personal intentions of players like questioning their integrity, selfishness, etc, then your views have nothing to do with facts or genuineness. Its completely powered by genuine hate for a player (and most probably because you like some other player whom you feel is overshadowed) I have followed many of your posts on other forums, so please don't make these tall claims of genuineness.

:two_thumbs_up:

[velu]

struggling to score runs and being selfish to reach landmarks are two different things

watever makes you happy :icflove: anyway this thread is not about whether sachin is selfish or not we are deviating from the topic .. MSD or sachin ?? :hmmm:

[Old guy]

This is a ridiculous thread. Tendulkar would compete only with Richards to be the best ODI cricketer ever' date=' Dhoni would struggle to make the top 10. There is simply no comparison whatsoever.[/quote'] seriously.. some people here using ur argument of world cup final performance but forgetting to read whole post where u said its mroe of a tie breaker and only gives advantage if rest everything is comparable and equal ..

[Divvy]

People often forget abt kallis.. In ODI's Sachin Ave : 44.83 RPI : 40.76 50 + runs in every 3.11 innings Kallis Ave: 45.26 RPI : 37.45 50+ runs in every 3 innings And don't forget Kallis' bowling. His figures are on par (or sligntly lesser than) with Srinath. He is basically Sachin+Srinath Sachin is the greatest batsman in ODI, but IMO, Kallis is the greatest "cricketer" in ODI's. Comparable to Sir Sobers, Imran, Haldlee in tests.

[The Outsider]

People often forget abt kallis.. In ODI's Sachin Ave : 44.83 RPI : 40.76 50 + runs in every 3.11 innings Kallis Ave: 45.26 RPI : 37.45 50+ runs in every 3 innings And don't forget Kallis' bowling. His figures are on par (or sligntly lesser than) with Srinath. He is basically Sachin+Srinath Sachin is the greatest batsman in ODI, but IMO, Kallis is the greatest "cricketer" in ODI's. Comparable to Sir Sobers, Imran, Haldlee in tests.

Oh bhai, check out Kallis' strike rate. It's very ordinary. And beyond statistics, Kallis has never been an impact player in ODIs while batting or bowling. He is a good and stable support act in the middle order like Dravid used to be, but one would seriously struggle to think of innings by Kallis which stay in your mind like Tendulkar's 175, the Desert Storm centuries, and so many more.

[rkt.india]

When you have SRT, anyone else can only fight for second spot. :two_thumbs_up:

[rkt.india]

This is a ridiculous thread. Tendulkar would compete only with Richards to be the best ODI cricketer ever' date=' Dhoni would struggle to make the top 10. There is simply no comparison whatsoever.[/quote'] I think Ganguly, Dhoni, Yuvraj have big fight for second best ODI player for India.

[Divvy]

Oh bhai' date=' check out Kallis' strike rate. It's very ordinary. And beyond statistics, Kallis has never been an impact player in ODIs while batting or bowling. He is a good and stable support act in the middle order like Dravid used to be, but one would seriously struggle to think of innings by Kallis which stay in your mind like Tendulkar's 175, the Desert Storm centuries, and so many more.[/quote'] My knowledge in cricket is very limited (it's the reason I went for stats) , so I have no choice but to agree with you.

[omkarkiran]

People often forget abt kallis.. In ODI's Sachin Ave : 44.83 RPI : 40.76 50 + runs in every 3.11 innings Kallis Ave: 45.26 RPI : 37.45 50+ runs in every 3 innings And don't forget Kallis' bowling. His figures are on par (or sligntly lesser than) with Srinath. He is basically Sachin+Srinath Sachin is the greatest batsman in ODI, but IMO, Kallis is the greatest "cricketer" in ODI's. Comparable to Sir Sobers, Imran, Haldlee in tests.

As u Said.. Sachin is the greatest Batsman ever in ODI... Kallis will be the greatest Allrounder in ODIs :shakehands:

[omkarkiran]

I think Ganguly' date=' Dhoni, [b']Yuvraj have big fight for second best ODI player for India.

cannot be yuvi.. chances for Sehwag I guess if he gets into form.. :pray:

[SLICKR392]

This is a ridiculous thread. Tendulkar would compete only with Richards to be the best ODI cricketer ever' date=' [b']Dhoni would struggle to make the top 10. There is simply no comparison whatsoever.

SRT any day but the haters here are as blind and delusive as the fanboys.

[JaFanatic]

I think Ganguly' date= Dhoni, Yuvraj have big fight for second best ODI player for India.

:two_thumbs_up:

[Sachin=GOD]

The haters here are as blind and delusive as the haters.

he's talking about an international top 10 list - and Dhoni certainly would struggle to come into such a list.

[SLICKR392]

:two_thumbs_up:

Yuvraj > Ganguly. Won us plenty of games, can bowl better than him and has a far superior SR compared to Ganguly's SR of 73.

[Sidhoni]

Yuvraj > Ganguly. Won us plenty of games' date=' can bowl better than him and has a far superior SR compared to Ganguly's SR of 73.[/quote'] That and Yuvi won us a WC. Second Indian to be MOTT in a WC (Don't know if there was such a thing in 83)

[The Outsider]

SRT any day but the haters here are as blind and delusive as the haters.

Maybe you are in a rage mode like your avatar and did not read my post correctly? Or are you seriously saying that Dhoni is a certainty to make an all time top 10 ODI list of international cricketers?

[Sachin=GOD]

That and Yuvi won us a WC. Only Indian to be MOTT in a WC (Don't know if there was such a thing in 83)

Goddy in 2003.

[The Outsider]

That and Yuvi won us a WC. Only Indian to be MOTT in a WC (Don't know if there was such a thing in 83)

Huh? Tendulkar won it in '03.

[Sidhoni]

Goddy in 2003.

Huh? Tendulkar won it in '03.

Oops. I thought he only won the golden bat.