Brett Lee rates Tendulkar above Lara

[maniac]

+1. I have followed KP from his England A times when he scored 3 centuries in 4 matches in India and is a massive fan; but no, KP is not greater than Sachin. :cantstop:

He is using K.P is a crutch.He even said Mhd.Yusuf is > Dravid and Laxman :haha:

[velu]

He is using K.P is a crutch.He even said Mhd.Yusuf is > Dravid and Laxman :haha:

thats your argument and not mine .. still 898 << 933 or 925 :finger:

[Old guy]

+1. I have followed KP from his England A times when he scored 3 centuries in 4 matches in India and is a massive fan; but no, KP is not greater than Sachin. :cantstop:

I got into test cricket because of him earlier it was like bonus stuff before or after odi series :--D

[Magneto]

i would pick KP in tests over sachin and i am not a padosi :dontknow: only our fans would pick sachin over KP , its not simple if we remove indian glass

Maybe then you can say even Hayden is better than Sachin. Hayden Cook G Smith ABDV etc

[velu]

:hysterical:keep em coming....Even England doesn't want to pick him or for the matter of fact South Africa

he won more ashes than the midget :giggle:

even england fans pick sachin over kp

but still played more match winning/saving knocks than midgu :--D

[fedex]

top 5 batsman in test 1.bradman 2.sachin/lara 3.richards 4.kallis 5.ponting/dravid

[velu]

Maybe then you can say even Hayden is better than Sachin. Hayden Cook G Smith ABDV etc

smith has a strong case

[velu]

top 5 batsman in test 1.bradman 2.sachin/lara 3.richards 4.kallis 5.pointing/dravid

fedex top 5 :giggle: kallis is 4th complements ur cricketing knowledge

[Magneto]

smith has a strong case

I am sure :cantstop:

[velu]

I am sure :cantstop:

as a cricket fan first , i want to win a game rather than my fav player to score a ton .. as a test batsmen , smith is not far behind statswise if we ignore longevity

[Old guy]

as a cricket fan first , i want to win a game rather than my fav player to score a ton .. as a test batsmen , smith is not far behind statswise if we ignore longevity

Why is he not winning match now when dale steyn is injured ? Again I am huge fan :p

[fedex]

fedex top 5 :giggle: kallis is 4th complements ur cricketing knowledge

dude do you even followed cricked before 2000...i rated based on batting,you are free to disagree

[Magneto]

as a cricket fan first , i want to win a game rather than my fav player to score a ton .. as a test batsmen , smith is not far behind statswise if we ignore longevity

Easier to win the match when you have Pollock, Ntini, Steyn, Morkel, Philander etc bowling for you.

[fedex]

as a cricket fan first , i want to win a game rather than my fav player to score a ton .. as a test batsmen , smith is not far behind statswise if we ignore longevity

you are telling sachin has been rating for only longevity..wisden rated him 2nd test batsman after bradman even in 2002..may be wisden sachin fantactic :giggle:

[velu]

you are telling sachin has been rating for only longevity..wisden rated him 2nd test batsman after bradman even in 2002..may be wisden sachin fantactic :giggle:

they are not sahin fanatic .. if they are then thy might have included one or two of his innings in the top 100 list :--D

[fedex]

they are not sahin fanatic .. if they are then thy might have included one or two of his innings in the top 100 list :--D

i thought discussion about better player..not about whether sachin inings deserves in wisden top 100 :haha:

[Crookbond]

he won more ashes than the midget :giggle:

I think most Australian and England players have won more Ashes than Tendulkar.

[Laaloo]

I guess this is the appropriate smiley here:

[Laaloo]

so which players are rightly rated as the greatests?

I think he would make a compelling case for Raina

[jusarrived]

so which players are rightly rated as the greatests?

I dont know whos the greatest , I dont know how you can compare players from different era . But I rate VVS and Dravid above him in tests . Tendulkar is probabaly better than every one else overall .