Why do people want rohit back?

[velu]

* He had so much time to play his shots :--D

ball had so much time and space to float and hit the stumps :hysterical:

[Detonator]

Okay, he has played very few matches overseas, it wouldn't be much of a difference if he comes in place of binny. if he clicks, it will be a huge boost to indian batting line up.

[vvvslaxman]

Okay' date=' he has played very few matches overseas, it wouldn't be much of a difference if he comes in place of binny. if he clicks, it will be a huge boost to indian batting line up.[/quote'] England bowling is so weary that guys like Kohli, Dhawan, Pujara wil cash in. You may not need 6th batsman. Hardest part of the tour is complete.

[undisputed chap]

more like sending a sheep to slaughterhouse :hysterical:

:giggle:

[CG]

England bowling is so weary that guys like Kohli' date=' Dhawan, Pujara wil cash in. You may not need 6th batsman. Hardest part of the tour is complete.[/quote'] Do not jump the gun.We are known to be complacent after a victory and after so many years.The next test is really series decider.

[Detonator]

England bowling is so weary that guys like Kohli' date=' Dhawan, Pujara wil cash in. You may not need 6th batsman. Hardest part of the tour is complete.[/quote'] one single collapse will easily turn into a loss. dhoni won't gonna give the ball to binny, so we can assume his role is a batsman. rohit is a much better bat than binny if poms roll out a flat deck. it wouldn't hurt if he is given a chance.

[vvvslaxman]

Do not jump the gun.We are known to be complacent after a victory and after so many years.The next test is really series decider.

What if Rohit flops big time in the series.. you will have 4 weary Indian bowlers who will be bowled to the ground and England will stage a come back out of nowhere.

[vvvslaxman]

one single collapse will easily turn into a loss. dhoni won't gonna give the ball to binny' date=' so we can assume his role is a batsman. rohit is a much better bat than binny if poms roll out a flat deck. it wouldn't hurt if he is given a chance.[/quote'] We had collapses in the first two tests. Didn't hurt us. We survived the worst.

[vvvslaxman]

You guys are assuming Rohti automatically turn up and score 100, 200. If he can do,, i can safely assume Pujara, Kohli will score 200, 300. or even Ashwin score 100.

[Detonator]

What if Rohit flops big time in the series.. you will have 4 weary Indian bowlers who will be bowled to the ground and England will stage a come back out of nowhere.

even kohli is a big flop, so does dhawan. My hunch is that rohit did a very good job in CT, he might be a success here. as i said b4, dhoni not gnna give the ball to panni

[ThePhenomenal1]

You guys are assuming Rohti automatically turn up and score 100' date=' 200. If he can do,, i can safely assume Pujara, Kohli will score 200, 300. or even Ashwin score 100.[/quote'] Exactly! Just because he's on the bench people think he's gonna score hundreds. We have enough batsmen and most, even dhawan, have scored 30+. Bowling is a bigger concern as binny has no use as of now and id rather play a 4th seamer. Keeps other 3 seamers fresh and adds variety if we have varun aaron.

[Laaloo]

What if Rohit flops big time in the series.. you will have 4 weary Indian bowlers who will be bowled to the ground and England will stage a come back out of nowhere.

Dhoni wont bowl Binny anyways so that is a moot point

[ThePhenomenal1]

even kohli is a big flop' date=' so does dhawan. My hunch is that rohit did a very good job in CT, he might be a success here.[/quote'] against swing, rohit will flop. did well in CT but hardly any swing.

[Detonator]

You guys are assuming Rohti automatically turn up and score 100' date=' 200. If he can do,, i can safely assume Pujara, Kohli will score 200, 300. or even Ashwin score 100.[/quote'] nah, but do you think 33 yr old binny gonna play forvever? Rohit otoh is a long term prospect.

[vvvslaxman]

even kohli is a big flop' date=' so does dhawan. My hunch is that [b']rohit did a very good job in CT, he might be a success here.

Not against England. Besides Dhawan did a better job.

[vvvslaxman]

nah' date=' but do you think 33 yr old binny gonna play forvever? Rohit otoh is a long term prospect.[/quote'] Ashwin or fast bowler should replace.

[vvvslaxman]

Dhoni wont bowl Binny anyways so that is a moot point

Result of that idiotic tactic almost hurt us but for some bizzarre batting from England. Bhuvi was clocking 72 mph . He could barely walk. Shami and Ishant could not go on forever . You are left with Jaddu that's it. Having an option is a must. Not going in with an option is a huge risk considering none of our top order can be considered a decent bowler.

[CG]

What if Rohit flops big time in the series.. you will have 4 weary Indian bowlers who will be bowled to the ground and England will stage a come back out of nowhere.

Playing binny does not serve any purpose except pleasing mayanti.Binny is not going to bowl.We can replace binny with ashwin or aaron.

[vvvslaxman]

Playing binny does not serve any purpose except pleasing mayanti.Binny is not going to bowl.We can replace binny with ashwin or aaron.

That is what i am saying too. Either Ashwin or Aaron pr Pankaj should repalce him. You need a 5th bowler ( seamers or ashwin) or 5th bowling option(Binny). No need of 6th batsman. That too Rohit as 6 is very unreliable abroad.

[Laaloo]

Result of that idiotic tactic almost hurt us but for some bizzarre batting from England. Bhuvi was clocking 72 mph . He could barely walk. Shami and Ishant could not go on forever . You are left with Jaddu that's it. Having an option is a must. Not going in with an option is a huge risk considering none of our top order can be considered a decent bowler.

Yup. Jadeja was creating no trouble at all on the fifth day. Ishant was nearing the end of his spell. Shami was ineffective and Bhuvi was tired. England :facepalm: