Do U think Hashim Amla is best odi Batsman ever??

[velu]

On a secular note' date=' Yes. But on a serious note, No.[/quote'] :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:

[BlueBee]

On a secular note' date=' Yes. But on a serious note, No.[/quote'] :hysterical::hysterical:

[YCCC]

At the moment, possibly. But 'ever' I don't think so. Candidates for me would be Richards and some lad from Mumbai you may be rather familiar with

[Austin 3:!6]

At the moment' date=' possibly. But 'ever' I don't think so. Candidates for me would be Richards and some lad from Mumbai you may be rather familiar with[/quote'] Even at present he is a bottler in key ODI's like ABDV. Kohli is the best ODI player at present and his records speak for himself. Not talking about Strike rate and Avg only but due to sheer disdane he chased those improbable targets. Don't go by his test failures...he is the best ODI batsman easily.

[adi B]

On a secular note' date=' Yes. But on a serious note, No.[/quote'] haha:cantstop:

[sensible-indian]

Best ever in ODIs: No 1 - Viv No 2 - Sachin

[sensible-indian]

Amla isn't the No 1 ODI player in the world. That goes to Kohli or ABDV.

[King Tendulkar]

Gaurav92 has come out with post of the year:hysterical:

[game_changerr]

On a secular note' date=' Yes. But on a serious note, No.[/quote'] :hysterical::hysterical::hatsoff:tracer bullet

[kosingh]

You are using statistics to rate batsmen. Personally, my favorite ODI batsman ever is Viv Richards. But if you must use statistics, then there is no way anyone can beat SRT.

[Midfielder]

He is decent.

[zep1706]

Best ever in ODIs: No 1 - Viv No 2 - Sachin

Arguable. It is true that Viv has higher average and SR (not by far though although those numbers were mind blowing for his time) Sachin has hit a lot more 100s. Viv has just 11 hundreds in 187 games. At the same rate he would have had 27-28 hundreds had he played as many games as Tendulkar, Tendulkar has 21-22 more.

[gaurav92]

Gaurav92 has come out with post of the year:hysterical:

:--D

[AmreekanDesi]

LOL even currently both Kohli ad AB de villers are better than him

[sensible-indian]

Arguable. It is true that Viv has higher average and SR (not by far though although those numbers were mind blowing for his time) Sachin has hit a lot more 100s. Viv has just 11 hundreds in 187 games. At the same rate he would have had 27-28 hundreds had he played as many games as Tendulkar' date=' Tendulkar has 21-22 more.[/quote'] Viv goes beyond stats. His impact was crazy. Both are GOATs in ODI but Viv is greater than Sachin in my view. Even if you take neutral fans' views, its Viv all the way.

[kosingh]

Arguable. It is true that Viv has higher average and SR (not by far though although those numbers were mind blowing for his time) Sachin has hit a lot more 100s. Viv has just 11 hundreds in 187 games. At the same rate he would have had 27-28 hundreds had he played as many games as Tendulkar' date=' Tendulkar has 21-22 more.[/quote'] So by your argument, Amla is better than Tendulkar

[sourab10forever]

ABDV...match winner

[zep1706]

On a secular note' date=' Yes. But on a serious note, No.[/quote'] This is epic. :hysterical::hysterical::hysterical:

[zep1706]

So by your argument' date=' Amla is better than Tendulkar[/quote'] I did not make a definitive statement. I said it was arguable.

[CSK Fan]

Even if you take neutral fans' views, its Viv all the way.

Actually I disagree. I have only heard this from most Pak fans and some Indian fans. Not even West Indians themselves consider him above Sachin though they do say he is an ODI great. So I do not think most neutrals put Viv ahead, Aussie put Sachin ahead, mostly because he performed against them in ODIs. Anyways, this one is too close to call so I would be happy with either way