Sunil Narine reported for suspect action in CLT20

[kira]

Ashwin also might get called. Forthe fun of it to see whether a bowler with a clean action can pass the tests.

Ashwin is clean and lankans should never question anyone's action :giggle:

[Old guy]

Ashwin also might get called. Forthe fun of it to see whether a bowler with a clean action can pass the tests.

You kidding me ?until tomorrow it was bcci not targeting narine because he is from ipl and now ashwin who is totally clean bar one match where he imitated narine ?

[King Tendulkar]

Its the end of spin as we know :cantstop: Not one good leggie in cricket at the moment. And now all off spinners getting banned. Will be left with a world full of Ashely Giles type spinners:haha:

[Old guy]

this will force teams to play proper leg spinners for attacking

[kira]

Its the end of spin as we know :cantstop: Not one good leggie in cricket at the moment. And now all off spinners getting banned. Will be left with a world full of Ashely Giles type spinners:haha:

Better to have ashely giles than chuckmal

[Lord]

Better to have ashely giles than chuckmal

I'd rather have other way round.Who wants to see mediocre spinners being smashed happlessly?there got to be a even contest seeing Narine bamboozle batsmen was great,however he did it.Give me that any day

[Old guy]

instead of encouraging chucking make tracks which assists bowlers ..

[Lord]

instead of encouraging chucking make tracks which assists bowlers ..

I'd look to increase limit a bit too for spinners.Not as blatant as Ajmal obviously

[Old guy]

I'd look to increase limit a bit too for spinners.Not as blatant as Ajmal obviously

please do not be fooled by what is happening ...every one getting banned does not proves its impossible to be good off spinner without chucking it only proves neglect of this problem before and how every cricketer was forced to chuck to out do others look at pakistan they banned more than 10 bowlers and reported more than 20! but only after what happened now ..why not do it before ? swann did not chucked and was better than ajmal in many ways..

[Lord]

please do not be fooled by what is happening ...every one getting banned does not proves its impossible to be good off spinner without chucking it only proves neglect of this problem before and how every cricketer was forced to chuck to out do others look at pakistan they banned more than 10 bowlers and reported more than 20! but only after what happened now ..why not do it before ? swann did not chucked and was better than ajmal in many ways..

Swann was an exception more than norm.Other clean offies struggle big time unless its a turner. Its possible to be good spin bowler without chucking.But same you can score runs without switch hit,dilscoops etc.Ban them too then. In the end you want balance between bat and ball and existence of star bowlers. They raised the limit from 5 to 15 but it seems its not enough for spinners.Especially doosra.I say raise it a little to see if doosra can be bowled in that limit.

[JaFanatic]

BCCI :two_thumbs_up:

[JaFanatic]

Swann was an exception more than norm.Other clean offies struggle big time unless its a turner. Its possible to be good spin bowler without chucking.But same you can score runs without switch hit,dilscoops etc.Ban them too then. In the end you want balance between bat and ball and existence of star bowlers. They raised the limit from 5 to 15 but it seems its not enough for spinners.Especially doosra.I say raise it a little to see if doosra can be bowled in that limit.

Saqlain Mushtaq did not chuck for doosras know

[kira]

I'd rather have other way round.Who wants to see mediocre spinners being smashed happlessly?there got to be a even contest seeing Narine bamboozle batsmen was great,however he did it.Give me that any day

We are not playing baseball. If you chuck you are not a Bowler

[Old guy]

Swann was an exception more than norm.Other clean offies struggle big time unless its a turner. Its possible to be good spin bowler without chucking.But same you can score runs without switch hit,dilscoops etc.Ban them too then. In the end you want balance between bat and ball and existence of star bowlers. They raised the limit from 5 to 15 but it seems its not enough for spinners.Especially doosra.I say raise it a little to see if doosra can be bowled in that limit.

dude you can turn the ball away legally too but it wont have that much rip or spin and problem here with most bwolers is that their quicker ball is suspect like in case of samules and also narine and in case of ajmal and senanayake every ball they bowled was suspect! recent chucking we seen does not proves bowling off spin is impossible it only shows how ignoring it lead to wide spread chucking . you can still bowl without chucking but why should you if chucking gives you advantage ? why is that some countries who ban chuckers at domestic level have no problem right now while others are banning 2 dozen bowlers ?!

[Old guy]

basically this hardly makes the point of allowing more bend...this only shows boards like PCB and WICB need to be lot more strict and weed out chuckers at school level ,under 17 level and under 19 level so that they can produce proper bowlers who can be effective without bending arm make swann like bowlers a norm its totally possible he was not freak his arm worked just like every other guy! only difference is system he came out of :)

[rkt.india]

A bit of chucking on doosra is fine, but problem gets bigger when normal off spinners are chucked big time.

[Lord]

dude you can turn the ball away legally too but it wont have that much rip or spin and problem here with most bwolers is that their quicker ball is suspect like in case of samules and also narine and in case of ajmal and senanayake every ball they bowled was suspect! recent chucking we seen does not proves bowling off spin is impossible it only shows how ignoring it lead to wide spread chucking . you can still bowl without chucking but why should you if chucking gives you advantage ? why is that some countries who ban chuckers at domestic level have no problem right now while others are banning 2 dozen bowlers ?!

The other countries that banned it are also unable to produce a good world class offie except Swann. Ofcourse bowling off spin is possible but it'll be only be a defensive option as batsmen can play them all day long.You won't see them troubling any good batsmen unless pitches are friendly.Even then only some can do it.

[Old guy]

A bit of chucking on doosra is fine' date=' but problem gets bigger when normal off spinners are chucked big time.[/quote'] that is exactly what is happening right now and bi of chucking iwll not even be reported going over 15 to 20 sometimes is understandable and i do not even think you get banned for bowling 1 odd deliver like that if average is much lower. but what we saw recently was complete joke with bowlers literally throwing deliveries

[Lord]

Saqlain Mushtaq did not chuck for doosras know

Was he ever tested?how many degrees did he straighten his arm by?

[beetle]

Finally.....aaya onth pahaad ke neeche!!!!:yay: