Jump to content

Is there more to Rohtak sisters' story than they claim?


Recommended Posts

Posted
well guess what' date='a new video has come out now,in favour of the girls[/quote'] Are you talking about video of boys apologising and beaten by family ?
Posted
maybe its men from haryana who migrate to pune and bangalore and indulge in such things?
No. Haryana is one of the more prosperous states. Mostly the educated folks working in IT etc would go to Pune, Bangalore. IT folks don't indulge in such things.
Posted
So far I have not seen any woman on TV supporting girls version of story. And the anger in this thread is toward media and not toward innocent girls or women.English media has almost blacked out the news since the boys version came out
Now you know how big a hypocrite Arnab Goswami is.
Posted
Now you know how big a hypocrite Arnab Goswami is.
Now he cannot take a side, shout with conviction and righteous anger. He has to tread a fine line between taking the girls side and the boys side, but that doesn't suit his show's format so he ignores it, poor arnab :haha:
Posted
Now he cannot take a side' date=' shout with conviction and righteous anger. He has to tread a fine line between taking the girls side and the boys side, but that doesn't suit his show's format so he ignores it, poor arnab :haha:[/quote'] :haha: Also has to accept that he was wrong earlier, that doesn't suit the format either.
Posted
DM dood' date=' I wouldn't say Beetle di is wrong but she is giving her gut response, out of representativeness heuristic. A distortion of facts tend to appear while trying to take a side in a case as vague as this topic. There is no risk of antagonization when people speak out of personal experiance.[/quote'] The essential gist of her post was - "We need more such women to beat up mean irrespective of what the situation is to drive fear into men". I can assure you that this will not only suppress the actual cases but also will lead to marginalization. It's happened far too many times in history to fall for that again. The vagueness of the case doesn't give a free pass to support illegal acts.
Posted
Now you know how big a hypocrite Arnab Goswami is.
Now he cannot take a side' date=' shout with conviction and righteous anger. He has to tread a fine line between taking the girls side and the boys side, but that doesn't suit his show's format so he ignores it, poor arnab :haha:[/quote']
Posted
You are making the very people whom you are against you, to succeed by loss of hope. OTOH, you are also making the people who are on your side to doubt your rationale. In terms of antagonization, don't draw a line between the real-virtual worlds. After all, it is just the medium that changes - the manifestation of thoughts are still in your (sub)conscious mind. Our thoughts don't change according to the medium - the tone/emphasis might be different but you'd still say your mind on phone versus in person. I speak as well wisher and active supporter of the women who face regular oppression. That's my last word on this topic. :)
plenty of last words DM.....
Posted

Though the case need to be investigated properly without any fear or favor but even if it turns out to be true that boys were indeed harassing d girls it can not be made an ideal case of instant justice by assaulting the accused.... Not that I m a gender biased or misogynist and trying to take side of accused... It is because if the boys r really bullish and r on there way to just misbehave the girls den in this case they would not allow their machoness to be hurt by merely a few slaps from abala nari.... Remember they r no gentle men and weaker sex would ultimately be d victim (if not always atleast most of d time)... We as a society r not sensitive enough to get into someone else's feud and fight with d unjust until it doesn't concern us... When people don't give a damn about d verbal argument happening in front of der eyes why wd they interfere in d others physical dispute? ... Fear of repercussions must be der but can only b instilled by d enlightenment of society as a whole.

Posted
The essential gist of her post was - "We need more such women to beat up mean irrespective of what the situation is to drive fear into men". I can assure you that this will not only suppress the actual cases but also will lead to marginalization. It's happened far too many times in history to fall for that again. The vagueness of the case doesn't give a free pass to support illegal acts.
Agree. I am just explaining beetle's state of mind. It's just coming out of anger. I wish she could understand your point. I quite like the gist though. Similar to the plot of the movie Inglorious Bastards, "Kill random Nazi soldiers to strike fear into the Third Reich". :winky:
Posted
good grief our media must the truly the worse in the world. All this highlights in todays world you have to be very careful with what you do.
the worrysome part is that its not just the small,irrelevant media channels but massive channels like ndtv,cnn,times etc who jumped the gun and glorified the girl to no end.there is very low credibility in our msm
Posted
the worrysome part is that its not just the small' date='irrelevant media channels but massive channels like ndtv,cnn,times etc who jumped the gun and glorified the girl to no end.there is very low credibility in our msm[/quote'] have to say in the uk the print media is **** probably worse than the indian media however the TV is heavily regulated as is radio.
Posted
Agree. I am just explaining beetle's state of mind. It's just coming out of anger. I wish she could understand your point. I quite like the gist though. Similar to the plot of the movie Inglorious Bastards, "Kill random Nazi soldiers to strike fear into the Third Reich". :winky:
Is Beetle a girl. So far on ICF (4 years of reading), i always thought of her as a male.:--D
Posted
Is Beetle a girl. So far on ICF (4 years of reading), i always thought of her as a male.:--D
typical Haryanvi male mentality..... for shame
×
×
  • Create New...