HippoSucks Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 Some of your justification are just out of this world. India don't deserve to win because Australia declared twice hence critical umpires decision is key moments are accepted. In some other place..you also said when another Indian batsman was given LBW wrongly..that since it was a slog sweep he deserve to be given LBW. The bottom line is that Australia got a lot of bad calls in their favor. That also when India was getting into a position of strength. We can do what ifs...but atleast I am sure that no team can take 10 - 12 bad decisions from umpires specially at key moment and expect to win specially on away tours. That's why I expect the umpires to fix that...during India home stretch. I will have no sympathy for the opposition now if they get 10+ bad calls against them vs 1-2 in their favor when they tour India & lose that way. And you completely ignore the bad calls against Australia? Kohli being given not out wrongly is much worse for Australia than is Saha getting out wrongly for India. Also, the umpires are just that - umpires. They don't have technologically advanced eyes allowing them to see everything. Get DRS if you are so annoyed at these wrong decisions, which are now supposedly due to favoritism. By the way, Erasmus in South African. Why would he have any partiality towards Australia? If anything, they would be partial towards India.
rajmarie Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 And you completely ignore the bad calls against Australia? Kohli being given not out wrongly is much worse for Australia than is Saha getting out wrongly for India. Also, the umpires are just that - umpires. They don't have technologically advanced eyes allowing them to see everything. Get DRS if you are so annoyed at these wrong decisions, which are now supposedly due to favoritism. By the way, Erasmus in South African. Why would he have any partiality towards Australia? If anything, they would be partial towards India. Yes yes...I will go out to Walmart and get DRS. hopefully it fixes the wrong decision that is given to my team in every innings.
HippoSucks Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 Yes yes...I will go out to Walmart and get DRS. hopefully it fixes the wrong decision that is given to my team in every innings. And it will fix the the wrong decisions against Australia which are less in number, but of more important batsman.
rajmarie Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 And it will fix the the wrong decisions against Australia which are less in number' date=' but of more important batsman.[/quote'] 1st...thanks for accepting that Australia got quite a lot of wrong decisions in their favor...vs India. 2nd...which important batsman got wrong decision and when?
zep1706 Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 I strongly disagree with this name change. The purpose of this thread was to highlight the umpiring mistakes and to underscore the point that lack of DRS has been hurting India in overseas test matches. What the hell is finelg corner? :whack::hitler:
putrevus Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 what is this thread doing in fineleg corner, whoever merged it has no common sense.
HippoSucks Posted January 8, 2015 Posted January 8, 2015 1st...thanks for accepting that Australia got quite a lot of wrong decisions in their favor...vs India. 2nd...which important batsman got wrong decision and when? It is obvious Australia got a few less wrong decisions against them, but they missed out on century makers.
zep1706 Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 wat the duck :mad: I am using your OP to open a new thread. It is important. I would however not include the Rohit's no ball as I think it was not conclusive enough to call a no ball.
zep1706 Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Glaring umpiring decisions- India in Australia 2014/15 Credit goes to cricket_hacker who opened the original thread. Somehow it got merged with an exiting thread for no reason. So I am using his original post to open a new thread. to record decisions on both sides Against India 1st test Saha wrongly given bat-pad Warner not given caught down the leg side Dhawan wrongly gloved against a bouncer Rahane wrongly given bat-pad 2nd test Pujara given caught behind off the glove when the ball clearly hit the helmet Aaron no inside edge given caught Ashwin no inside edge 3rd test Rahane wrongly given LBW on 147 while sweeping,ball missed off(Dharmasena),broke 262 run partnership and led to a collapse Murali VIjay wrongly given out lbw when ball was clearly sliding down leg at a crucial junction in the match.(dharmasena again) 4th test 4th test Rahane was not out. Given out LBW but the ball was too high. Bhuvi was wrongly given out caught behind by the third umpire. Against Australia First test "Lyon to Vijay, no run, he's padded up on middle stump! And Vijay survives. Lyon is hunched up on the ground, can barely believes Erasmus did not raise the finger. It was a good length ball just a shade outside off, cuts back in to catch a bemused batsman in front of off stump. Would it have slid, would it have bounced? Eagle Eye says it would have hit crashed into leg stump! One-all then" Lyon to Kohli, no run, flighted on middle and he's hit Kohli on the pads in front of middle as he plays the sweep. Huge appeal from Lyon. Erasmus says it would have been high. But EagleEye says impact in line and it was hitting middle! That's another one against the Aussies... Second test None Third test None Forth Test None
zep1706 Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 The score so far is 11-2 against India. I am not including two close dismissals of Rahane and Rohit as those imo were not conclusive enough to call no balls and Haddin's caught behind in the 3rd test for the same reason.
MCGGG Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 If only we had a wicket review system, oh wait.......
Vijy Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 If only we had a wicket review system' date=' oh wait.......[/quote'] :giggle:
MCGGG Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Well Micheal Clarke stood there too when he was caught at first slip against Kumble in 2007-08, whole channel nine crew was defending him then, Andrew Symonds, remember in the same series which changed whole series on its head. Ricky Ponting in world cup stood like a statue when he hit the cover off the ball and later defended he always waits for umpire to give him out. Stop this hypocrisy Broad did nothing wrong then he was doing what Aussies have been doing for ages and getting away with and defending it as some sort of birth right. But the moment shoes was on the other side whole fricking country including prime minister was whining. Just because India does not use DRS , it does not mean umpires have license to screw it. It is same bloody hypocrisy I see from every media outlet when it comes to Indian bowling, if Aussies score runs it is due to great batting but moment Indian batsmen start scoring pitch always all of sudden becomes flat. Not sure if you actually bothered to read my post but I said I didn't get the hate for Broad, and you never walk in any situation IMO.
brendan07 Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 So let's not talk about tbe howler we got against Smith...
Vijy Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 Aww... poor Stewie.. but the record is still unbalanced, wouldn't ya say?
Detonator Posted January 9, 2015 Posted January 9, 2015 ^ That looked plumb, but a really faint inside edge. but okay, that evens out with Bhuvi's howler.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now