Replacement for saha watch thread

[vishalvirsingh]

Parthiv is a cool batsman but with his small height wont have the right reach as a wicket keeper and that could be costly..... saha was keeping wonderfully ...one umesh yadav down the leg grab was out of the world. I am convinced that saha is a better keeper than DHoni though as a batsman he has not succeeded in tests............ we have to give him time.... some more time to succeed.

[tweaker]

Bhogle & Manjrekar are of the view that Saha should bat below Ashwin.I think this suggestion is very ridiculous.Saha should be given 2-3 more tests ,if he is not able to improve his batting,Ojha should be selected in his place

[Forever Indian]

On 15/06/2015 at 11:04 AM, Forever Indian said:

If Pappu Patel's keeping has improved then I would play him. He is currently playing as an opener for Gujarat in tests, so if he comes in at no.6 or 7 he will be well suited to face the second new ball. He is a good player of fast bowling and plays the short ball decently, so will be ideal overseas. But the big question is, has his keeping improved?

Said this a year and a half back. But his keeping will keep him out of being played as a regular keeper.

[maniac]

1 word "PANT"