Uproar against Aleem Dar

[Stuge]

 

 

Note :

 

As the Soft Signal was out, and TV umpire stays with the on field umpire if there is not much conclusive evidence to reverse the decision . Commentators were of the opinion ,since video is aired in 2D ,its very difficult for the umpires to give a decision .

 

https://sportscafe.in/articles/cricket/2019/jun/24/twitterati-slam-aleem-dars-third-umpiring-after-giving-liton-das-and-soumya-sarkar

 

 

 

Edited June 25, 2019 by Stuge

[Asim]

Soft-signal was out, stayed out? What's wrong then, fingers looks beneath or at least no Clear evidence to declare against on-field call...

I think even that Tahir catch was looking more out, def if on-field call was out then...

 

(Btw soft-signal doesn't make much sense most of the times, if umpire have no clue what happened 60m far, why they still must have to give a call which def affects the final decision)

[Oldhere]

Tahir catch was not out but over the last 3 yrs or so Aleem dar has made lot of mistakes from his earlier standards

[maniac]

Aleem Dar’s umpiring quality has gone down ever since he started looking like a guy straight out of the opium fields  of Afghanistan or in other words streets of Bradford. 

 

Cant trust this guy. Clearly has crusade on his mind.

[Crookbond]

7 hours ago, Asim said:

Soft-signal was out, stayed out? What's wrong then, fingers looks beneath or at least no Clear evidence to declare against on-field call...

I think even that Tahir catch was looking more out, def if on-field call was out then...

 

(Btw soft-signal doesn't make much sense most of the times, if umpire have no clue what happened 60m far, why they still must have to give a call which def affects the final decision)

The soft signal is like a fall back if technology is inconclusive. In that case, the situation falls in the hands of the umpire.

[Aiden]

That was out. Benefit of doubt always goes to batsman. Dont like it then change the rules.

[Deleted_User_1]

10 hours ago, maniac said:

Aleem Dar’s umpiring quality has gone down ever since he started looking like a guy straight out of the opium fields  of Afghanistan or in other words streets of Bradford. 

 

Cant trust this guy. Clearly has crusade on his mind.

Aleem was trying hard to deflect any suspicion that he could be favoring a fellow Mussel man!

 

(j/k)

Edited June 26, 2019 by Audiophile

[First class]

I think he has been the best umpire over last decade. 

[chewy]

That SL umpire has been the worst in this world cup