Jump to content

Shubhman Gill Captaincy effect…


Recommended Posts

Posted

He is 26, most senior player is Jaddu and even he isnt playing next test. 2 sides he leads almost everyone is fighting to keep their position. Lets not criticize for the sake of criticizing.

Posted
On 5/20/2026 at 6:21 PM, vvvslaxman said:

He has got the team he wanted. GT team for tests. Let us see how he goes.

Most of the GT team players are now selected for team India test ,odi ,T20 also A team.

 

Gill

Sudarshan 

Sundar 

Siraj 

Prasidh 

Suthar 

Arshad 

Gurnoor 

Ashok 

Kumar Kushagra 

Posted
1 hour ago, tweaker said:

Most of the GT team players are now selected for team India test ,odi ,T20 also A team.

 

Gill

Sudarshan 

Sundar 

Siraj 

Prasidh 

Suthar 

Arshad 

Gurnoor 

Ashok 

Kumar Kushagra 

Sai and Arshad are not good enough  that is purely a favoritism selection. Prasidh is okay for Tests only, and the same goes for Sundar. Gurnoor did well in the previous a series and started well internationally The same goes for Suthar. Ashok is a good prospect for India  but he is in the wrong IPL team. Kumar Kushagra has a good List A career better than Tilak and Badoni in 50 over format. Honestly  he deserves a spot more than Tilak and Badoni for this tournament

Posted
7 hours ago, tweaker said:

Most of the GT team players are now selected for team India test ,odi ,T20 also A team.

 

Gill

Sudarshan 

Sundar 

Siraj 

Prasidh 

Suthar 

Arshad 

Gurnoor 

Ashok 

Kumar Kushagra 

 

Sad that this is what we've become. If you don't play for the "right" IPL team, you've no chance. Likes of Sarfaraz, Auqib will never truly get a chance and even likes of Axar will be sidelined in favor of poorer options like Sundar :((

Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, Vk1 said:

picking arshad is peaks of IPL team bias

Arshad is a good pick, he is the only bowler who bowls 140+ kmph and can bat hit 4/6,need to develop such bowler too for white-ball.

 

He is not #1/2 bowler but #3 bowler , any match pandaya does not play in white-ball Ind batting end at 5 and even with him it ends at #6.

Need bowler who can bat a bit, hang around stitch small partnership and can hit 4/6 when needed.

 

Edited by tapandrun
Posted
19 hours ago, tapandrun said:

Arshad is a good pick, he is the only bowler who bowls 140+ kmph and can bat hit 4/6,need to develop such bowler too for white-ball.

 

He is not #1/2 bowler but #3 bowler , any match pandaya does not play in white-ball Ind batting end at 5 and even with him it ends at #6.

Need bowler who can bat a bit, hang around stitch small partnership and can hit 4/6 when needed.

 

Bowlers have to be selected first on their primary skill. Once you start selecting bowlers on so called ability to bat, you will be losing on both ends.

Posted
1 hour ago, putrevus said:

Bowlers have to be selected first on their primary skill. Once you start selecting bowlers on so called ability to bat, you will be losing on both ends.

Yes thats why they are giving him chance to develop, he is not that far off from other 2 pacers selected in the A side. If the primary skill of 5 players are similar level then try to develop the player with some secondary skill they can be more useful and provide balance.

Posted
3 minutes ago, tapandrun said:

Yes thats why they are giving him chance to develop, he is not that far off from other 2 pacers selected in the A side. If the primary skill of 5 players are similar level then try to develop the player with some secondary skill they can be more useful and provide balance.

He is already 28 with just 5 FC matches.I doubt he has much future.

 

 

Posted
2 minutes ago, putrevus said:

He is already 28 with just 5 FC matches.I doubt he has much future.

 

 

Bowler with pace does not make it to the playing 11 in domestics , he should be looked as stop gap and can be used there are only 3 LA pacers with 140+ kmph pace.

Him, MIshra and Naman.

 

Then there is tried and tested khaleel who does not seem to improve on anything but keeps making come-backs just because he os LA pacer

Posted
21 hours ago, tapandrun said:

Arshad is a good pick, he is the only bowler who bowls 140+ kmph and can bat hit 4/6,need to develop such bowler too for white-ball.

 

He is not #1/2 bowler but #3 bowler , any match pandaya does not play in white-ball Ind batting end at 5 and even with him it ends at #6.

Need bowler who can bat a bit, hang around stitch small partnership and can hit 4/6 when needed.

 

I don't think we can risk having Arshad like bowlers who are below par in their main skill. Arshad's batting is just a bonus addition nothing more.

Posted
36 minutes ago, Vk1 said:

I don't think we can risk having Arshad like bowlers who are below par in their main skill. Arshad's batting is just a bonus addition nothing more.

We got rana 

Posted
17 hours ago, Manucrick said:

We got rana 

yes rana is tier 1 level.. can't say about this guy.

Posted
23 hours ago, Manucrick said:

We got rana 

Arshad is being tried as a LA option, in addition to being LA pacer who bowls 140+kmph he can bat a bit.

 

Ind does not have many options in this area -- Naman, Mukesh, Mishra, Gurjap, Mohsin

 

Gurjap does not have the pace, Mishra and Mukesh will be nearly same age as Arshad and Naman is new, Mohsin is not even fit to play t20 not sure he has fitness to play Odis . Then there is khaleel.

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...