Sooda Posted October 8, 2009 Posted October 8, 2009 Gavaskar was more than flattering in his praise for his brother-in-law. I have had the privilege to watch both play in their prime' date=' and Gavaskar was waaaaaayyy more classy overall than Vishy could ever be. Granted that Vishy played the off side shots with more style, more so the square cut, however as an overall package I would choose Gavaskar to bat for my life anyday AND as a classier batsman.[/quote'] Hmm yeah, I did always suspect that SG was going a bit OTT with his praise on that one. Vengsarkars problem is that he was bit of an FTB, I think Im right in saying the only tons he scored overseas are the three he scored at Lords. I think thats 14 of his 17 centuries in India. Id say The Lax Man was a a little bit ahead in the stakes
putrevus Posted August 7, 2010 Posted August 7, 2010 I dont think VVS is 5th best indian batsmen ever.even Vengarkar would have stronger case Vengy and laxman have lot in common both them underachieved in my book, both of them were middle order batsmen who to get in team started as openers and failed.That really knocked their averages under fifty.Both them played under shadows of greater batsmen of their times vengy under Sunny and Vishy.Laxman under Sachin and Dravid. Both were stroke makers who were bit lose in their stroke play early in their careers,Vengy had higher peak than laxman but that lasted for 18 months after that he was never the same. Laxman in last 67 test matches averages almost 50 with 11 hundreds that too batting at no 6 most of the time has been more consistent and is more a match winner than Vengy. Laxman off late has become model of consistency doesn't have many hundreds to show for as he had to bat with tail lot of times,Dravid always has said I wish i had Laxman shot making ability. He is perfect No 5 Batsmen for India as he blends his experience with youth following him in order.Even if Dravid retires he should stay at no5 .
Mamu Posted August 7, 2010 Posted August 7, 2010 If Laxman was a biscuit' date=' he would be pure magic. The most underrated and under appreciated Indian batsman of all time. Love him to death.[/quote'] And he has himself to blame for that. Lot of times he looks so stupid, gets out stupidly, sometimes looking completely out of sorts, sometimes you would think this guy is new to cricket. He comes to the crease -- lazily wafting his willow as if this is nets ! As I have said before -- in the long run he has not lived up to his potential!
Sachinism Posted August 7, 2010 Posted August 7, 2010 laxman when he's 50 :cantstop::cantstop::cantstop:
Mamu Posted August 8, 2010 Posted August 8, 2010 Vengy and laxman have lot in common both them underachieved in my book, both of them were middle order batsmen who to get in team started as openers and failed.That really knocked their averages under fifty.Both them played under shadows of greater batsmen of their times vengy under Sunny and Vishy.Laxman under Sachin and Dravid. Both were stroke makers who were bit lose in their stroke play early in their careers,Vengy had higher peak than laxman but that lasted for 18 months after that he was never the same. Laxman in last 67 test matches averages almost 50 with 11 hundreds that too batting at no 6 most of the time has been more consistent and is more a match winner than Vengy. Laxman off late has become model of consistency doesn't have many hundreds to show for as he had to bat with tail lot of times,Dravid always has said I wish i had Laxman shot making ability. He is perfect No 5 Batsmen for India as he blends his experience with youth following him in order.Even if Dravid retires he should stay at no5 . I would have Laxman, Azhar, Mohinder and Sanjay Manjrekar ahead of Vengsarkar any day. I would even drop Sidhu to MO and have him ahead of Vengsarkar. Vengsarkar's only fame was how he went about mauling the English Bowlers. Nothing besides that.
pensionplan Posted January 4, 2011 Posted January 4, 2011 After the recent spurt of great Test match innings he played over the last few months to go along with an already stellar career VVS has carved a niche for himself and has a special chapter dedicated to him in the annals of Test cricket that extend beyond mere numbers. He is without a doubt an equal to any great Test batsman that have played for India and a case can be made for him to be a top 2-3 ever Test batsman to have played for India.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now