Greatest ODI Players

[SLICKR392]

whats wrong with that??

+1 Ganguly was a good captain. A decent ODI player..nothing great, his S/R says it all. Yuvi has won us way more matches than he has!

[virufan]

Only 1 English player?? Need to add Collingwood, Neil Fairbrother to the list. And no Steve Waugh, Ajay Jadeja?

[Vilander]

Murali Vijay should be no 4. This list sucks :beee:

[Raghav_12]

If OP had managed to keep his obssesive syndrome with Dhoni and hatred with Sachin, it could have been very good list. Still, I would say it's a very good effort. Some changes I would have lliked: Dean Jones should be much ahead than 39. Afridi can move up probably, particularly if you consider that he is still very young Don't know if Younis was that good in ODI's (or may be i still remember Jadeja?) Ganguly should not be that higher up Azhar? If he has been kept out for his role in fixing, than I may agree. else he might be good shout From memory I remember Trescothick was good. Not sure if good enough. Somebody mentioned Fairbrother. I may agree with that. How about Alan Lamb?

[Tendya]

1. Sachin Tendulkar 1. Vivian Richards 3. Sanath Jayasuriya(13k+ runs, 300+wickets) 4. Adam Gilchrist 5. Wasim Akram 6. Inzamam 7. Muralitharan 8. Bevan 9 Mcgrath 10.Brian Lara Among the current lot, 1. Amla 2. Kohli 3. de Villiers

[vvvslaxman]

you might as well have added Vijayakanth to the list

[Rohit S. Ambani]

Lance Klusener @ 34 ? Impact wise he should be in top 20.

[Rameshraja17]

Symonds and Irfan not deserved to be in the list. Shocking to see No mahela Jayawardena..????? WC final centurion... guys like Andy flower , anil kumble , Alec stewart , Darren gough and Heath streak should also be added considering their contribution...

[Rameshraja17]

1. Sachin Tendulkar 1. Vivian Richards 3. Sanath Jayasuriya(13k+ runs, 300+wickets) 4. Adam Gilchrist 5. Wasim Akram 6. Inzamam 7. Muralitharan 8. Bevan 9 Mcgrath 10.Brian Lara Among the current lot, 1. Amla 2. Kohli 3. de Villiers

I liked d way u numbered Both sachin and richards as 1:hatsoff: but Kallis should be somewhere in the top 3 list....

[panther]

batsman 1) viv 2) gordan greendigge 3) gary kirsten 4) andrew symonds 5) saeed anwar

[don_corleone840]

1 Sachin tendulkar 2 Sanath Jaysurya 3 Vivian Richards 4 Glenn Mcgrath 5 Ricky Ponting 6 Ms dhoni 7 Adam Gilchrist 8 Wasim Akram 9 Kapil dev 10 Sourav ganguly

[prinzo]

What about the greatest fielder the game has ever seen Jonty Rhodes?

[rixxuu]

MSD at 2 and Lara at 23? I think Lara is an all time great, atleast deserves to be in top 10 if not top 5...:nervous:

[saket123]

"Greatest ODI players" is as meaningless a term as Greatest Car or Greatest Movie. The criteria, parameters, variables.. all matter.. without which this is just pure mental masturbation.

[The Outsider]

Aadarniye Sri Murali Vijay Ji?

[Rohit S. Ambani]

Your list is outdated, Sachin Tendulkar should be in Top 3.

[JaFanatic]

Your list is outdated' date=' Sachin Tendulkar should be in Top 3.[/quote'] are you taking him seriously:giggle:

[Geoff Boycott]

1. Paul Collingwood

[dangerman1985]

batsman 1) viv 2) gordan greendigge 3) gary kirsten 4) andrew symonds 5) saeed anwar

Tendulkar should be on the top of that list. saeed anwar?:hysterical: what a joke. even ganguly is better than him

[JaFanatic]

Tendulkar should be on the top of that list. saeed anwar?:hysterical: what a joke. even ganguly is better than him

what is that? he is one of the greatest batsman in odi cricket and definitely better than anwar:agree: