We can debate till the mules come home...

[Prakat]

Who has mules?

[Raghav_12]

To be honest, other than Ashwin nobody drops himself out of the playing 11. Zak picked 5 wickets, so did Ishant. They set up the match with their first innings exploits. Shami of course was pick of the bowlers for second innings.

[maniac]

After Ashwin,Dhoni is the only guy who deserves to be dropped :giggle: what the hell exactly did he bring in to the table in this test.

[Raghav_12]

After Ashwin' date='Dhoni is the only guy who deserves to be dropped :giggle: what the hell exactly did he bring in to the table in this test.[/quote'] I had thought of that but resisted from typing lest backlash will ensue. :giggle:

[Sidhoni]

Just making such a thread won't change the fact that it will be the right decision to go with the same 11. He may go in with an extra pacer but that is not necessary.

[rkt.india]

Just making such a thread won't change the fact that it will be the right decision to go with the same 11. He may go in with an extra pacer but that is not necessary.

No, it wont be. We need a bowler who can take wickets in place of Ashwin.

[asterix]

No' date=' it wont be. We need a bowler who can take wickets in place of Ashwin.[/quote'] Fanboys will not understand that... They've developed the Dhobi mentality of a stubborn mule...

[Sidhoni]

No' date=' it wont be. We need a bowler who can take wickets in place of Ashwin.[/quote'] Durban would be better for him. He can also prove handy with the bat if the top order fails.

[rkt.india]

Durban would be better for him. He can also prove handy with the bat if the top order fails.

I doubt with the way he bowled at Wanderers. He did not trouble any batsman, not single appeal. He was no where near taking a wicket. Even Raina would have done better than him.