Jump to content

No PANT but Jaidev & RAINA in Indian T20i team in SOA


Shy9

Recommended Posts

8 minutes ago, raki05 said:

Can you tell me some of his match winning performance in entire 10 yrs and i can name u al other batters around him who atleast won a match single handadly.people talk abt sachin stretching his career unnecessarly. What crediblity and business dhoni have to be in t20 team at this time, what does he wants to proove.

He has been at best around 3rd or 4th best batsman in the side most of his career and also due to playing in lower order. So he fulfills that role as keeper-bat, which is pretty low as per his standard and our expectations.

And as I said, he has been good in last couple of years. I dunno what you mean by what does he wants to prove? I guess he is playing cricket like everyone else in the team. Play and win. 

BTW, I have no issue with him being dropped or others getting a chance as backup. But obviously, our management does not think Pant is in TOP 4 or 5 keepers or else he would have played some games already. 

Link to comment
9 minutes ago, Shunya said:

He has been good in last 2 years. What is wrong in that?

Selective stats. He's good awful in t20s. Look at that SL knock. Rr was 11 and this guy is taking singles and twos. A 12(5) knock would have been better. I guess that's why cricinfo publish a comment 'only Kohli is trying to win the game'. He made some cheap runs against perera when the game was over and now you are shoving stats on me. Dude stop. 

Link to comment
33 minutes ago, Shunya said:

He has been at best around 3rd or 4th best batsman in the side most of his career and also due to playing in lower order. So he fulfills that role as keeper-bat, which is pretty low as per his standard and our expectations.

And as I said, he has been good in last couple of years. I dunno what you mean by what does he wants to prove? I guess he is playing cricket like everyone else in the team. Play and win. 

BTW, I have no issue with him being dropped or others getting a chance as backup. But obviously, our management does not think Pant is in TOP 4 or 5 keepers or else he would have played some games already. 

What was so good abt his last 2 year in t20. 

Link to comment
13 minutes ago, Laaloo said:

Selective stats. He's good awful in t20s. Look at that SL knock. Rr was 11 and this guy is taking singles and twos. A 12(5) knock would have been better. I guess that's why cricinfo publish a comment 'only Kohli is trying to win the game'. He made some cheap runs against perera when the game was over and now you are shoving stats on me. Dude stop. 

I think you are talking about Newzealand game 

http://www.espncricinfo.com/series/18029/scorecard/1120094/india-vs-new-zealand-2nd-t20i-nz-in-ind-2017-18/

Agreed, Dhoni did not play well in that game and most importantly could not support Virat Kohli earlier in the partnership. But just for the record again, we were 67/4 in 10th over and chasing 197, so probably you wanted him to score 20-25 ball 50 at that point and win us the game and he could not do it and end up only 49(37). But if you have to bring it up to prove that Dhoni is the reason for the loss, than I dunno what to say about your bias.

And what is this perera thing? Stop this nonsense just to put down Dhoni. Does he decide to play against srilanka? or is it that Kohli, Rohit, Pandya, etc all needs to be dropped because they play Srilanka and scored loads of runs. I am sure its not just perera he scored off in last couple of years, ffs stop lying. 

Link to comment
8 minutes ago, Shunya said:

I think you are talking about Newzealand game 

http://www.espncricinfo.com/series/18029/scorecard/1120094/india-vs-new-zealand-2nd-t20i-nz-in-ind-2017-18/

Agreed, Dhoni did not play well in that game and most importantly could not support Virat Kohli earlier in the partnership. But just for the record again, we were 67/4 in 10th over and chasing 197, so probably you wanted him to score 20-25 ball 50 at that point and win us the game and he could not do it and end up only 49(37). But if you have to bring it up to prove that Dhoni is the reason for the loss, than I dunno what to say about your bias.

And what is this perera thing? Stop this nonsense just to put down Dhoni. Does he decide to play against srilanka? or is it that Kohli, Rohit, Pandya, etc all needs to be dropped because they play Srilanka and scored loads of runs. I am sure its not just perera he scored off in last couple of years, ffs stop lying. 

I'm not blaming him for the loss but his innings was pathetic. When Kohli was there we had a chance at an improbable win. Dhoni didn't do jackshit when the match was alive. That's dhoni in a nutshell in t20s. How am I lying about perera? Even in that Eden gardens odi, kuldeep Yadav faced more balls against lakmal than dhoni and looked more assured. Dhoni got some cheap runs at the end and viola oh look he's not a ftb.

 

 

Regarding that t20, I wanted him to do more than 28(28)* at one point. Is that so hard to do when the rrr is more than 12.  Show some intent instead of playing for not outs. Tu chamchagiri karta reh. 

 

Facts are bitter sorry. 

Link to comment
49 minutes ago, Laaloo said:

Selective stats. He's good awful in t20s. Look at that SL knock. Rr was 11 and this guy is taking singles and twos. A 12(5) knock would have been better. I guess that's why cricinfo publish a comment 'only Kohli is trying to win the game'. He made some cheap runs against perera when the game was over and now you are shoving stats on me. Dude stop. 

if only they inflated India's batting totals by the same factor that Dhoni's average gets inflated by *not outs we would have won all those games

Edited by mancalledsting
Link to comment
35 minutes ago, Laaloo said:

I'm not blaming him for the loss but his innings was pathetic. When Kohli was there we had a chance at an improbable win. Dhoni didn't do jackshit when the match was alive. That's dhoni in a nutshell in t20s. How am I lying about perera? Even in that Eden gardens odi, kuldeep Yadav faced more balls against lakmal than dhoni and looked more assured. Dhoni got some cheap runs at the end and viola oh look he's not a ftb.

 

 

Regarding that t20, I wanted him to do more than 28(28)* at one point. Is that so hard to do when the rrr is more than 12.  Show some intent instead of playing for not outs. Tu chamchagiri karta reh. 

 

Facts are bitter sorry. 

Right, he should have done more than that to make us win. But knowing you, you would have then said that he scored cheap runs. Fact is he is not as good as he is in ODIs but he is not as bad as you want to portray. Over exaggarating and lying is not going to change those facts.  

These are the numbers for Indian batsman in last 2 years and he would have scored max 30 odd runs against Perera out of those 479 which you were shamelessly trying to lie to put him down. 

Overall figures
Player Span Mat Inns NO RunsDescending HS Ave BF SR 100 50 0 4s 6s  
V Kohli 2016-2017 24 22 8 850 89* 60.71 598 142.14 0 8 1 93 15 investigate this query
RG Sharma 2016-2017 26 26 1 749 118 29.96 523 143.21 1 5 2 71 34 investigate this query
MS Dhoni 2016-2017 33 27 16 479 56 43.54 338 141.71 0 1 0 34 17 investigate this query
KL Rahul 2016-2017 12 11 2 458 110* 50.88 310 147.74 1 3 1 41 20 investigate this query
S Dhawan 2016-2017 19 19 3 423 80 26.43 340 124.41 0 3 0 54 12 investigate this query
SK Raina 2016-2017 18 14 2 283 63 23.58 218 129.81 0 1 1 24 10 investigate this query
MK Pandey 2016-2017 13 10 3 220 51* 31.42 169 130.17 0 1 1 13 8 investigate this query
Yuvraj Singh 2016-2017 17 14 3 209 35 19.00 194 107.73 0 0 1 16 11 investigate this query
HH Pandya 2016-2017 26 16 1 154 31 10.26 119 129.41 0 0 2 8 8 investigate this query
KM Jadhav 2016-2017 7 4 0 108 58 27.00 86 125.58 0 1 0 11 3 investigate this query
AM Rahane 2016-2016 7 7 2 102 40 20.40 96 106.25 0 0 1 8 0 investigate this query

 

Dhoni does not need chamchagiri. Indian cricket fan knows his worth. Not everyone hates their own players and wishes bad for them like you and your gang do. 

Link to comment
Runs Mins BF 4s 6s SR Pos Dismissal Inns   Opposition Ground Start DateAscending  
0 8 2 0 0 0.00 4 bowled 2   v South Africa Johannesburg 1 Dec 2006 T20I # 10
TDNB - - - - - - - -   v Scotland Durban 13 Sep 2007 T20I # 26
33 46 31 3 1 106.45 6 caught 1   v Pakistan Durban 14 Sep 2007 T20I # 29
24 31 20 2 0 120.00 4 run out 2   v New Zealand Johannesburg 16 Sep 2007 T20I # 32
10* 22 8 0 0 125.00 4 not out 1   v England Durban 19 Sep 2007 T20I # 40
45 39 33 4 1 136.36 6 run out 1   v South Africa Durban 20 Sep 2007 T20I # 43
36 21 18 4 1 200.00 5 run out 1   v Australia Durban 22 Sep 2007 T20I # 45
6 9 10 0 0 60.00 5 bowled 1   v Pakistan Johannesburg 24 Sep 2007 T20I # 46
9* 11 5 0 1 180.00 5 not out 2   v Australia Mumbai (BS) 20 Oct 2007 T20I # 47
9 30 27 0 0 33.33 6 caught 1   v Australia Melbourne 1 Feb 2008 T20I # 52
13 17 17 1 0 76.47 5 bowled 2   v Sri Lanka Colombo (RPS) 10 Feb 2009 T20I # 82
2 5 6 0 0 33.33 6 bowled 1   v New Zealand Christchurch 25 Feb 2009 T20I # 84
28* 57 30 2 0 93.33 5 not out 1   v New Zealand Wellington 27 Feb 2009 T20I # 85
26 26 21 0 1 123.80 3 bowled 1   v Bangladesh Nottingham 6 Jun 2009 T20I # 93
14 9 13 1 0 107.69 3 caught 2   v Ireland Nottingham 10 Jun 2009 T20I # 101
11 24 23 0 0 47.82 5 caught 1   v West Indies Lord's 12 Jun 2009 T20I # 105
30* 33 20 3 0 150.00 6 not out 2   v England Lord's 14 Jun 2009 T20I # 109
5 11 12 0 0 41.66 5 run out 2   v South Africa Nottingham 16 Jun 2009 T20I # 113
9 - 12 0 0 75.00 3 caught 2   v Sri Lanka Nagpur 9 Dec 2009 T20I # 126
46 55 28 3 2 164.28 3 bowled 2   v Sri Lanka Mohali 12 Dec 2009 T20I # 127
15* 2 6 0 2 250.00 5 not out 2   v Afghanistan Gros Islet 1 May 2010 T20I # 153
16* 6 6 1 1 266.66 6 not out 1   v South Africa Gros Islet 2 May 2010 T20I # 155
2 10 8 0 0 25.00 6 caught 2   v Australia Bridgetown 7 May 2010 T20I # 165
29 30 18 2 2 161.11 6 run out 2   v West Indies Bridgetown 9 May 2010 T20I # 169
23* 43 19 0 1 121.05 4 not out 1   v Sri Lanka Gros Islet 11 May 2010 T20I # 173
10* 19 11 0 0 90.90 7 not out 1   v South Africa Durban 9 Jan 2011 T20I # 196
8 15 8 1 0 100.00 7 caught 1   v England Manchester 31 Aug 2011 T20I # 204
21 44 26 0 1 80.76 6 run out 1   v England Kolkata 29 Oct 2011 T20I # 214
48* 55 43 1 3 111.62 6 not out 2   v Australia Sydney 1 Feb 2012 T20I # 217
21* 26 18 2 0 116.66 4 not out 2   v Australia Melbourne 3 Feb 2012 T20I # 218
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v South Africa Johannesburg 30 Mar 2012 T20I # 242
16* 13 14 2 0 114.28 5 not out 1   v Sri Lanka Pallekele 7 Aug 2012 T20I # 255
22* 31 23 2 0 95.65 5 not out 2   v New Zealand Chennai 11 Sep 2012 T20I # 261
18* 21 9 2 1 200.00 6 not out 1   v Afghanistan Colombo (RPS) 19 Sep 2012 T20I # 265
9 23 8 1 0 112.50 5 caught 1   v England Colombo (RPS) 23 Sep 2012 T20I # 272
15 21 21 2 0 71.42 7 caught 1   v Australia Colombo (RPS) 28 Sep 2012 T20I # 278
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Pakistan Colombo (RPS) 30 Sep 2012 T20I # 282
23* 20 13 3 0 176.92 7 not out 1   v South Africa Colombo (RPS) 2 Oct 2012 T20I # 286
24* 29 21 2 0 114.28 6 not out 2   v England Pune 20 Dec 2012 T20I # 292
38 23 18 3 2 211.11 7 caught 1   v England Mumbai 22 Dec 2012 T20I # 294
1 7 2 0 0 50.00 5 bowled 1   v Pakistan Bengaluru 25 Dec 2012 T20I # 296
33 39 23 4 0 143.47 5 bowled 1   v Pakistan Ahmedabad 28 Dec 2012 T20I # 298
24* 44 21 2 0 114.28 6 not out 2   v Australia Rajkot 10 Oct 2013 T20I # 331
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Pakistan Dhaka 21 Mar 2014 T20I # 378
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v West Indies Dhaka 23 Mar 2014 T20I # 382
22* 16 12 1 2 183.33 4 not out 2   v Bangladesh Dhaka 28 Mar 2014 T20I # 389
24 36 20 1 1 120.00 6 bowled 1   v Australia Dhaka 30 Mar 2014 T20I # 393
0* 3 1 0 0 0.00 6 not out 2   v South Africa Dhaka 4 Apr 2014 T20I # 399
4* 10 7 0 0 57.14 5 not out 1   v Sri Lanka Dhaka 6 Apr 2014 T20I # 400
27* 35 18 2 1 150.00 5 not out 2   v England Birmingham 7 Sep 2014 T20I # 405
20* 22 12 2 1 166.66 5 not out 1   v South Africa Dharamsala 2 Oct 2015 T20I # 456
5 20 8 0 0 62.50 6 caught 1   v South Africa Cuttack 5 Oct 2015 T20I # 457
11* 3 3 1 1 366.66 5 not out 1   v Australia Adelaide 26 Jan 2016 T20I # 485
14 18 9 2 0 155.55 4 caught 1   v Australia Melbourne 29 Jan 2016 T20I # 486
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Australia Sydney 31 Jan 2016 T20I # 489
2 2 2 0 0 100.00 6 caught 1   v Sri Lanka Pune 9 Feb 2016 T20I # 496
9* - 5 1 0 180.00 6 not out 1   v Sri Lanka Ranchi 12 Feb 2016 T20I # 497
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Sri Lanka Visakhapatnam 14 Feb 2016 T20I # 499
8* 4 2 0 1 400.00 7 not out 1   v Bangladesh Dhaka 24 Feb 2016 T20I # 509
7* 6 3 1 0 233.33 7 not out 2   v Pakistan Dhaka 27 Feb 2016 T20I # 512
7* 7 4 0 1 175.00 7 not out 2   v Sri Lanka Dhaka 1 Mar 2016 T20I # 515
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v U.A.E. Dhaka 3 Mar 2016 T20I # 517
20* 7 6 1 2 333.33 4 not out 2   v Bangladesh Dhaka 6 Mar 2016 T20I # 521
30 - 30 1 1 100.00 6 caught 2   v New Zealand Nagpur 15 Mar 2016 T20I # 535
13* 15 9 0 1 144.44 6 not out 2   v Pakistan Kolkata 19 Mar 2016 T20I # 541
13* 29 12 1 0 108.33 6 not out 1   v Bangladesh Bengaluru 23 Mar 2016 T20I # 547
18* 29 10 3 0 180.00 6 not out 2   v Australia Mohali 27 Mar 2016 T20I # 553
15* 24 9 1 0 166.66 4 not out 1   v West Indies Mumbai 31 Mar 2016 T20I # 556
19* - 17 1 0 111.76 6 not out 2   v Zimbabwe Harare 18 Jun 2016 T20I # 558
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Zimbabwe Harare 20 Jun 2016 T20I # 559
9 19 13 1 0 69.23 6 bowled 1   v Zimbabwe Harare 22 Jun 2016 T20I # 560
43 53 25 2 2 172.00 5 caught 2   v West Indies Lauderhill 27 Aug 2016 T20I # 562
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v West Indies Lauderhill 28 Aug 2016 T20I # 563
36* 47 27 3 0 133.33 5 not out 1   v England Kanpur 26 Jan 2017 T20I # 592
5 16 7 0 0 71.42 6 bowled 1   v England Nagpur 29 Jan 2017 T20I # 593
56 56 36 5 2 155.55 4 caught 1   v England Bengaluru 1 Feb 2017 T20I # 594
2 - 3 0 0 66.66 5 caught 1   v West Indies Kingston 9 Jul 2017 T20I # 617
1* - 1 0 0 100.00 5 not out 2   v Sri Lanka Colombo (RPS) 6 Sep 2017 T20I # 618
DNB - - - - - - - 2   v Australia Ranchi 7 Oct 2017 T20I # 623
13 24 16 1 0 81.25 6 stumped 1   v Australia Guwahati 10 Oct 2017 T20I # 624
7* 4 2 0 1 350.00 5 not out 1   v New Zealand Delhi 1 Nov 2017 T20I # 630
49 44 37 2 3 132.43 6 caught 2   v New Zealand Rajkot 4 Nov 2017 T20I # 631
0* 3 0 0 0 - 7 not out 1   v New Zealand Thiruvananthapuram 7 Nov 2017 T20I # 632
39* 40 22 4 1 177.27 4 not out 1   v Sri Lanka Cuttack 20 Dec 2017 T20I # 633
28 41 21 2 2 133.33 3 bowled 1   v Sri Lanka Indore 22 Dec 2017 T20I # 634
16* 20 10 2 0 160.00 7 not out 2   v Sri Lanka Mumbai 24 Dec 2017 T20I # 635

 

 

These are all the innings dhoni has played in T20I till now, I have a simple question for dhoni chamchas, out of these 75 innings how many would you consider as good knocks? ( I am already setting the bar too low, I am not even asking for great innings or match winning innings, just good innings)

 

Answer this question honestly and you will see your own bias towards dhoni

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...