Jump to content

RSS Gone Rogue : Bhagwat questioning legitimacy of Hindu texts


Lone Wolf

Recommended Posts

Fact is who the hell is he to challenge anything about our Hindu texts?  Why doesn't he has the guts to speak against others? 

Taking full advantage of Peaceful Hindus now eh? 

Inko kya hi pata chalega. 

 

First he blasts upper castes or Brahmins as they created varna system according his distorted mai baap marxist history. 

 

No wonder British loved these folks. 

VHP should teach these guys a lesson... And it is about time they take over from them.  They are doing all the work at Ground level while RSS is busy milking votes of minorities. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Lone Wolf said:

Fact is who the hell is he to challenge anything about our Hindu texts?  Why doesn't he has the guts to speak against others? 

Taking full advantage of Peaceful Hindus now eh? 

Inko kya hi pata chalega. 

 

First he blasts upper castes or Brahmins as they created varna system according his distorted mai baap marxist history. 

 

No wonder British loved these folks. 

VHP should teach these guys a lesson... And it is about time they take over from them.  They are doing all the work at Ground level while RSS is busy milking votes of minorities. 

 

 

What is wrong in what he said? While, whether he has the authority to talk about scriptures is debatable , he is not holding a gun to accept his opinion.

You can take it or leave it, but nobody can say he has no right to express his opinion. More than our laws, dharma gives him the right as there is no blasphemy in our religion.

 

What he says is accepted by most dharma pandits. Vedas were transmitted orally for 1000s of years orally before we found script . even  after script was invented, it was on dried palm leaves amd other forms , before cloth or paper arrived at India. The unabridged original works of versions puranas, smriti, ithasas like Ramayana and Mahabharata is highly argued and there is no single authority that claims it is theirs that is final. In this context, some of the verses seems to have been introduced later by someone in the last 1000 years or later. Manusmriti also claims that it is not the ultimate text, but needs to be changed or followed as per time and need. It is true that Sanatana dharma is closer to science than any religion as the two are separated. dharma is not against science and dharma can evolve just like darwinian evolution. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sameeksha toh har samay honi chahiye. Har cheez ki honi chahiye. Hum log koi mari-hui sanskriti to hai nahi jo sab kuch pata hai, paa liye aur samajh liye. 

 

Hamari toh manyata yeh hai, ki woh nirakaar aur nirgun hai. Joh aadi se hai aur jiska koi aant nahi..

 

Like Varna paddhati can be explained 3-4 different ways. 

 

1. Feet are Shudra, Stomach area Vaishya, Hands/Shoulders Kshatriya & Head and above head is Bramha.

2. Jaati/Caste by birth is varna paddhati

3. We all are born Shudras first, our feet always tend towards vices. In our freedom we win over those and then phase of Vaishya begins where we seek. Then we graduate to Kshatriya state where real Jihad begins where we win over our vices and finally we attend the state of bramha, we become dwija.

 

There are 2 more interpretations. Now when something is written down, it susceptible interpretation. In my view Jaati/caste system was never meant to be, yet it is there. Sameeksha kyu nahi honi chahiye? 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bhagvat ji is nowadays having talks with Muslims leaders so that difference and grievances of Hindus and Muslims can be resolved. It’s happening since 2019, but the negotiations have been restarted post Covid.

 

I can understand reasoning of RSS that India can not be developed if 20%( Muslims)  of population of India doesn’t develop or get benefited from polices. 
 

I am happy with his above endevour but , offlate a lot of statements he has bren making is part of his negotiation where Muslim leaders are demanding him to make such statement.
But in all fairness, he has to choose his words very  carefully as he is running a risk of loosing his own support base . It also looks ks like borderline appeasement which if continued will undoubtedly be giving rise go another party who will not suppress the Hindu grievances for sake if appeasement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...