Dhoni vs Bhuvi vs Cook vs Anderson- who is the better test batsmen

[CSK Fan]

Arre, please continue on the feeback thread, cannot keep moving posts

[maniac]

Cook,Bhuvi,Anderson,dhoni in that order

[velu]

Cook' date='Bhuvi,Anderson,dhoni in that order[/quote'] its not abt technique .. runs .. test runs scored in the end :giggle:

[Yoda-esque]

its not abt technique .. runs .. test runs scored in the end :giggle:

Manjrekar says hi

[maniac]

its not abt technique .. runs .. test runs scored in the end :giggle:

And how many runs has he been scoring overseas :giggle: No temperament either.....cook is just having a bad patch....joke to compare those 2 Bhuvi is the one we are waiting for,not jaddu or binny. And Anderson is a world class bowler who is a world class night watchman. Dhoni is not even a world class keeper. Yeah dhoni vs cook captaincy is a valid thread....you know me might win that once in a while,so you are better off with that comparison,not at a skill level :icflove:

[maniac]

Can't beleive yodaesque who has been watching cricket forever defends dhoni :headshake: Maybe srt should have been a regional bigot and said mns rules and Mumbai belongs only to maharashtrians,we would see him in love with srt Ps j/k tha bhau

[Sachin=GOD]

And how many runs has he been scoring overseas :giggle: No temperament either.....cook is just having a bad patch....joke to compare those 2 Bhuvi is the one we are waiting for,not jaddu or binny. And Anderson is a world class bowler who is a world class night watchman. Dhoni is not even a world class keeper. Yeah dhoni vs cook captaincy is a valid thread....you know me might win that once in a while,so you are better off with that comparison,not at a skill level :icflove:

Cook never was as good as people made him out to be. If he continues to score badly in the remaining tests of this series then I won't be surprised if he's sacked as Captain and dropped from the team.

[Yoda-esque]

Can't beleive yodaesque who has been watching cricket forever defends dhoni :headshake: Maybe srt should have been a regional bigot and said mns rules and Mumbai belongs only to maharashtrians,we would see him in love with srt Ps j/k tha bhau

Lol ,don't know what you think about me gaaru,but I won't justify my thoughts on myself SRT or MSD to you :icflove:

[maniac]

Cook never was as good as people made him out to be. If he continues to score badly in the remaining tests of this series then I won't be surprised if he's sacked as Captain and dropped from the team.

Comparing cook with other legends like srt,etc was a joke but he is not as bad as he is made out to be either

[Sachin=GOD]

Comparing cook with other legends like srt' date='etc was a joke but he is not as bad as he is made out to be either[/quote'] Its only in the last few months that people have been calling him crap. Before that almost everyone sang praises of him. IMO Amla or Michael Clarke or Graeme Smith are all better than him.

[The Outsider]

See' date=' it's not about averages. It's about blind hate. Otherwise no one compares a batsman who averages a piddly 30 in FCs with a Test double centurion.[/quote'] Yeah, would be completely crazy to say Atherton with an average in the 30s was a better batsman than Gillespie with a test double hundred.

[Magneto]

Yeah' date=' would be completely crazy to say Atherton with an average in the 30s was a better batsman than Gillespie with a test double hundred.[/quote'] LOL. I am talking about someone who averages 30 in some 70 odd innings in the flat pattas in domestic FCs. Dhoni's double came against Australia, Gillespie's against Bangladesh. It's not just about one odd innings. Dhoni has a 100 in every 20 odd FC innings, Bhuvi has one 100 in his entire batting career of 76 matches. And no, he does not necessarily bat at No.9 in FCs.

[The Outsider]

LOL. I am talking about someone who averages 30 in some 70 odd innings in the flat pattas in domestic FCs. Dhoni's double came against Australia' date=' Gillespie's against Bangladesh. It's not just about one odd innings.[/quote'] Dhoni's double came on the same flat pattas, which are of no relevance to the original topic of this thread.

[Magneto]

Dhoni's double came on the same flat pattas' date=' which are of no relevance to the original topic of this thread.[/quote'] And Bhuvi's 2 Test 50s have come on flat pattas too, where Anderson, Binny, Shami all made merry and scored 50s.

[CSK Fan]

And Bhuvi's 2 Test 50s have come on flat pattas too' date=' where Anderson, Binny, Shami all made merry and scored 50s.[/quote'] Yes, but people were comparing his technique in the first innings here and not those 50. As I said before, no one was looking at the run scored but the quality of those runs and the way he played

[Vilander]

Lol anyone who seriously argues that Dhoni is a worser bat than Bhuv has lost it, Bhuv is a good bat probably better than Ashwin and Rohit but still Dhoni has done more in tests.

[Yoda-esque]

Lol anyone who seriously argues that Dhoni is a worser bat than Bhuv has lost it' date=' Bhuv is a good bat probably better than Ashwin and Rohit but still Dhoni has done more in tests.[/quote'] :D

[The Outsider]

And Bhuvi's 2 Test 50s have come on flat pattas too' date=' where Anderson, Binny, Shami all made merry and scored 50s.[/quote'] Okay, so you think Dhoni is a such a superior batsman to Bhuvneshwar in conditions similar to this match, which is the context of this thread that the comparison is ridiculous then bring points pertinent to that rather than irrelevant garbage like Dhoni's double hundred at home. Gillespie has one away from home.

[CSK Fan]

And Bhuvi's 2 Test 50s have come on flat pattas too' date=' where Anderson, Binny, Shami all made merry and scored 50s.[/quote'] People are talking about this

[Sachin=GOD]

Lol anyone who seriously argues that Dhoni is a worser bat than Bhuv has lost it' date=' [b']Bhuv is a good bat probably better than Ashwin and Rohit but still Dhoni has done more in tests.

Funny.