Jump to content

What should be India's approach on 5th day?


Austin 3:!6

What should be India's approach on 5th day?  

  1. 1.

    • Look to chase the target
    • Play for a draw


Recommended Posts

Posted

Adelaide was the only venue where India could have dreamt of winning a test match but that seems to be a distant dream now. Sitting on 5th day we are looking down the barrell. Chasing 363 on a 5th day turning pitch against a confidence Lyon will never be easy, specially when you have a long tail like this Indian XI has. So how you think Kohli and his boys should approach this? Try to be positive and look to chase this total? Or look to grind out a draw playing whole day? Personally I do not think 2nd option is the best approach as no player in this line up has the capability including skipper Kohli to defend one whole day. Your views?

Posted

Attempt it. The approach can be reassessed after half a session. Though Lyon will be a huge concern. These players are no way near against spin as they think they are. The pitch has enough rough to spread nervousness around the camp.

Posted

If we think we cannot survive one full day defending, then might as well go for the target... Two benefits that I can see :- 1. If we get a bit of luck and top 3 get us to a flier ( 4-5 runs per over ), the fields will be more defensive making it easy to knock singles around and we will be in the match for longer. Then we can make a decision in the last 20 overs depending on where we stand. 2. Even if we fail in the chase ( losing or drawing ), it will create doubts in Clarke's mind on what target is safe...similar case when we had Sehwag in our team...Opposition always had to keep in mind the Sehwag factor and used to declare with target as 370-380 instead of 300. I am sure it would have helped us draw a few matches due to the less no. of overs we had to bat

Posted

The only way they can survive (which they WONT) is: Play normal positive cricket. Respect the good balls, solidly defend them. Take singles when possible, and put away the bad balls. Play normal, but positive cricket and defend and leave the good balls. Dont go into a shell, nor dont go "aggressive kohli-like" CHASING target. Just play normal. Thing is they will NOT do this, the pressure is immense and they will mentally implode. Nathan Lyon (and Harris and MJ) will be a terror with close-in fielders on this pitch.

Posted

If Australia take their lead to 400, forget about winning. If they declare with a lead of 360 then do this. No definite plan is needed. Take it hour by hour, session by session. Essentially try to play for a draw until the goal post is within the striking distance. By tea time, if we are behind by 150 or so runs and have plenty of wickets, may be we have a chance to win.

Posted

leave,leave and just leave.this is a docile pitch,not too difficult to handle the pacers. against lyon the batsmen need to be decisive and commit entirely either on the FF or BF.cant just stay on the pitch and defend.he might produce a shaun udalesque spell tomorrow :nervous:

Posted

I think we will save the test the pitch is flat and its start of tour everybody has got runs and bit of spice today will motivate these guys.

Posted

If Mooli/Chepu can't bat at least 30 overs tmrw forget about winning/drawing. Dhawan is anyways unreliable. Cannot afford to expose our middle order to the new/newish ball. Harris and MJ will be devastating and Lyon too.

Posted
If Mooli/Chepu can't bat at least 30 overs tmrw forget about winning/drawing. Dhawan is anyways unreliable. Cannot afford to expose our middle order to the new/newish ball. Harris and MJ will be devastating and Lyon too.
Its not the new ball but when the ball starts reversing harris and co will be deadly,
Posted

India's approach on day 5's of a test match while under pressure has always been the same and that is to fold meekly. While I don't expect that to change, there is no harm in hoping for an unexpected fight to survive.... There is not a one in a billion chance of them even getting close to this target. So maybe they get 1 good session where they don't lose a wicket and that can help them draw this.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...