Jump to content

What should be the effective batting order for boxing day Test?


Lone Wolf

Recommended Posts

Posted

In my view 

Pujara (to blunt the new ball) 

Mayank

Gill (stroke maker) 

Rahane

jaddu (left hander) 

Vihari

Pant (aggressive  left hander) 

Ashwin

Umesh

Bumrah 

Siraj

 

Posted

It should be decided at the moment based on the stage of the match. If 2nd wicekt falls after 40-45 overs, send in Pant/Jadeja and make sure we can maintain a left-right combo for as long as possible.. if it falls early on, send in vihari

Posted
2 minutes ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

Gill has played most of his FC career as an opener. Let him be the opener.

 

My choice:

Gill, Mayank, Pujara, Jadeja, Rahane, Pant, Ashwin, Umesh, Bumrah, Siraj

 

 

 

In Test cricket Top 3 position is more or less similar.  Both have to face new ball more often than not.  Pujara at 3 doesn't seem right as games goes no where when he's at 3. If he has to blunt the new ball & tire bowlers..  He may as well open making life easier for Gill.  Having two nervous openers to face Aussie pace battery first up is not a great idea tbh. 

Posted
41 minutes ago, Lone Wolf said:

In Test cricket Top 3 position is more or less similar.  Both have to face new ball more often than not.  Pujara at 3 doesn't seem right as games goes no where when he's at 3. If he has to blunt the new ball & tire bowlers..  He may as well open making life easier for Gill.  Having two nervous openers to face Aussie pace battery first up is not a great idea tbh. 

You're saying this about the guy who won us the Test series vs the same set of bowlers on the last tour to Australia! Let him be at peace at number 3 and use the same approach which has got him success so far. He bats for long, we'll do well. It's as simple as that. 

 

And you couldn't more incorrect about top 3 being similar in Tests. Some of the best number 3s in recent test history Sanga, Dravid, Amla, all struggled whenever asked to open

Posted
1 hour ago, ShoonyaSifar said:

You're saying this about the guy who won us the Test series vs the same set of bowlers on the last tour to Australia! Let him be at peace at number 3 and use the same approach which has got him success so far. He bats for long, we'll do well. It's as simple as that. 

 

And you couldn't more incorrect about top 3 being similar in Tests. Some of the best number 3s in recent test history Sanga, Dravid, Amla, all struggled whenever asked to open

Take a look at Pujara's record since that series 2 years back..  He is no way near his best.  About time we stop giving those games too much  importance.  Recent form matters as well.  

Posted

Gill

Mayank

Pujara

Rahane

Pant

KL Rahul

Jadeja

Ashwin

Umesh

Bumrah

Siraj

 

Only reason Pant at 5 instead of 6 is to split up the two left handlers.

Posted

M Agarwal

H Vihari

C Pujara

S Gill

A Rahane

R Jadeja

R Pant

R Ashwin

U Yadav

J Bumrah

M Siraj

 

The likely person under pressure for his spot is H Vihari, he should open. It may free him up and has opened before.

 

Rohit will be back from 3rd Test if Vihari fails either at opening or middle order.

 

S Gill has scored 3 double hundreds in his first class career, 2 have been at Number 4 & Number 5 against New Zealnad A and West Indies A, prefer him at Number 4. 

 

Posted

If India does not manage to draw or win the second Test against Australia then it will be the first time in their 88 years of a Test playing nation that they will lose all matches in a calendar year (minimum 3 Tests).

We somehow gotta show some fight.  9 outta 10 times we will lose.  But Rahane needs to win the toss somehow  to even the odds. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...