Tabraiz Shamsi vs Kuldeep Yadav

[maniac]

2 left arm chinamen bowlers.

 

Kuldeep was supposed to be the next big star spinner for India, had a tremendous run and then saw decline

 

Shamsi on the other hand has been around for a while but now he is the no.1 T20 spinner in the world.

 

stats wise and body of work wise Kuldeep is way ahead however watching Shamsi bowl recently he might be a handful in UAE in WT20.

 

Can Kuldeep be given another chance or is Shamsi the next big mystery spinner.

 

Who will have a better career going forward?

 

[Lone Wolf]

Sandakan I thought had massive potential bowls at good pace & his googly dips & can beat batsman in flight. 

Kuldeep has lost confidence & barely able to land the ball in same spot. 

Shamsi has improved leaps n bounds. 

 

These three are the prominent left arm wrist spinners currently. 

The Afghan one hasn't played much. 

[Ankit_sharma03]

Was thinking on same lines of making a thread on them. Shamsi has improved massively 

IPL contract on the way as well, MI shud target him

[Ankit_sharma03]

 

great bowling

 

[Lord]

as a wrist spinner you need to be mentally tough which Kuldeep isnt.Needs to work on it.

 

Shamsi is nothing special though

[Ankit_sharma03]

 

[Ankit_sharma03]

 

Performance after performance 

[nitinbwj]

Picked up 3 wickets today

[maniac]

On 7/8/2021 at 6:34 AM, Lord said:

as a wrist spinner you need to be mentally tough which Kuldeep isnt.Needs to work on it.

 

Shamsi is nothing special though

Still feel the same way?

[Serpico]

Tabi Raju Shamsi

[Lord]

30 minutes ago, maniac said:

Still feel the same way?

 

What has changed?You want me to rate him for doing well vs Irish?

 

Its an era of poor batsmen against spin and yet he's not well vs England and India,two top teams.Rest are rubbish.And that's just T20.

 

In ODIs his record is average still.

 

I suppose he'll be picked up in IPL next year.Will be interesting,as he was rubbish last time he played for RCB

 

Still well ahead of current Kuldeep though.

 

 

[Sean Bradley]

Both are Trash, Shamsi is better on current form. 

Edited July 23, 2021 by Sean Bradley

[Ankit_sharma03]

On 7/23/2021 at 12:37 AM, Lord said:

What has changed?You want me to rate him for doing well vs Irish?

He performed against pak n wi also. 

 

What has changed ?? His lengths n control. 

He is in the slot most times where batsman doesnt knw if to go on front foot or back.

 

Earlier it was 1-2 good balls and then filth. 

If u see the video comparison n notice the diff starts from run. Shamsi is relaxed n in rhythem . 

 

Kuldeep also bowled against trash sl but wass hardly effective

[Lord]

9 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

He performed against pak n wi also. 

 

What has changed ?? His lengths n control. 

He is in the slot most times where batsman doesnt knw if to go on front foot or back.

 

Earlier it was 1-2 good balls and then filth. 

If u see the video comparison n notice the diff starts from run. Shamsi is relaxed n in rhythem . 

 

Kuldeep also bowled against trash sl but wass hardly effective

 

I meant from the time of my original post

 

Already said hes well ahead of Kuldeep.

 

WI generally dont play thier full side due to disputes and all.Even Kuldeep has done well vs them IIRC

[Lone Wolf]

9 hours ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

He performed against pak n wi also. 

 

What has changed ?? His lengths n control. 

He is in the slot most times where batsman doesnt knw if to go on front foot or back.

 

Earlier it was 1-2 good balls and then filth. 

If u see the video comparison n notice the diff starts from run. Shamsi is relaxed n in rhythem . 

 

Kuldeep also bowled against trash sl but wass hardly effective

I saw Fakhar taking him into cleaners in an ODI..  He has good form on his side but he ain't that special. 

Teams like England Australia will put him to sword.  That being said he is surely not the worst out there. 

Rashid K > Hasaranga> A Rashid> Zampa>Sodhi=Shamsi