Was ponting better than sachin in odis?

[Trichromatic]

4 minutes ago, King6 said:

Due to longevity? 

 

He didn't get rated after retirement. He was rated best even before halfway of his career.

 

No one knew that longevity was a factor in 2001 or 2005.

 

 

[cricketfan28]

2 minutes ago, King6 said:

Due to longevity? 

Pressure, the pressure on sachin was immense, ponting had nothing like that in comparison.

Pressure on sachin was very  high and we will never know how someone like ponting might have responded to  that, he is also human.

[RJman]

It's simple.

 

Australia have won 6 world cups.

 

So their batsmen, bowlers, captain, allrounders, managers, coach, fielders, ballboy, champiwallah etc  ALL OF THEM are better than anyone from any other country.

 

AUSTRALIA is the supreme team in the World and their players are GOAT. All other countrymen are at least 2 tiers below any Australian cricketer.

 

 

 

[Haarkarjeetgaye]

On 11/22/2023 at 4:54 AM, AKane said:

This is a team game, you are supposed to play for the team results. Rest is all noise. For some of us. For some 49 hundreds and 50 hundreds matter. Different strokes for different folks.

 

Apne andar daal le centuries. Nahi chahiye hamein

[srgadjon]

Who cares how many centuries, records, averages Sachin has ? Australia won 6 World cups, India only 2. This is what matters, not your bloody records which you can shove where the doesnt shine.

 

[DeepSpace]

Screw Ponting and Tendu. Babbar-e-Hajam is Bradman, the mother of all goats!!! Just ask Rameez.

[raki05]

On 11/21/2023 at 10:42 PM, King6 said:

Please share

Yes with 76 sr ponting was better player than Sachin.

[singhvivek141]

Ponting was only better than Sachin from 2003-2007, everywhere else Sachin beats him comprehensively.

[King6]

41 minutes ago, raki05 said:

Yes with 76 sr ponting was better player than Sachin.

Ponting sr is 80

[King6]

7 minutes ago, singhvivek141 said:

Ponting was only better than Sachin from 2003-2007, everywhere else Sachin beats him comprehensively.

In 2000s decade there isn't much difference between them

[raki05]

1 minute ago, King6 said:

Ponting sr is 80

Still 6 point below sachin’s SR and there is difference of 100 match around between them. So even in that era when rest all Indian batters were playing some 70-75 sr sachin’s SR was 86. Now compare ponting SR with some of his own  teammates like Gilchrist , Hayden, Martin, Slater.

[King6]

12 minutes ago, raki05 said:

Still 6 point below sachin’s SR and there is difference of 100 match around between them. So even in that era when rest all Indian batters were playing some 70-75 sr sachin’s SR was 86. Now compare ponting SR with some of his own  teammates like Gilchrist , Hayden, Martin, Slater.

Bat avg In away 

 

vs NZ - Sachin 39 - Ponting 49

vs Pak - Sachin 37  - Ponting 97

Vs SA - Sachin 25 - Ponting 44

vs SL - Sachin 41 - Ponting 45

vs Eng - Sachin 40 - Ponting 44

vs WI - Sachin 54 - Ponting 27

vs aus - Sachin 31   vs Ind - ponting 47

 

Sachin stats inflated due to most matches played in Asia.. 

Edited November 28, 2023 by King6

[raki05]

14 minutes ago, King6 said:

Bat avg In away 

 

vs NZ - Sachin 39 - Ponting 49

vs Pak - Sachin 37  - Ponting 97

Vs SA - Sachin 25 - Ponting 44

vs SL - Sachin 41 - Ponting 45

vs Eng - Sachin 40 - Ponting 44

vs WI - Sachin 54 - Ponting 27

vs aus - Sachin 31   vs Ind - ponting 47

 

Sachin stats inflated due to most matches played in Asia.. 

lol india wasn’t getting tours like today… Compare to that aus was getting more abroad tour.

[King6]

@raki05

Outside Asia 

Sachin avg - 40.7 sr - 82 (away) 

Ponting avg - 42.7 sr - 82.7

 

Outside Oceania continent (aus+nz) 

 

Ponting avg - 43.4 sr - 80 (away) 

Edited November 28, 2023 by King6

[King6]

10 minutes ago, raki05 said:

lol india wasn’t getting tours like today… Compare to that aus was getting more abroad tour.

Sachin played 175 matches in out side Asia

[singhvivek141]

1 hour ago, King6 said:

In 2000s decade there isn't much difference between them

From Sachin's debut till 31 Dec 2002

Sachin : Avg 44.40, SR 86.56

Ponting : Avg 41.43, SR 76.50

 

From 01 Jan 2003 to 31 Dec 2007

Sachin : Avg 44.6, SR 82.84

Ponting : Avg 47.8, SR 85.3

 

From 01 Jan 2008 till retirement

Sachin : Avg 48.xx, SR 91.xx

Ponting : Avg 35.xx, SR 79.29

 

Ponting has only upper hand in between 2003-07.

[raki05]

2 hours ago, King6 said:

@raki05

Outside Asia 

Sachin avg - 40.7 sr - 82 (away) 

Ponting avg - 42.7 sr - 82.7

 

Outside Oceania continent (aus+nz) 

 

Ponting avg - 43.4 sr - 80 (away) 

I have seen both play since start of their career till end and i know whom to choose if i would like one to play for me. No because Sachin is Indian, Australia have produced so many great batter and i know for sure i wont choose Ponting for my odi team if i have to choose one from aus.

[mishra]

On 11/21/2023 at 5:11 PM, Mariyam said:

Stats is for em nerds.

 

Sample answer: NO.

 

Shall provide a detailed statistical treatise later.

Think , I saw a podcast on Yuvi. He said, Bhai Australians were different beast alltogether. Do your best, sab kuchh shaee hai, but still you loose. You have hit a wall.

 

Sachin and Lara were two players who during there time were only ones , gave their Team a chance against Aussies.

 

As far as Stats are concerned, People need to compare stats of Pakistani batters against England in England. Most likely on average, Pakistani batters have done better than Indian batters