Tiger80 Posted June 20, 2012 Author Posted June 20, 2012 Pinki Pramanik's gender test inconclusive Kolkata: The gender of Asian Games gold medalist Pinki Pramanik could not be established at the Barasat General Hospital on Tuesday as it did not have the facilities, and the case was sought to be referred to the better equipped SSKM Hospital in Kolkata. "There was ambiguity in the reports we got. We don't have the facilities for chromosome and hormone tests. We did the ultrasonography, but all the tests could not be done", Chief Medical Officer of North 24 Parganas district Dr Sukanta Sil said after Pramanik's medical tests lasting about three hours. X-ray, scan and blood samples could not be taken because of lack of proper facilities at the Barasat General Hospital, where the athlete was taken. "We are making a plea to the chief judicial magistrate that the case should be referred to the SSKM Hospital. Being the state's referral hospital, SSKM has better facilities. So the tests should be done there", said Sil who headed a seven-member medical team. The report has to be submitted to the court by June 29. Pramanik is in judicial custody accused of rape and of being 'male'. Pramanik, who won the 4x400m relay gold in the Doha Asian Games 2010, was arrested on June 14 after being accused of multiple sexual assault and misrepresentation of gender by a 30-year-old estranged woman who had a live-in relationship with the athlete for two years. The middle distance runner, who had won five gold medals and one silver between 2005 and 2006, officially retired the next year, but there were reports that the athlete was not allowed in a Madurai national meet because of 'excessive male hormones'. http://ibnlive.in.com/news/pinki-pramaniks-gender-test-inconclusive/266878-3.html
vvvslaxman Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 Let us assume Pinki is a male. He made a promie he would marry her. Based on that he had a consensual sex with that girl. He didn't marry her. How is that a rape? http://legalfighter.wordpress.com/2009/12/01/is-it-a-crime-to-have-a-relationship-under-pretext-of-marriage/
CSK Fan Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 Let us assume Pinki is a male. He made a promie he would marry her. Based on that he had a consensual sex with that girl. He didn't marry her. How is that a rape? http://legalfighter.wordpress.com/2009/12/01/is-it-a-crime-to-have-a-relationship-under-pretext-of-marriage/ Having sex under false promise is rape under Indian laws
vvvslaxman Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 Having sex under false promise is rape under Indian laws i think very few countries have that law. It makes no sense in this age and era where i know for a fact girls take advantage of guys as well.
CSK Fan Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 Pinki Pramanik's gender test inconclusive Kolkata: The gender of Asian Games gold medalist Pinki Pramanik could not be established at the Barasat General Hospital on Tuesday as it did not have the facilities, and the case was sought to be referred to the better equipped SSKM Hospital in Kolkata. "There was ambiguity in the reports we got. We don't have the facilities for chromosome and hormone tests. We did the ultrasonography, but all the tests could not be done", Chief Medical Officer of North 24 Parganas district Dr Sukanta Sil said after Pramanik's medical tests lasting about three hours. X-ray, scan and blood samples could not be taken because of lack of proper facilities at the Barasat General Hospital, where the athlete was taken. "We are making a plea to the chief judicial magistrate that the case should be referred to the SSKM Hospital. Being the state's referral hospital, SSKM has better facilities. So the tests should be done there", said Sil who headed a seven-member medical team. The report has to be submitted to the court by June 29. Pramanik is in judicial custody accused of rape and of being 'male'. Pramanik, who won the 4x400m relay gold in the Doha Asian Games 2010, was arrested on June 14 after being accused of multiple sexual assault and misrepresentation of gender by a 30-year-old estranged woman who had a live-in relationship with the athlete for two years. The middle distance runner, who had won five gold medals and one silver between 2005 and 2006, officially retired the next year, but there were reports that the athlete was not allowed in a Madurai national meet because of 'excessive male hormones'. http://ibnlive.in.com/news/pinki-pramaniks-gender-test-inconclusive/266878-3.html What facilities is needed to check for a pen!s?
CSK Fan Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 i think very few countries have that law. It makes no sense in this age and era where i know for a fact girls take advantage of guys as well. Oh yes, I completely agree. There are so many relationships which take a turn for worse after 1-2 years yet the guy cannot break up or change his mind because he earlier promised marriage. A woman's position is still equated with sex
Needforspeed Posted June 20, 2012 Posted June 20, 2012 What facilities is needed to check for a pen!s? Yeah, Either he/she/it has it or doesn't. One who doesn't have a **** cannot rape. :dontknow:
Lord Posted June 21, 2012 Posted June 21, 2012 Yeah' date=' Either he/she/it has it or doesn't. One who doesn't have a **** cannot rape. :dontknow:[/quote'] ofcourse he can.havent u seen a rape in bollywood movies
rkt.india Posted June 22, 2012 Posted June 22, 2012 What facilities is needed to check for a pen!s? :haha:
Crookbond Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 Pinki Pramanik released from jail after 25 days Before getting into a car and driving off the 26-year-old said, "I have been framed and the woman is still trying to fix me." That woman is Pinki's 30-year-old live-in partner who has alleged that Pinki is a man who raped her. The retired middle-distance runner was arrested on June 14. The judge at the North 24 Parganas district court, while granting bail to Pinki yesterday, had observed that Section 376 of the Indian Penal Code, which deals with rape could not be applied in the case. He granted bail on a surety of Rs. 5000. So apt! http://sports.ndtv.com/othersports/athletics/item/193324-pinki-pramanik-released-after-spending-25-days-in-jail
CSK Fan Posted July 11, 2012 Posted July 11, 2012 http://ibnlive.in.com/news/mms-of-pinkis-alleged-gender-test-goes-viral-online/269058-3.html Even as Asiad gold medallist runner Pinki Pramanik fights a legal battle after accused of being a male and arrested for alleged rape, a video showing the athlete completely naked and undergoing tests at a private nursing home has gone viral online. The 29-second clip was reportedly circulated after Pinki underwent a gender verification test at a private nursing home in North 24 Parganas district where the sprinter was taken subsequent to her arrest June 14. "I have heard about the video clip, though I am yet to see it. Those responsible for making the clip must be immediately arrested for such a heinous act. The matter needs to be reported to the police but at the moment Pinki is behind bars and no one from her family is available to file a report," Pinki's counsel Tuhin Roy said. :WTF:
Crookbond Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 I'm not sure why would people like to see a she-male. :dontknow:
DomainK Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 The way I see it, she is sitting on a gold mine at the moment. Apart from suing the woman who accused her/him of rape for defamation and a bunch of other charges, she has a number of cases against the government including the MMS that was recorded and leaked while in custody. If she ha proper counsel, she should emerge a millionaire out of this.
Crookbond Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 The way I see it' date=' she is sitting on a gold mine at the moment. Apart from suing the woman who accused her/him of rape for defamation and a bunch of other charges, she has a number of cases against the government including the MMS that was recorded and leaked while in custody.[b'] If she ha proper counsel, she should emerge a millionaire out of this. When was the last time someone won a libel in India against the government?
punjabi_khota Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 The way I see it' date=' she is sitting on a gold mine at the moment. Apart from suing the woman who accused her/him of rape for defamation and a bunch of other charges, she has a number of cases against the government including the MMS that was recorded and leaked while in custody. If she ha proper counsel, she should emerge a millionaire out of this.[/quote'] Do these defamation/libel cases ever get a result in India ? I have probably never heard of any such case ever going anywhere after the initial hoopla.
coffee_rules Posted July 12, 2012 Posted July 12, 2012 When was the last time someone won a libel in India against the government? http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_rs-1-crore-for-medical-neglect_1256190 He is a cousin of my wife. He died of brain hemorrhage in 2011. After fighting for 20 years they won this case in the Supreme court of India. He died a year after they won the case. He was rendered paraplegic due to medical negligence in 1989 and wheelchair bound for 22 years of his prime life.
Crookbond Posted July 13, 2012 Posted July 13, 2012 http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report_rs-1-crore-for-medical-neglect_1256190 He is a cousin of my wife. He died of brain hemorrhage in 2011. After fighting for 20 years they won this case in the Supreme court of India. He died a year after they won the case. He was rendered paraplegic due to medical negligence in 1989 and wheelchair bound for 22 years of his prime life. I have heard about it and empathize with your family but this doesn't count as libel.
Recommended Posts