Who is the best wicketkeeper-batsman REVISED

[Lord]

who the f is Kushal Janith Parera:fear:

[vvvslaxman]

What did Jimmy Say??

http://www.cricketcountry.com/cricket-articles/Mohinder-Amarnath-s-demand-for-MS-Dhoni-s-sacking-Error-of-perception-or-just-prejudice/23507

[SLICKR392]

Mods please make the poll public.

[carnish]

Wow many teams have crap keepers :haha:..Seriously Dinesh karthik is much better than many guys in that list .. except sanga abd and dhoni..

Sanga doesnot keep anymore in tests.

[carnish]

http://www.cricketcountry.com/cricket-articles/Mohinder-Amarnath-s-demand-for-MS-Dhoni-s-sacking-Error-of-perception-or-just-prejudice/23507

Now I know that even if removed from the selection panel, why he is not picked up by ESS team for commentary as I believe he is a very good hindi commentator. He has angered the BCCI bosses. :giggle:

[Mahaa Raavana]

Voted for MSD...Without a doubt he is the best WKB at the moment...

[vvvslaxman]

would vote for ABDV. But it is cheating :hitler: He is an A grade specialist batsman who is made into a keeper.

[putrevus]

I would want Prior as WK batsman in my team. ABDV is just started so it is not yet fair to include him, he is hand down best batsman of the lot.

[indiaregulator]

Having Prior as WK keeper isn't really fair is it now. It's like England training Pietersen (who is an excellent slip fielder) to be a WK and then proclaiming to the world that he is the best WK/Batsman in the business and on par with Gilchrist at winning matches.

[Junyfan]

some strange names Indeed,

[Old guy]

Having Prior as WK keeper isn't really fair is it now. It's like England training Pietersen (who is an excellent slip fielder) to be a WK and then proclaiming to the world that he is the best WK/Batsman in the business and on par with Gilchrist at winning matches.

only problem is peitersen can never keep as well as abdv kept so in the end he is just as good as any other keeper out there and on top of that is world class batsman... if there was problem with his keeping then complain but he has been safer then prior

[indiaregulator]

Yeah sorry typo I meant ABDV. It still remains to be seen whether ABDV can keep up his glovework. Kamran Akmal was excellent prior to 2007 and then he made clanger after clanger. Prior hasn't made a mistake in a long time, despite playing his past year or so in subcontinental conditions where he has had to face more spin.

[Muloghonto]

ABDV does not qualify. he has clearly stated that he is a stop-gap wicket keeper, has hardly any experience keeping wickets and as such, should be given atleast 20-30 tests to evaluate. Rating ABDV as a wicket-keeper is as ridiculous as rating Rahul Dravid as a wicket keeper.

[Square Drive]

Is it for test, ODIs or T20? Incomplete players list.. where is Chandimals and Akmals? Can't vote :headshake: The poll/thread is not up to the standard.

[tweaker]

a b devillers

[Vanarp22]

No Gilchrist, are you ****ing kidding me? Not keeping him in the list makes this a :fail: poll

I said RIGHT NOW

[Square Drive]

who the f is Kushal Janith Parera:fear:

You can see his last 1st class innings here; http://www.espncricinfo.com/sri-lanka-domestic-2012/engine/current/match/590792.html Already the next Jayasuriya according to some SL fans :giggle:

[SLICKR392]

Adnan is the middle one and Umar is the youngest Akmal. There are too many Akmals.

And all are WKs? :cantstop: Adnan is a jolly good guy. Not bad with the gloves either compared to his sibs.

[Swing_n_Speed]

Always Dhoni for me. And how do we know he's that good? Check out his trophy cabinet.

[Texan]

ABDV