who is best dhoni or sangakara?

[koksmayu]

who is best dhoni or sanga?

[Muloghonto]

Pretty obvious if you ask me. As a batsman, Sanga. As a keeper, Dhoni. Sanga was a good ol 'first slipper turned into wiket keeper' experiment, ala Dravid. Helped that he'd kept at kids level. Does not make him a keeper.

[vamos_rafa]

Tests- Sangakara hands down. ODIs- Well depends, what role you want. Sangakara is a far far more accomplished bat, but Dhoni's the ultimate finsher.

[surajmal]

Tests- Sangakara hands down. ODIs- Well depends, what role you want. Sangakara is a far far more accomplished bat, but Dhoni's the ultimate finsher.

ODIs - It is Phoni hands down. Guy is going to go down as the best ODI player ever.

[Muloghonto]

ODIs - It is Phoni hands down. Guy is going to go down as the best ODI player ever.

He can. If he does another 100 ODIs at this rate, then i say move over Tendu and Richards, here is Dhoni as #1 alltime. But as it stands now, he is one of the top 10 ODI bats ever and an automatic consideration for alltime ODI world team alongside Gillchrist (due to the fact that Gilly opened, it does make him fit around differently than Dhoni).

[surajmal]

He can. If he does another 100 ODIs at this rate' date=' then i say move over Tendu and Richards, here is Dhoni as #1 alltime. But as it stands now, he is one of the top 10 ODI bats ever and an automatic consideration for alltime ODI world team alongside Gillchrist (due to the fact that Gilly opened, it does make him fit around differently than Dhoni).[/quote'] Guy has got an ego the size of empire state. He will retire from tests to focus on ODIs. Watch. He wants to be considered as the ATG.

[Junyfan]

sanga is great test batsman ,no comparison(he does not keep)

[Pagalpanti]

Test - Sanga OD - Dhoni Both better than each other by miles in the respective formats

[G_B_]

test Sangakarra odi Dhoni t20 hmm both suck

[vvvslaxman]

ofcourse whingakkara in tests. He is a good test batsman.

[I6MTW]

Dhoni is a better keeper in both formats. Tests: Sanga ODI: Dhoni.

[Sidhoni]

Sanga isn't the keeper in tests :dontknow:

[Crookbond]

In terms of stumper I think Dhoni wins hands down.

[adi B]

whats the criteria?

[Sean Bradley]

Dhoni as a overall package.

[Sidhoni]

Dhoni wins without any doubt in ODIs. And in tests, Sangakarra isn't a WKB so he doesn't qualify if you are comparing two wicket keepers.

[SLICKR392]

Whinga as a batsman in Test cricket...

[Number]

If you are comparing Sanga the batsman with Dhoni then lol.

[Executioner]

Sangakkara as a batsman is much better than Dhoni. Sangakkara is one of the best Test batsman of all time, Dhoni on the other hand is ordinary in tests. In ODIs, Dhoni is the better player and has an average of 50. High average is a courtesy of not-outs but still an excellent finisher Dhoni is. Sangakkara has a near 40 average in ODIs so not a big margin in ODIs. In T20s, sangakkara is slightly better than Dhoni as he has had some noticable performances in the T20 WCs. If you ask me, who is the better WK-batsman, then i will go with Dhoni who is a regular and brilliant keeper who can bat as well. If you ask me about batsman, then sanga wins hands down

[carnish]

Sangakkara ... better batsman overall. ODIs .... Dhoni wins but not by a huge margin Tests... I wont say ... people know it already.