If there is one batsman who doesn't deserve a place in Indian team, it is..

[Zanjeer]

......... ..... ..... Complete the sentence....yep, yep..that's him.... Sucks at overseas conditions...:haha:

[Sidhoni]

I am guessing you mean Dhoni. In that case, it would help if you come across this concept of a wicketkeeper in cricket. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wicket-keeper Now you have edited your post which earlier hinted at Dhoni, just proving what a loser you are.

[Tom Riddle]

Murali Vijay. kick that scum out of the team

[vamos_rafa]

Murali Vijay. kick that scum out of the team

This.

[ThePhenomenal1]

Dhoni still hung in there but once again, that triggered a collapse. the tail needs to strengthen. That's my issue, our tail just gives up.

[CG]

Dhoni is indias most experienced batsman and its his third tour of Sa.

[HouMac]

Dhoni should NEVER be in surviving mode, because he just doesn't have the technique to survive long. Might as well go out playing your game. At least he would score some quick runs that way. I was cringing when he was blocking every ball this morning. Knew it was only a matter of time before he fell without adding anything to the score. This morning's collapse primarily falls on his shoulders.

[asterix]

I told you guys yesterday that he's not a recognised Test WK/Batsman... The tail starts from him and he should be ashamed of that....He should be playing Test matches and should've vacated his place for a competent WK/Batsman...

[rkt.india]

I told you guys yesterday that he's not a recognised Test WK/Batsman... The tail starts from him and he should be ashamed of that....He should be playing Test matches and should've vacated his place for a competent WK/Batsman...

Who is that?

[Switchblade]

Who is that?

Saha ?

[Gunner]

Dhoni's good enough to be in the test team as a wicket-keeper batsman. It's his captaincy and selection that deserve criticism.

[Trichromatic]

Saha ?

:hysterical:

[Switchblade]

:hysterical:

Thats what I thought asterix was talking about he may have wanted Saha instead of MS

[jf1gp_1]

Saha ?

:hysterical: Saha is what mohit sharma was before people saw him bowl Kartik is the only one who comes close but Dhoni is a better keeper than both kartik and patel.

[putrevus]

just because you think you dont have anyone better you continue with a batsmen who is almost a tailender. you try new player if you think old one is never going to get better and it looks like we have that case here.

[NareshK]

Saha is a better batsman than Dhoni ? :hysterical: Goes to show the stupidity of some of the posters here.

[Switchblade]

Saha is a better batsman than Dhoni ? :hysterical: Goes to show the stupidity of some of the posters here.

I did not say that he is a better batsman than MS I just thought that asterix wanted Saha to be in the side as he is in the 17 man squad.

[Zanjeer]

I would love to bring in a youngster like sanju Samson. Yes, he isn't a regular keeper, but from what I have seen he is a very good keeper and a very talented batsman..

[NareshK]

I would love to bring in a youngster like sanju Samson. Yes' date= he isn't a regular keeper, but from what I have seen he is a very good keeper and a very talented batsman..

I'm glad you are not in charge of making that decision. Watch IPL and leave test cricket for others.

[jf1gp_1]

I would love to bring in a youngster like sanju Samson. Yes' date=' he isn't a regular keeper, but from what I have seen he is a very good keeper and a very talented batsman..[/quote'] Werent you a big time supporter of bringing in Mohit sharma asap to test setup ?