Jump to content

Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy 2017


tweaker

Recommended Posts

Posted
14 minutes ago, renjith said:

technically as well kishan looks better. pants batting looks heavily leg side oriented. he also showed some weakness outside offstump in the under 19 worldcup. if he comes in top 3 at international level. top quality bowlers soon will exploit his weakness outside offstump. anyways he is not going to fix that issue playing domestics as domestic bowlers does not seem to give any sort of challenge for him. playing aways tours with A team under dravid looks the best option for him.

Kishan was hopeless outside off stump in U19 WC. Pant was far better. Pant is just getting carried away due to his reputation.

Posted
1 minute ago, beetle said:

@sscomp32Congrats ....tumhari east Zone wins and Ishan does well.

Mithai khilao.:biggrin:

LOL Thanks. To be honest he is the only bright light for me in this squad. Rest all are either not good enough or veterans. If he fails it will be tough for them to compete. 

 

Good to see him play a match winning knock :cheer: 

Posted
10 minutes ago, MultiB48 said:

 

 

 

 

technically not the best,but then there is hardly anyone to guide them at state levels due to the lack of int cricketers /capita in india ,you need a bunch of int pacers to look at junior level pacers in each state and then develop them

See Dinda came from a unprvileged background , but he came into A tours and in scheme for India squad at a youngish age along with IPL, we had NCA, MRF academy, IPL has excellent coaching team also it's a personal initiative if you wanna make it to the next level , once you debut at you g age you can evaluate n work on what needs to be done to achieve success at next level, Akhtar did it , Zak did it, you no your body best, also it's your trade, these days all tools are available, recording, analysts, materials, consultants, be your own council n guide , he lacked one thing most n that was belief to belong at that level.

In a different way Munaf was more talented and had more potential came from. Poor back ground n rural area but was unlucky to have Chappelle as coach, Munaf under Kumble n Virat could have been a diff story.

The one thing besides talent which separates the has been to successful players is a fanatical desire to make it to next level n be successfully, do everything it takes to belong, succeed, confident.

Posted
4 minutes ago, sscomp32 said:

LOL Thanks. To be honest he is the only bright light for me in this squad. Rest all are either not good enough or veterans. If he fails it will be tough for them to compete. 

 

Good to see him play a match winning knock :cheer: 

sayan Ghosh is another guy to keep an eye on.

Posted
13 minutes ago, rkt.india said:

Kishan was hopeless outside off stump in U19 WC. Pant was far better. Pant is just getting carried away due to his reputation.

yes I remember kishan as well strugling outside off stump in u19 wc. personally i felt kishans defence a bit more stronger. may be coz pant does not care to defend any ball.

comparitively pant looks heavily legside oriented player. something like ganguly on offside. 

Posted
28 minutes ago, beetle said:

Pant came much  later with few overs left .Had to make the most of the balls left.

It was the same in today's match too. I am not saying that he is not a good player. But just need to cut down the aerial shots

Posted
1 minute ago, sscomp32 said:

He didn't play the regionals so he did not join in the zonal tournament. Much better to allow a youngster rather than wasting a spot. 

Wonder why he wasn't as thoughtful to give up on his test captaincy and overstayed by 3 miserable years or more n selector who wanted to fire him was fired by Srini, those three years cost us dearly

Posted

Watching the replay and commentators are somewhat right. Kishan is ready to wait and picks which delivery to hit. Pant is just a ball 1 slogger and does not wait enough. sometimes you need to wait. 

Posted (edited)

Both Kishan and Pant seem more interested in hitting 6s than 4s.

 

It is possible that both slog the ball more often than they play cricketing shots.

 

Ofcourse, I have never seen Pant in a FC match and it is possible that he plays differently there

Edited by express bowling
Posted
Posted
7 minutes ago, sscomp32 said:

Watching the replay and commentators are somewhat right. Kishan is ready to wait and picks which delivery to hit. Pant is just a ball 1 slogger and does not wait enough. sometimes you need to wait. 

Probably the hype is getting to Pant but i dont think hes a ball one slogger otherwise he wouldnt have been this consistent.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...