Wisden-CricViz ODI and T20 MVPs of the Century

[Tibarn]

I figured since I made a thread for the Test MVPs from their magazine, I would make one for limited overs as well. I can post the whole list for these two because they simply put all 30 on a single page with no individualized analysis. 

 

Here is the ODI list

Indian players 

Virat #6

Jaddu #19

Sachin #22

Irfan #23

 

These rankings are pretty strange: Flintoff as the MVP of the century 

 

Here are the T20 rankings: these aren't exclusively international, so take it with a grain of salt. They include IPL, BB, etc in it, so some of the travelling mercenaries might have their ratings over-inflated, IMO.

  

Bumrah comes in #2

BK #15

 

[Gollum]

ODI rankings look absurd. 

[zen]

 I am surprised that they are still doing this  

 

Anyways, for those who want to make claims based on this:

 

• Kohli fans can claim Kohli > Sachin
• Sachin fans can claim, Sachin > Dhoni (not on the list) 
• Jadeja fans can claim, Jadeja > Sachin 
• Irfan fans can claim, Irfan = Sachin 
• Gilchrist, Bevan, Ponting, Rohit, etc not in the list, so no claims 
• Misbah fans

 

 

Edited August 23, 2020 by zen

[Tibarn]

Here is a blurb which should be considered, regarding CricViz's model, basically: All-rounders are the only players who affect the game during both phases. 

 

As cricket starts using more of these data analytics, the view of the importance of all-rounders will increase, while specialists, either pure batsmen or pure bowlers, will decrease.    

[Gollum]

Dabur Amla is the most low impact, nonsense ODI batsman of all time. He is at #9. Kallis at #10, another mediocre ODI player. 

 

Jaddu above SRT, Vaas, Hussey, Gayle, Sanga etc in ODIs. Wtf!!!!

Edited August 23, 2020 by Gollum

[SK_IH]

Ravindra Jadeja 

[Ankit_sharma03]

Odi men - chanderpaul, scott styris, jacob oram, jadeja, mathews .....ye kya hai

 

I think its just adding contributions thts why a.r like oram, jaddu, irfan, mathews, styris are there....who batted, took wkts.

[Gollum]

34 minutes ago, Ankit_sharma03 said:

Odi men - chanderpaul, scott styris, jacob oram, jadeja, mathews .....ye kya hai

 

I think its just adding contributions thts why a.r like oram, jaddu, irfan, mathews, styris are there....who batted, took wkts.

Can't find Jayasuriya, Dilshan, Aravinda, Warne, Ponting, Gilly, Symonds, Donald, Klusener, MSD, Yuvi, Rohit, Guptill, Baz, Bond, Stokes, Buttler etc.

 

Misbah is the only guy from Pak. Forget Ws, Anwar, Inzi, Moyo, Saqlain, Afridi....even Gul, Amir, Razzaq were far better ODI players than him.